Oceanside: Rent-Control Supporters Outspent By Those Who Want to End It

Friday, May 25, 2012
Ray Huard
North County Times

Backers of a ballot measure that would phase out rent control
in Oceanside's 17 mobile-home parks have vastly outspent those fighting
to keep it, according to reports filed with the city clerk.

Between
Jan. 1 and May 19 ---- the latest date for which figures are available
---- the political action committee supporting Proposition E had raised
$238,348. That's on top of the $16,775 that the committee ---- Taxpayers
and Property Owners for Fairness, Yes on E ---- had raised in 2011.

The
committee is sponsored by the Western Manufactured Housing Communities
Association, an industry group for mobile-home park owners.

By comparison, groups opposed to Prop. E reported combined contributions in 2012 of nearly $45,000.

Councilman
Jerry Kern, who championed Prop. E, said those supporting it needed
more money, in part to overcome what he called the emotional appeal of
those trying to keep rent control for mobile-home park residents.

"All
the emotions are on their side," Kern said. "It's very hard to go
against somebody who says, 'They're going to take my home away.'"

Kern
said voters also are more inclined to vote against a ballot measure,
particularly if they aren't sure what the measure is about.

"If you're confused, you usually vote 'no,' so we have to get a clear message out there," Kern said.

Mobile-home
residents who are fighting the ballot measure have no way to match the
money that Prop. E supporters have poured into the campaign, said Chris
Gow, president of the Oceanside Manufactured Homeowners Alliance, an
organization representing mobile-home residents.

"We have people
power," Gow said. "We just have to keep doing what we have been doing.
We have our rallies, and we're hitting the grocery stores with our
brochures and word of mouth."

Money raised by groups fighting
against Prop. E includes $16,643 raised by the political action
committee Save Oceanside; $16,190 raised by the political action
committee Taxpayers for Oceanside Neighborhoods; and $12,141 raised by
the Oceanside Manufactured Homeowners Alliance.

The alliance was
not required to report contributions because it is not a political
action committee like the other groups, said Assistant City Clerk Holly
Trobaugh.

Prop. E would retain rent control for people who already
live in rent-controlled spaces, but would remove it when they leave or
sell their homes. If they passed on their homes to someone else, rent
control would continue only if that person were already living in the
home.

Among the larger contributions to Yes on E in 2012 were
$92,917 from Cavalier Mobile Estates; $67,924 from Mission View Mobile
Inc. of San Diego; $45,000 from the Western Manufactured Housing
Communities Association; $42,423 from B&B Lamplighter Oceanside of
Santa Ana, owners of Lamplighter Mobile Home Park; $20,000 from El
Camino 76 Mobile Estates; $19,499 from Terrace Gardens of Santa Ana;
$18,500 from Westwinds Mobile Lodge of Laguna Beach; and $10,000 from
Pacific Trailer Park of Encinitas.

Among the larger contributions
to Save Oceanside were $2,500 from the Oceanside Police Officers
Association; $1,000 from Kallogian & Fuselier, a Carlsbad law firm
that has represented mobile-home park residents; and $1,500 from
mobile-home park resident Thomas Linkhart.

Contributions to
Taxpayers for Oceanside Neighborhoods included $1,350 from Cavalier
Homeowners Association; $1,500 from mobile-home resident Edward Karlson;
and $2,500 from the Oceanside Police Officers Association.

Help build power for renters' rights: