No decision has yet been made, but Telegraph Hill residents Corey Ruda and Michael Barron are embroiled in a controversy with their landlord that could spell eviction for them and lead to a significant impact on the rest of their illustrious neighborhood.
The landlord, David Taylor, surprised the gay couple in late March and announced plans to add on to the living room and decks of their apartment, located on the eastern slope of Telegraph Hill near the Greenwich Street Stairs.
Taylor said that the extensive construction would require Ruda and Barron, both 42, as well as their upstairs neighbor, to vacate the property for as long as six months – in real estate jargon, a capital improvement eviction.
"This proposed project would result in the loss of green space on the hillside that supports beautiful old trees, wildlife, and provides privacy between neighbors," Ruda wrote in an op-ed piece in the Bay Area Reporter last month. He added that the property would become "a McMansion, with a Disneyland facade in front and a massive eyesore and incongruence in the rear."
Originally Taylor planned to begin construction in July, but that date came and went without work starting or even any permits being issued, as Ruda and Barron have chosen to stand their ground and fight for their rent-controlled slice of historic San Francisco.
Ruda, who works as the marketing director for Community Thrift store, moved into the apartment on Montgomery Street in 2004, and had lived just a few doors down before that – "I've lived on the same lot since my late 20s." Barron, he said, moved in with him later the same year.
Taylor purchased the property, and two others in the vicinity, in 2008.
Soon thereafter, the new landlord questioned him about Barron sharing the apartment, suggesting he should increase the rent. He backed down after Ruda confronted him.
Barron and Ruda both stated they don't believe Taylor to be homophobic, but rather new to the area, and motivated by financial concerns.
"Out of the three buildings that he owns here, our unit and our upstairs neighbor's unit pay the least because we are the longest term residents," Barron said. "New tenants pay at least double what we pay. I feel that the plan is more to convert these to a TIC unit and sell them, since he is using Master Builders SF, which claim to be TIC specialists on their website."
TICs, or tenancies in common, represent a loophole landlords use to get around the Ellis Act and the Condominium Conversion Ordinance, which regulate evictions and limit condo conversions citywide to 200 annually.
Barron also noted that Taylor's associate is Peter Iskander, a North Beach developer who has gained notoriety for tactics such as his recent eviction of four ailing and elderly Greenwich Street tenants with no alternative home.
Taylor denied the TIC accusation.
"There never has been an intention to TIC the building," he said. "Iskander is not a colleague but is the builder I hired to do my addition."
Ruda and Barron's upstairs housemate declined to be interviewed.
Jon Golinger is the current president of the Telegraph Hill Dwellers, a nonprofit organization founded in 1954 that has played a key role in keeping high-rises, parking lots, and chain stores out of the unique and tourist-attracting neighborhood. He told the B.A.R . that construction evictions of this sort surged during the dot-com boom of the late 1990s, "when the economy was hot," and speculated that a similar wave is beginning now in anticipation of the America's Cup, which will come to San Francisco in 2013.
Golinger described Taylor's proposed additions as "dramatically more than a minor tweak" that will require a special variance by the Historic Preservation Commission. To date, all parties concerned have attended five separate hearings of the commission at City Hall.
In early September, Barron and Ruda hosted an open house for the commissioners to visit the property and get a first-hand feel for what the expansion would mean.
During a September 7 hearing, a number of concerned neighbors gave testimony. In addition to Barron, six others spoke out against the project, including Mark Bittner, author of The Wild Parrots of Telegraph Hill, which inspired the film of the same name by Bittner's wife, Judy Irving.
Taylor's proposal was referred to further hearings before the Architectural Review Committee.
Aaron Peskin, former president of the Board of Supervisors and now chair of the San Francisco Democratic County Central Committee, is another neighbor who has offered support to the couple.
"I've known Corey forever," Peskin said, who is also a former president of the Telegraph Hill Dwellers. "We're a tight-knit neighborhood; we stick up for each other. Telegraph Hill Dwellers has always been concerned with tenants' rights, as well as preservation. I'm a landlord myself, I get a reasonable return on my property, and I like rent control. What you're seeing here is greedy behavior by a landlord who is not respecting the rights of long-term tenants."
Taylor disagreed.
"I am trying to improve the building within known building codes to capture the views and expand the living space from approximately 600 to 800 square feet," Taylor said. "Corey is a nice guy who disagrees with my plans to improve my property."
Ruda said the neighborhood's historical significance should be considered.
"I can see his perspective," Ruda said of Taylor's plans. "'I own the building, I can do whatever I want with it.' But if you own property in a historic district in San Francisco with rent-controlled tenants, it's not that simple. This neighborhood is like no other area in the world."
Golinger echoed that sentiment.
"No one likes restrictions on changes to their property," he said. "But when you buy into an area like Telegraph Hill, you have effectively signed a contract for the benefit of living in a special place. You have the parrots soaring overhead. You are part of something bigger and better than personal gain."
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.