Parkmerced in Default: What Now for Owners’ Plan to Bulldoze Over 1,500 Rent-Controlled Homes?

Tuesday, June 1, 2010
Dean Preston
Beyond Chron

The owners of San Francisco’s Parkmerced cannot pay their mortgage, yet
they want permission from the city to demolish more than 1,500 rent
controlled homes. While most of the public discussion about the
proposed development project has been about environmental, transit and
preservation issues, the planned demolition of so many rent-controlled
housing units is reason alone to stop this project.

Parkmerced was built by the Metropolitan Life
Insurance Company (MetLife) after World War II. Met Life also built
similar complexes in New York City (The Riverton Houses, Stuyvesant
Town and Peter Cooper Village) and other large U.S. cities. For
decades, these developments have provided stable housing for
middle-class renters in increasingly expensive urban real estate
markets.

In 2005, a partnership of Stellar Management and Rockpoint Group
purchased Parkmerced and The Riverton. The complexes were purchased for
sums that could not be justified by the existing rental income on the
properties. Instead, as noted in a New York Times piece this weekend:
“just like Riverton and Stuyvesant Town, the owners of Parkmerced
sought to take advantage of a roaring market to replace rent-regulated
residents with tenants able to pay far higher rates.”

These “predatory equity” schemes have not been working out as investors
intended. Tishman Speyer (Stuyvesant Town), Stellar Management
(Riverton), Page Mill Properties (East Palo Alto), and others wound up
in foreclosure, with banks, pension funds and other institutional investors losing the funds invested in these reckless schemes.

Parkmerced is not far behind these other properties on the road to foreclosure. The latest news is that the owners are in default
on their loans. Former Willie Brown spokesman P.J. Johnston, now
working for Stellar Management, sought to reassure the community that
the default would not change life at Parkmerced. According to Johnston,
the owners remain committed to moving forward with their development
plans.

Those plans calls for the demolition of over 1500 “garden apartments,”
all of which are subject to San Francisco’s rent control law. The
owners argue that they will replace these units with over 5000 new
housing units on the site at a rate of 300 per year. (It is unclear how
many of these anticipated units would be rental
units. The owners admitted at a recent Planning Commission hearing that
the mix of rentals to owned units “has not been finalized.”) They claim
that they will replace the rent-controlled units with new
rent-controlled units.

The promise to replace the demolished rent-controlled housing with
rent-controlled housing cannot be taken at face value. First, given the
owners’ current financial situation, there is no assurance that they
would be able to perform on such a promise. In a worst-case scenario,
one that seems entirely possible, rent controlled homes would be
bulldozed and then the project abandoned – in whole or in part – when
it came time to build the replacement units.

Second, the City must remember that this ownership group’s business
model involves the deregulation of rent-controlled units. At minimum,
the city should demand and examine placement memoranda, investment
agreements and other documents that the owners provided to potential
investors. Similar documents in other predatory equity deals reveal the
intent to displace tenants and raise rents despite local tenant
protection laws.

Third, now that California’s Court of Appeal has expanded the
Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act to bar most rent-restrictions on new
housing, proposed rent restrictions on replacement housing would likely
be challenged in court by the owners, or subsequent owners, of
Parkmerced. While Costa Hawkins recognizes a limited exception for
certain types of development agreements, the 2009 Palmer v. Sixth Street
court decision shows that cities cannot rely on the Courts to interpret
Costa Hawkins to allow rent-restrictions on new housing. Until state
law changes so that the city can guarantee its residents that
replacement units will be rent-regulated, the City should not even
consider allowing such a large-scale demolition of rent-controlled
housing units.

Finally, let’s not forget that San Francisco has a policy against demolishing sound rent-controlled housing. The City’s Planning Code
makes this clear. The City’s Planning Department reiterates the point:
“Under requirements of the General Plan, the Department is predisposed
to discourage the demolition of sound housing.”

Given the precarious financial position of the owners, the
uncertainties regarding rent-restrictions on replacement housing and
the city’s policy to discourage the demolition of sound housing, it is
hard to imagine that any responsible city official would approve moving
forward with a plan to demolish over 1500 rent-controlled homes at
Parkmerced.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: