The stories the tenants tell are outrageous.
Mark Goodoien said an exterminator told him the cockroach infestation in his apartment was the worst he'd ever seen.
Two floors below, Sue Hansen said squirrels lived in her walls.
In Annie Almanzar's unit, rotting kitchen pipes caused repeated flooding, and the bedroom walls were covered in mold.
'Anytime I reported anything to the landlords, they would just blow you off,' Goodoien said.
Landlords Hyder Jaweed and Asgher Ali (aka Jaweed), are notorious in the Twin Cities rental-property business.
Columbia Heights inspectors weren't surprised when a tenant from Goodoien's apartment building called to complain last fall, considering they had made 119 visits there in the past six years and had previously revoked the rental license.
In fact, the name Jaweed rings a distinctly unwelcome bell for housing and fire inspectors, tenant-advocacy groups, management companies, contractors, garbage haulers, and utility providers.
Jaweed, 34, and Ali, 29, brothers who live together in a six-bedroom, 4,800-square-foot house in North Oaks, are prolific property owners with a history of neglecting their buildings, mostly occupied by low-income tenants.
One or both brothers have owned at least 17 rental properties in several cities over the last 10 years. (Go to TwinCities.com to see a map of their property locations.)
In many instances, they have not paid their bills or
Advertisement
their employees, have evicted tenants who complained and have waited until the last possible minute to make city-ordered repairs to properties.
Despite the efforts of city inspectors, the Jaweeds have been successful at manipulating a loosely structured rental-property regulatory system. Inspectors and other regulators say the Jaweeds do the minimum necessary to meet city standards. Housing inspectors struggle to get compliance on even the smallest violations.
And no one knows exactly how to make them follow the rules. Cities have tried, but their efforts have fallen short.
This revolving door of violations, inspections and sanctions costs taxpayers and subjects thousands of tenants — who often have nowhere else to go — to unsafe and unhealthy living conditions.
The Jaweeds did not respond to multiple phone messages and e-mails from the Pioneer Press and refused to sign for a certified letter. Their attorney, Kenneth Hertz, did not return a phone message and instructed Asgher Ali not to answer questions from a reporter when approached after a court hearing.
VULNERABLE TENANTS
John Fitzgerald and his girlfriend were expecting a baby and were short on time and money when they searched for an apartment in early 2009. The Peters Place apartments in Columbia Heights looked sizeable for the price, Fitzgerald said, and there were no obvious problems.
He never saw the actual unit he would move into. Once there, the problems started immediately, he said.
"The bedbugs were out of control," he said, and the bathroom ceiling leaked.
By then, they were locked into a one-year lease, the baby had arrived and Fitzgerald, 33, had lost his job.
"We were kind of stuck," he said.
Fitzgerald said the Jaweeds didn't listen to his complaints and wouldn't fix anything, either. Fitzgerald ended up putting a plastic bag on the ceiling to catch the dripping water.
He and his family got out the minute the lease was up. (For more on Peters Place, see Page 9A.)
Tenants in the buildings the Jaweeds have owned across the state, including Burnsville, Brooklyn Center, Newport, Forest Lake, Fridley and Rochester, are usually low-income earners. Many don't speak English.
With limited affordable housing options in the suburbs, low-income renters have few other choices. Unlike some landlords, the Jaweeds accept taxpayer-funded Section 8 housing vouchers. And they don't run background checks or require an application, according to former employees, making it even easier for those with bad credit, criminal records or past evictions to put a roof over their heads.
The bottom line is that most of the tenants in the Jaweeds' properties are vulnerable, says Eric Hauge, a tenant organizer at HOME Line, Twin Cities-based tenant advocacy group.
"They're not going to stick their neck out when they know next month they might not be able to pay their rent," Hauge said. "When you have that much stacked up against you, you're just going to take it."
'THEY WANTED THEIR RENT'
Tenants' stories are the same: bugs, rodents, mold, leaking pipes, holes in walls, missing fire-safety equipment, broken security locks, unlit hallways, broken or leaking windows, graffiti, inoperable washers and dryers and overflowing garbage containers.
Residents at Brookhaven apartments, the Jaweeds' Brooklyn Center complex, got so fed up with the landlords' nonresponsiveness last fall that they sent a letter to the landlords and city officials detailing a list of problems, including mold and broken windows, needing to be fixed "for the safety, well being and comfort for us and our families."
"We feel neglect is present and ongoing in the complex," the Sept. 17 letter reads. "We ask, as stated in the lease agreement, that these items be fixed in a timely manner."
Six weeks later, the problems remained, and the city deemed the building too hazardous for occupancy, city inspection records show. The Jaweeds made just enough repairs within the inspectors' 72-hour deadline to allow residents to remain, but some problems were still unresolved in early January, said Vickie Schleuning, Brooklyn Center's director of building and community standards.
Tenants from several buildings said that while the Jaweeds didn't respond quickly to problems, they were prompt in collecting rent.
"All they wanted, boy, when the first day of the month came around, they wanted their rent," said Sue Hansen, who lived in Peters Place between 2007 and 2008.
Inspectors from numerous communities say the Jaweeds are among a small number of landlords who don't respond within the usual 30-day window to remedy housing-code violations.
Inspection records for Peters Place, in Columbia Heights, show it has taken an average of 15 weeks for the Jaweeds to make city-ordered repairs.
BEDBUG SCARS
While city officials worked to get the Jaweeds to comply, some residents took more extreme measures to get the landlords' attention.
Laura Nyaundi, who lives in the Charleswood apartments in Burnsville, has fought for almost three years over the conditions in her apartment. She started by complaining to the property manager and then to the Jaweeds. When that failed, she contacted the city and filed a civil lawsuit, which was settled last month, according to court records.
In March 2008, Nyaundi and her daughters, then ages 8 and 2, moved into Charleswood, unaware the place was crawling with bedbugs and cockroaches, according to court documents.
She pleaded with management to eradicate the pests or to move her family to a new unit. Her daughters suffered scarring from severe bedbug bites. Nyaundi's child care provider turned away the 2-year-old, fearing the girl would carry the bedbugs on her clothing and transfer them to others. And friends refused to visit, the documents show.
"Maybe it's not a big deal to you, but if you see the pictures of the bites on my 2-year-old daughter maybe then you will have some sympathy," Nyaundi wrote in a letter to the building manager in April 2008.
The Jaweeds ignored Nyaundi's requests, which included maintenance problems in her unit, and never followed through on a promise to move the family to another unit, according to the lawsuit Nyaundi started in late 2009.
Nyaundi and another tenant, who sued at the same time, will each receive an undisclosed amount from the settlement.
Burnsville officials said in December that the Jaweeds had provided documentation that they treated the building for bedbugs and there haven't been any complaints since March.
The reason some unhappy tenants don't just leave is that moving can be expensive, particularly if they have to buy all new furniture in order to prevent carrying bedbugs and cockroaches with them.
"I'll hear judges say to tenants, 'Well, why don't you move if it's so bad?' " said HOME Line's Hauge. "Well, those tenants are in a lease, and you can't just break a lease. ... But even if you could, it's not easy to move. It's a lot of money. You might lose your security deposit. You risk having an eviction filed against you."
EVEN MANAGERS FURIOUS
Caught in the middle of the angry tenants, frustrated city officials and stubborn landlords are the property managers the Jaweeds hired to run each building.
Paramark Corp., a professional management company, agreed to run the Center Pointe complex in Brooklyn Center after a January 2008 court-ordered agreement between the city and the Jaweeds regarding how the property should be maintained.
In the four months that followed, Michael Busch of Paramark had trouble getting money from the Jaweeds to pay utility and other bills, according to court documents.
"Everyone is knocking on the door for payment. We need to get cash in every account THIS WEEK to take care of fires," Busch wrote in an e-mail to Asgher Ali on Jan. 16, 2008.
On March 21, 2008, Busch wrote: "Are you still alive? Please call me."
The next month, Paramark's contract was terminated, according to court records. The next management company quit in July.
At other properties, the Jaweeds hired individuals to oversee day-to-day operations, and several of them told of similar frustrations in court affidavits.
Amy Huber, who worked for the Jaweeds as a property manager from November 2008 to April 2009 in Forest Lake and Burnsville, said there were times she used her own money for repairs after the Jaweeds refused to pay because of a tenant's ethnicity, according to a November 2009 affidavit.
Huber said that anytime she requested money to do maintenance on a unit, the brothers would first ask about the resident's ethnicity. "If I'd confirm that the resident happened to be Hispanic, the Jaweeds denied me funding to do the repair and say, 'Why should we replace it? The (racial slur) will just ruin it again anyway,' " the affidavit said.
In March 2009, Huber was transferred to Charleswood in Burnsville.
"Lines of residents formed outside my office door daily, and residents would complain to me about the neglect of their units by management," she wrote in an affidavit.
Instead of ponying up money to deal with the problems, the Jaweeds told Huber to let the complaining tenants out of their lease, Huber's affidavit says.
"When I did so, I was instructed to immediately prepare eviction documents which were later used in legal proceedings to extract more money from the former tenants," Huber said.
She quit after five months, no longer wanting to be "a part of the Jaweeds' disgusting operation," she said. She's also in the midst of a sexual-harassment employment lawsuit against the brothers.
Other employees said they were asked to lie.
Jerome Aderman, a tenant at Peters Place in Columbia Heights who was paid $50 a month to act as caretaker, said the Jaweeds told him in November to tell the Pioneer Press that there were no problems despite a pending inspector visit that day. He did, and then sent the reporter off the premises, as the Jaweeds ordered him to.
"I didn't want to," Aderman said in a January interview, just days after he quit. "I was the one that called the fire marshal in the first place."
WHEN WORK GOT DONE, CONTRACTORS WEREN'T PAID
Even when the Jaweeds fixed problems at their properties, they did not always pay, according to public records and interviews. They owe at least $300,000 to companies that did work or provided services for their properties. Of that total, $158,000 is due to CenterPoint Energy.
Former manager Huber talked about difficulties getting supplies for repairs because of outstanding Jaweed accounts at stores such as Home Depot and Menards. The Jaweeds took to using aliases to establish new accounts, Huber wrote in a June court affidavit.
"This would be in order to trick vendors into supplying services in spite of Hillcrest's unpaid bills," Huber wrote regarding the Forest Lake apartment complex. "Vendors would sometimes get suspicious and ask, 'This isn't those brothers, is it?' I would have to lie to them and tell them it was new management."
A garbage hauler stopped picking up trash from the Robinwood apartments in Robbinsdale in summer 2004 when he wasn't paid, according to Brian Ringham, a city housing inspector. Dumpsters at the four-building, 88-unit complex overflowed.
"There were flies and there were maggots," Ringham said. "Then the sanitation guy refused to remove his equipment ... and a new contractor brought in his equipment and put it next to the other stuff. It got to be a pile the size of a dump truck. The city ended up having to pay to get rid of it."
Tony Kromrey, a New Brighton contractor who had worked on and off for the Jaweeds over the past decade, listed in a court affidavit 30 contractors he personally knew who were owed money from the pair.
Kromrey wrote in the affidavit that, on numerous occasions, he saw the Jaweeds lie to other contractors when they showed up in person to collect on unpaid bills.
"The Jaweeds would look at them and say they didn't know who the owners were and would deny that they were the owners," Kromrey said. "It was like a big game — I've never seen anything like it."
Kromrey and his son sued the Jaweeds and won judgments totaling more than $6,400, which have not yet been satisfied.
Roofing contractor Hugo Casas was new to the business and had no idea about the Jaweeds' reputation when he responded to a Craigslist ad to do work for their Brookhaven apartments in Brooklyn Center last summer.
The Burnsville man said in an interview with the Pioneer Press that he was dumbfounded when city employees told him he wasn't the first to get stiffed by the Jaweeds.
Roofing two 6,000-square-foot garages at the apartment complex was the biggest job his small company, Hi-Tech Roofing, had landed in its first year of existence. Ali persuaded Casas to reduce his bid, and the pair agreed to $6,000 — barely enough to cover paychecks for his crew, Casas said.
When the job was over, Ali told Casas he'd get a check the next week. It never came. At first, Ali assured Casas the money would arrive, and then he stopped taking the contractor's phone calls.
"Why do they do that?" Casas asked in an interview with the Pioneer Press. "I want to do something — of course I want it to be legal. But everything costs so much. ... I couldn't believe people would do that to other people."
Minnetonka-based Dorglass Inc., which didn't get paid more than $72,000 for window and door installation at properties in Fridley and Brooklyn Center, is one of at least 25 contractors that filed liens against Jaweed properties. Dorglass threatened to sue, which prompted the Jaweeds to settle, and Dorglass got about two-thirds of its money.
Dorglass President Harvey Schmidt said one statement Asgher Ali made to him several years ago sticks with him.
In an interview with the Pioneer Press in November, Schmidt recalled, "He told me: 'This is America; you don't have to pay your bills.' "
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.