The middle-class tenants of Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village
in New York City are trying once again to take ownership of their
apartment complex. And they are asking for help from an institutional
investor that once bet against them.
The iconic, 110-building complex, which includes the two adjoining
developments, went into foreclosure earlier this year. That was because
real estate giant Tishman Speyer, along with BlackRock Realty and other investors, defaulted on debt they took on in 2006 from their controversial, $5.4 billion purchase of the buildings from Metropolitan Life.
Tishman's business plan for the complex was based on converting
rent-controlled apartments into market-rate apartments. This raised the
ire of many middle-class New Yorkers who saw Stuy Town, as it's known,
as an oasis of affordability in a notoriously high rental market.
Now, the tenants association is hoping to purchase the complex. To do that, they need investors -- and they are asking CalPERS, the huge California employees pension system that bet against them as an investor in the 2006 purchase, to join forces.
Is this a historic case of a power to the people, or simply a marriage
of convenience? And if successful, would this maneuver inspire others
in ailing rental complexes around the country to take matters into
their own hands?
CalPERS, which lost $500 million in the foreclosure, recently announced that it was wrong
to invest in the original purchase; going forward, the fund said, it
will only invest in real estate that protects tenants of
rent-controlled apartments.
Daniel Garodnick, the New
York City council member whose district includes the complex, said, "We
appreciate their new policy, which is why we invited them to come back
and talk to us about a tenant-sponsored plan."
In a letter
to CalPERS Chief Executive Anne Stausboll, he wrote that the new
investment "would send a message to the investment community that you
are serious -- and it would help end the uncertainty about the future
of our homes." CalPERS has not yet responded to the May 12 request.
The investors overestimated how quickly they would be able to turn
rent-controlled apartments into market-rate apartments. And few
expected the downturn in the real estate market. That combination did
in the investors.
Garodnick, who is also a lifelong resident of the complex, said, "The
business plan of the last few years [when Tishman owned the buildings]
was premised on the idea that you could get rent-stabilized tenants out
of their apartments at warp speed, and that's why it was so surprising
that CalPERS had participated." After all, he said, "They represent the
working people of California. It's a surprise that they would invest in
a business plan that took direct aim at the working people of New York."
But now that CalPERS has had a change of heart, all is forgiven.
Besides, the pension fund's new policy speaks to exactly what the
tenants association is trying to accomplish by purchasing the complex.
"Our goal is to convert the property into a home-ownership model, while
allowing tenants to stay as renters if they wish," said Garodnick.
"And, to insure the long-term stability of the community, and its
accessability to the middle class."
The tenant association is hoping that this time around, with the help
of potential investors like CalPERS, it will get the opportunity to
finally oversee the iconic property; a chance it lost when it was
outbid by Tishman in 2006. Said Garodnick: "We are looking to make
something positive about what is a very unfortunate and difficult
situation."
While not many apartment complexes are big enough to enlist the help of
a financial giant such as CalPERS, Stuy Town's initiative might inspire
other renters to come together in the name of controlling their own
housing fate.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.