Palo Alto-based property manager Page Mill
Properties committed securities fraud, misled its investors and engaged
in an illegal and "morally offensive" plan to gentrify a portion of
East Palo Alto, a group of Page Mill's investors is alleging in a
lawsuit against the beleaguered real-estate company.
Page Mill, which until recently was the largest landlord in East Palo
Alto, has been facing a storm of criticism since 2007 from East Palo
Alto's tenants, tenant advocates and city officials, many of whom
accused the company of engaging in a "predatory equity" scheme and of
flouting the city's rent-control ordinance. But as court documents make
clear, the company has also been fighting a legal war with its own
investors, who committed to investing $30 million to a now-crumbling
fund and are accusing Page Mill of withholding crucial information and
misleading them about its East Palo Alto portfolio.
The conflict between Page Mill and 19 of its investors -- including
more than a dozen experienced real-estate developers -- reached a
boiling point last October, a month after the company lost its East
Palo Alto holdings to foreclosure. On Oct. 12, frustrated investors
voted to oust Page Mill CEO David Taran from his position as the
manager of the Page Mill Properties Access Fund, a real estate fund
that Taran set up to finance the East Palo Alto portfolio.
In the Oct. 12 "written consent," the investors wrote that they have
"lost all faith in Access Fund Manager's ability to manage the Company,
and legitimately fear that Access Fund Manager, if allowed to continue
as managing member and manager of the company, will continue to pursue
its own improper self-interests, thus causing both the company and its
members further and irreparable harm." The investors also voted to
appoint Alpine Road Management, LLC, as the fund's new manager.
Two days later, Page Mill officials advised the investors that they
considered the request for a management change "void." The two sides
are now looking for an arbitrator to help them settle the dispute, said
attorney Steven Morger, who is representing the investors.
According to Morger's complaint, Page Mill began soliciting the
investors' participation in May 2007, when it provided them with a
"private placement memorandum" explaining the company's investment
strategy. The document, according to the complaint, was "based on a
slickly crafted pitch that combined (Bernard) Madoff-like airs of
exclusivity with projections of 'consistent and superior risk adjusted
returns.'"
The 68-page document describes the East Palo Alto portfolio as an area
"poised for growth and gentrification." The plan calls for engaging
East Palo Alto in a public-private partnership, developing
condominiums, fixing up the infrastructure and "further developing
community-oriented retail and service business."
But as the complaint states, Page Mill also failed to mention a few key
tidbits about its East Palo Alto portfolio. For one thing, the
portfolio was losing about $1.5 million a month at the time Page Mill
approached the investors and was a "literal black hole of operating
losses." The company also didn't disclose to its investors that its new
East Palo Alto holdings are subject to the city's rent-control
ordinance -- a detail that severely complicated Page Mill's plans to
raise rents and achieve an internal rate of return of 20 percent.
The company's plan for a private-public partnership with East Palo Alto
also didn't go as planned. Instead, Page Mill became entangled in about
a dozen lawsuits with the city, many of them centering on the
rent-control ordinance. The company successfully challenged the city's
attempt to revise the ordinance last year, forcing the city to delay
the vote until this June. Page Mill also petitioned San Mateo County to
remove the Woodlawn Park neighborhood from East Palo Alto's
jurisdiction.
One investor, Paul Magliocco, wrote in a declaration that Page Mill
materially misrepresented and fraudulently concealed material fact,
"falsely portraying the Fund as an ongoing success with bright future
prospects." Magliocco, who has been affiliated with the angel investor
network Keiretsu Forum, wrote that he would never have invested in the
fund had he known about the "scheme to evade rent control laws."
"From a purely economic perspective, it rendered the investment far too
risky," Magliocco wrote in the Dec. 7 declaration. "At least as
importantly, I find the scheme morally offensive.
"This investment was sold to me and my fellow investor members as
socially conscious and community beneficial. That was a cynical lie.
"Page Mill's scheme was exploitative and damaging to the East Palo Alto
community fabric, forcing many residents out of their homes with huge
(probably illegal) rent increases. Had I known the truth, I would have
wanted absolutely no part in it."
The investors are also claiming that Page Mill had failed to inform
them of the $50 million loan payment the company was scheduled to make
to Wachovia by Aug. 1, 2009. Page Mill failed to repay the loan and, as
a result, lost control of its 1,812 units to a court-appointed receiver
in September.
The company's default apparently surprised the investors, who were
repeatedly assured that everything was going according to the plan. In
November 2008, Taran had made a presentation at an investors' meeting
at the HP Pavilion in San Jose in which he was reportedly "upbeat about
the (East Palo Alto) portfolio's performance and prospects." At that
meeting, Taran projected a $1.5 million operating profit "six months
forward," according to the complaint.
By the third quarter of 2009, it became clear to everyone that the fund
was doomed. The missed loan payment and the subsequent foreclosure
wiped out Page Mill's then-$12 million fund and angered the investors.
On Aug. 13, more than a week after Page Mill defaulted on the loan, the
investors were "first warned that there might be a problem," the
complaint states. Less than a month later, the San Mateo County
Superior Court appointed a receiver, Wald Realty Advisors, to oversee
the properties.
Beside Magliocco, the list of plaintiffs also includes 14 Crow Canyon
Corporation, Dennis A. Chantland, Diablo Capital Venture Fund, Randy
Haykin, John Quandt, John Adams, Shane Albers, Colin Wiel Investments,
Dina Partners, Kevin Grauman, John Hammergren, James Levine, Neal
Mitchell, David Pottruck, William Powar, John Staples, Kenneth Stevens
and Vertical Venture Capital.
While the investors have attributed the fund's collapse to Page Mill's
fraudulent conduct, Page Mill has characterized their complaints as an
attempt to skirt a contractual obligation. Under the agreed-upon terms,
City National Bank fronted all the money for the fund with the
understanding that it could later call on the investors to repay it.
Early last October, when it was clear that the investment was tanking,
the bank asked the investors for $14.8 million in repayments. The
investors declined to pay and are now suing the bank, claiming that it
was complicit in luring them into Page Mill's scheme.
Page Mill's attorney, Christine Morgan, characterized the plaintiffs as
a "self-described group of elite, sophisticated, well-educated and
wealthy professionals" who should've known what they were getting into.
Albers, for example, serves as chairman and CEO of Investment Mortgage
Holdings, a company that manages more than $700 million in real estate
investments, Morgan wrote. Vertical Venture, meanwhile, reportedly has
more than 15 years of experience as a real-estate developer and
investors.
Their latest challenge to Page Mill is basically about the plaintiff's
"attempt to avoid honoring their obligation to pay for a group of
investments that might fail," Morgan wrote. Page Mill initiated
arbitration proceedings against three of the plaintiffs.
The three plaintiffs, Albers, Grauman and Vertical Venture, were
ordered by the courts to pay a total of $2.8 million, Morgan wrote.
Taran also disputed the investors' argument that the company misled
them into making a risky investment and failed to disclose its
financial obligations. The $50 million loan from Wachovia was used to
refinance a much larger loan from Greenwich Capital Financial Products,
Taran wrote -- a loan of which the investors knew, or should have
known. Without the Wachovia loan, the Greenwich loan would have matured
in December 2009 and would have required the company to pay Greenwich
about $125 million, he said.
The agreed-upon strategy was "to leverage a leveraged investment," Morgan wrote.
"However, as do all leveraged real-estate investments, Access Fund had
risks, and Plaintiffs were thoroughly advised of them," Morgan wrote.
"It should come as no surprise to this sophisticated group,
particularly given the real-estate market meltdown and credit crisis,
that the Fund could, and did, lose money."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the
use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright
owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website
in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in
California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S.
Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for
purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain
permission from the copyright owner.