Oceanside city planners say a proposal by the owners of Cavalier
Mobile Estates to convert their property from a rental park to a
resident-owned community is a clear attempt by park owners to
circumvent the city's rent control ordinance.
Early last year, the owners ---- Cavalier Mobile Estates LLC
---- tried to raise rents at the mobile-home community, but a city
panel rejected their request and a retired judge affirmed that
decision on appeal.
A few months later, the company unveiled its plan to subdivide
the property. The matter is set for review by the city Planning
Commission at a 7 p.m. Monday meeting in City Council chambers, 300
N. Coast Highway.
In a report to the commission, City Planner Jerry Hittleman
wrote that the proposal is "a ploy to avoid the continued
application of the city's rent control ordinance."
Hittleman advised the commission to reject Cavalier's request to
subdivide the 44-acre mobile home park into 347 individual lots
that could be sold to people who now rent the spaces.
Cavalier's lawyer, Mark Alpert of Santa Ana, did not return
phone messages Friday.
The mobile home park at 1225 Oceanside Blvd. has 347 spaces, 330
of which are rented under rent control agreements, Alpert said in a
September report to the city.
Conversion of Cavalier from a rental to a resident-owned park
would be devastating to the people who live there, said Frank
Merrifield, president of the Oceanside Manufactured Housing
Alliance, an umbrella group that represents residents of 10 of the
city's 19 mobile home parks, including Cavalier.
"It shouldn't be done. There's too many unanswered questions,"
Merrifield said Friday. "They don't give what the lots would cost
or what the rents would be. That ought to be established before
anything's done."
Most of the people who live in the mobile-home parks rely on
Social Security and couldn't afford to buy their lots, said
Merrifield, who lives in Rancho San Luis Rey Mobile Home Park.
"I know I couldn't," Merrifield said.
In a survey of park residents conducted by Cavalier owners, 127
residents who responded opposed the conversion, 19 supported it and
17 gave no opinion, according to Hittleman's report.
Conversion of Cavalier Mobile Estates wouldn't force people to
buy their lots, but it would allow the owners to raise rents for
people who don't, Hittleman wrote.
For renters who are not determined to be low income, rents could
be increased over four years to market rate, Hittleman wrote.
Rents for low-income residents also could be raised, but the
increase could be no more than increases in the consumer price
index, Hittleman an said.
Since 1982, mobile-home park rental rates have been subject to
approval by the city's Manufactured Home Fair Practices
Commission.
In October 2008, Cavalier owners asked to raise rents, but the
commission denied the request at an April 2009 hearing. Cavalier
appealed to an independent hearing officer, who also rejected the
park's request. Cavalier owners appealed that ruling in San Diego
Superior Court and Hittleman wrote that a court hearing on the case
is expected in June.
Hittleman wrote that the timing of the request to convert the
park to rental spaces led him to conclude that it was still another
move to sidestep rent control.
Call staff writer Ray Huard at 760-901-4062
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.