Many residents consider Park Merced, with its
wide-open traffic circles, apartment buildings and low-rise homes,
semiprivate garden courtyards and ample parking, a slice of suburbia on
the southwestern side of San Francisco.
But next week, the City Planning Commission could change all that. It
could approve an ambitious, $1.2 billion project to turn the
decades-old housing development into a state-of-the-art neighborhood,
filled with corner stores within walking distance of homes designed to
save water and power, newly designed public parks and easy access to
transit that designers hope will eliminate the need for cars.
Tripling housing
The plan calls for keeping all 11 apartment towers, but tripling the
number of homes over the next 20 years so that 14,000 new residents can
move into the 152-acre development. About 1,500 town homes would be
destroyed and replaced with 7,200 new units.
Units that currently have their rents controlled will stay that way, but new ones will be rented or sold at market rate.
While the development is applauded by many planners who say dense,
walkable communities are the future of the urban landscape, a handful of
Park Merced residents worry their reconfigured neighborhood will lose
its unique character and become just another part of big, anonymous San
Francisco.
"It was intended to be a building complex that looked like a park,"
said Terence Faulkner, retired chairman of the San Francisco Republican
Party and a resident of Park Merced since 2002. "It is a beautiful
place."
Construction on the development began in 1941, when airy, open spaces
were replacing the dense, urban neighborhoods of the early 20th
century. Thomas Church, considered by many to be the father of the
modern garden and a pioneer of the free-flowing, asymmetric designs
common to many gardens today, helped design the community.
But the suburban experience in Park Merced is not what San Francisco
is all about, said Craig Hartman, an architect with Skidmore, Owings and
Merrill, who redesigned the plan for the developer, Stellar Management.
"It's foreign to San Francisco," he said. "It was really built as a
place that didn't come from San Francisco at the time. It is internally
separate from San Francisco. In some ways, it is like a gated community -
it is not that, but it has that quality."
Today, transit first
The broad, sprawling streets that promote driving now run counter to
the city's transit-first policy, which promotes using transit, biking
and walking, said Gabriel Metcalf, head of the San Francisco Planning
and Urban Research Association, a pro-development think tank.
"Park Merced is part of the city that was conceived in an age when
Americans hated urban complexity," he said. "What we've learned in the
half-century since it was created is that traditional city patterns ...
is the more sustainable way of living."
But that contemporary urban structure can't be created quickly.
The plan calls for the area to be redeveloped in stages. As the
number of residents increases, more neighborhood amenities, including a
school, would be built.
If approved, the neighborhood's first coffee shops would be built in
five years. By the time a third of the new homes were constructed, a
grocery store and retail shops would be added. In 10 or 12 years,
Hartman said, Muni's M-Ocean View line would be extended into the heart
of the development.
Frequent foot traffic
The area, like other city neighborhoods, would have frequent foot traffic and a nightlife, Hartman said.
"I think it is going to feel like an authentic part of San Francisco," he said.
That's what concerns some residents, who worry that Park Merced's
rent-controlled apartments will be replaced by brand-new, expensive
units that are denser than ever before. Grass will be gone, as will some
parking spaces, they fear.
"It is a beautiful site," Faulkner said. "As long as you are dealing with low-rises."
Stellar Management has no intention of eliminating rent-controlled
apartments, said P.J. Johnston, spokesman for the developer. The plan,
if approved by the Planning Commission and, eventually, the Board of
Supervisors, says that every unit that is currently rent controlled must
stay rent-controlled.
"This is as solid a project as you can get in San Francisco," he said.
Living in 'time bubble'
Other residents, though, say they are looking forward to an upgrade of Park Merced.
"It's a bizarre but comfortable place to live," said Daniel Phillips,
former president of the Park Merced Residents' Organization. "You feel
like you are in a time bubble in the 1950s."
An unofficial poll of organization members shows that 64 percent are in favor of the proposed development, he said.
"The plans I've seen are much more conducive to a modern society," he added.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.