Several weeks ago, I lamented how the Occupy movement was drifting – from highlighting inequality to the right to camp out in public squares. But this weekend, I joined Occupy San Francisco’s march through local neighborhoods hit hard by real estate speculators – and ending at the main Wells Fargo Branch downtown. What I saw was a movement with a renewed focus that can sustain and build momentum going forward. Whether it’s predatory lending that resulted in foreclosures, or risky schemes that financed Ellis evictions and CitiApartments’ empire building, Wall Street banks like Wells Fargo have directly led to the mass displacement of the 99%. Working with San Francisco Tenants Union, ACCE and other established housing groups, Occupy SF went to Wells Fargo with a list of nine concrete demands – from no more financing of Ellis Act evictions, to stop evicting homeowners. Tomorrow, more Occupy actions are planned throughout the country with a focus on housing – as activists will occupy homes that are being foreclosed, and submit similar demands to other banks. As Rachel Maddow reported the other night, it was actions like this in the 1930’s that persuaded Washington that the status quo was untenable. This is where the Occupy movement is headed, and where it will get results …
The following letter was delivered to the Chairman of Wells Fargo on Saturday:
John Stumpf
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer
Wells Fargo Bank
420 Montgomery St.
San Francisco, CA 94104
Dear Mr. Stumpf:
Wells Fargo Bank (based in San Francisco) is number 23 on the Fortune 500 list, and in 2010 made $93 billion in revenue.
Wells Fargo engages in “predatory equity” lending, financing large landlords who seek financing from banks and proposals outlining their plans to purchase apartment buildings and displace 80% of the existing rent controlled tenants living there and to replace them with tenants paying market rents.
Wells Fargo Bank financed CitiApartments, which used the money to buy 8 apartment buildings containing 294 apartments. CitiApartments then evicted or forced out over 200 renters in these buildings, and then re-rented those apartments at much higher rents.
Wells Fargo Bank is the lender on 226 homes in San Francisco that are in some stage of foreclosure. That is about 18% of the 1,283 homes in San Francisco that are in some stage of foreclosure.
Nationally, “at the end of 2009, there were 350,169 Wells Fargo homeowners who were eligible for HAMP. As of Feb 2011, only 77,402 got permanent modifications: a 22% rate of modification more than two years into the program. Wells Fargo has cancelled 118,697 trial modifications and denied 175,336 homeowners from accessing HAMP. Unlike other national banks, Wells Fargo has not changed its foreclosure procedures despite numerous confirmed reports of ‘robo-signing’ and other illegalities in the foreclosure process.”
Over the last ten years, Wells Fargo paid the lowest worldwide tax rate of the top five big banks (24.8% -- $27.5 billion on $110.9 billion, pre-tax earnings) and reportedly did not pay any federal taxes in 2009.
The bank and real estate industry-driven economic crash has resulted in the loss of 9 million jobs and the biggest drop in homeownership since the Great Depression.
Banks have spent more than any other sector on lobbying between 1998 and 2011, and CitiGroup, JPMorgan, Chase, Bank of America, Goldman Sachs and Wells Fargo were at the top -- dropping $12,020,000 between them in 2011 alone.
Therefore, we demand that Wells Fargo Bank:
(1) STOP EVICTING RENTERS. Do not provide any more predatory equity loans to real estate investors who purchase rent-controlled apartment buildings with business plans focused on displacing existing renters and replacing them with renters paying market rents.
(2) NO MORE FINANCING ELLIS ACT EVICTIONS. Do not make any loans unless the loan recipient agrees not to do any Ellis Act evictions and contractually agrees to that provision by making the loan immediately due and payable should any such evictions occur.
(3) NO MORE EVADING CONDO CONVERSION LAWS. Do not provide any loans for condominium forms of ownership like Tenancies In Common (TIC’s), which are utilized for purposes of circumventing San Francisco’s Condominium Conversion law.
(4) Do not make any loans for any home or unit where tenants have been displaced in the previous 48 months and prior to making any loan on any home or unit we demand you contact the San Francisco Rent Board to determine if any eviction(s) have occurred at the address.
(5) KEEP FAMILIES IN THEIR HOMES: Establish a moratorium on all foreclosures until they establish comprehensive reforms to their loan modification practices, including offering principal reduction; affordable, fixed interest rates; and provide proof of ownership of the loan. We are also calling on Wells Fargo to cease all illegal evictions of tenants in foreclosed properties and commit to working with real estate companies and servicers who follow local and state tenant protection laws.
(6) STOP EVICTING HOMEOWNERS: Any homes or units which have been foreclosed on already, and where the owner currently remains living there, we demand that you offer that homeowner the right to rent their home and continue living there.
(7) FUND AFFORDABLE HOUSING: Provide the San Francisco Mayor’s Office of Housing with interest-free loans, for the purchase and construction of affordable housing, in an amount equal to any federal bailout funds we received, pro-rated to San Francisco’s share of those funds.
(8) RESPECT HUMAN RIGHTS: Wells Fargo invests in and profits from immigrant detention centers, like CCO or GEO Group, which are part of deporting and breaking up immigrant families from San Francisco – one more way big banks profit as we of the 99% are forced out of our homes.
(9) PAY YOUR FAIR SHARE: Wells Fargo needs to stop exploiting loopholes in property tax laws and federal tax shelters to avoid paying their fair share of local, state and federal taxes.
San Francisco Tenants Union
Causa Justa::Just Cause
Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE)
Eviction Defense Collaborative
Tenants Together
Asian Law Caucus
Coalition on Homelessness
OccupySF
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.