Owners Bet on Raising the Rent, and Lost

Friday, May 28, 2010
Charles V. Bagli
The New York Times

The first signs of financial turmoil came at Riverton Houses in Harlem.

Then came Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village on Manhattan’s East Side.

Now a third complex built by Metropolitan Life in the 1940s for veterans and middle-class families has run into financial distress after being purchased by speculators during the recent real estate boom. The owners of the sprawling Parkmerced apartment complex in San
Francisco announced this week that they would default on their $550
million mortgage, which comes due in October.

A partnership of Laurence Gluck of Stellar Management and the Rockpoint
Group, which had already lost Riverton Houses in Harlem in March to
foreclosure, put out a statement on Wednesday that placed their
problems at the 3,221-unit Parkmerced in the context of the current
economic downturn.

“The landscape has changed dramatically,” P. J. Johnston, a spokesman
for the owners, said in an interview. “The economy has taken a major
hit. Many properties are facing default.”

But just like Riverton and Stuyvesant Town, the owners of Parkmerced
sought to take advantage of a roaring market to replace rent-regulated
residents with tenants able to pay far higher rates.

The owners in all three cases invested substantial sums in upgrading
the aging buildings and renovating some apartments. But ultimately they
failed to increase revenue enough to cover the debt payments on the
properties, which were heavily leveraged. The recession did not help.

“It’s pretty interesting that they have all ended up in the same
place,” said Andrew Florio, an analyst at Real Capital Analytics, a
research firm. “People assumed they could boost revenues by kicking
people out and raising rents.”

Stellar told the more than 6,000 tenants at Parkmerced, which is spread
over 115 acres on the south side of San Francisco, that life would go
on as usual. They said they were negotiating with lenders, which
include Deutsche Bank,
to restructure their debt and would continue with their $1.2 billion
expansion proposal to nearly triple the number of apartments at
Parkmerced.

“Phone calls will be answered and issues addressed, our maintenance
team will respond to work orders, and the leasing team will continue to
lease new apartments,” Seth Mallen, an executive vice president for
Stellar, said in a statement.

But so far, lenders have been reluctant to acknowledge the losses and
restructure deals that were struck during the boom. And analysts say it
remains difficult for owners to refinance large properties at anywhere
near the old terms. As Stellar points out, they are not alone; more
than $150 billion in commercial loans like theirs have been transferred
to special servicers who handle troubled debts.

There is $550 million in senior debt on Parkmerced and an additional
$52 million in secondary loans, according to the owners, but it is not
as heavily leveraged as Riverton or Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper
Village. The default was bad news for the giant California public
employees pension fund, Calpers, which invested in all three
properties. Calpers has already written off a $500 million investment
in Stuyvesant Town.

Stellar and Rockpoint were forced to give up Riverton Houses after
defaulting on $250 million in loans. And Stuyvesant Town and Peter
Cooper, which had been bought by Tishman Speyer Properties and BlackRock Realty for $5.4 billion in 2006, is in foreclosure.

All three deals had prompted an outcry from tenant advocates who
bemoaned the loss of housing affordable to working and middle-class
families.

“The Bay Area, like New York City, continues to be one of the least
affordable real estate markets in the country,” said Christopher Lund,
a spokesman for the East Palo Alto Fair Rent Coalition. “The Parkmerced
is the largest multifamily complex in San Francisco and its 3,200
rent-stabilized units are a key part of the Bay Area’s remaining
affordable housing stock.”

MetLife
built Parkmerced, Stuyvesant Town, Riverton and a handful of other
large complexes in the 1940s amid a national housing crisis in a
remarkable effort to provide homes for returning veterans. At
Stuyvesant Town, for instance, the company received special property
tax exemptions in return for agreeing to build the complex, maintaining
relatively low rents and limiting its annual profit to 6 percent.

At the start of the real estate boom in 2004, private equity firms began buying these kind of meat-and-potato complexes, which they had long eschewed in favor of luxury buildings.

Rents covered less than a third of the monthly debt payments. Mr. Gluck
had estimated he could raise income substantially by converting half
the apartments to market rates by December 2011. But by the time he
neared default in August 2008, he had converted only 128. The lenders
took back the complex at a foreclosure sale earlier this year.

Tishman Speyer and its partner bought Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper
Village — 110 buildings with 11,227 apartments on 80 acres — from
MetLife in 2006, the largest deal ever for a single property. Their
business plan was essentially the same as that of Stellar Management.

And like Stellar, they failed to replace rent-regulated residents with
tenants willing to pay higher, market rents as rapidly as projected.
The partners exhausted $890 million in reserve funds earlier this year.
Lenders are now foreclosing on the property, whose value is estimated
at about $1.9 billion.

Stellar and Rockpoint bought Parkmerced the same year they acquired Riverton.

MetLife built the complex between 1944 and 1952. It consists of 11
13-story buildings with 1,683 apartments and 1,538 two-story
townhouses. Its original 206 acres are bound by San Francisco State
University on the north, San Francisco Golf Club on the south and Lake Merced to the west.

MetLife sold the property to the real estate mogul Harry B. Helmsley
for $40 million in 1970, two years after he acquired the Parkchester,
another MetLife complex in the Bronx with 12,271 apartments, for $90
million.

Parkmerced entered a period of slow decline as Mr. Helmsley and a
subsequent owner deferred maintenance and sold small parcels to San
Francisco State, according to tenants and the current owners.
Increasing numbers of students from San Francisco State have replaced
families at the complex.

Stellar bought the property in 2005 for $700 million and promptly
announced a renovation program, spending, it says, $135 million on new
elevators and sprinklers, renovating lobbies and upgrading vacant
apartments with new kitchen cabinets and countertops. The units on the
upper floors of the towers are now called “penthouses” and require
special entry keys.

“Stellar Management is probably the best manager we’ve lived under,”
said Dorothy Lefkovits, who has lived with her husband Martin at
Parkmerced for 15 years. But some residents and tenant activists worry
that Parkmerced rents will swell beyond the reach of the people for
whom it was originally built.

There are also mixed reviews of Stellar’s proposal, now under review by
the city, to demolish the 1,538 townhouses to make way for up to 7,400
new apartments over 20 years. It is part of an plan to create a dense,
environmentally sustainable community based on public transportation
and wind turbines.

In the meantime, Stellar’s lenders were forced to pay a $6 million tax
bill last year when Stellar and its partner could not come up with the
money, according to Realpoint, a debt rating agency. And rents in San
Francisco have fallen by 8 percent or more, while vacancies are up at
Parkmerced.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: