PETRA, the death of public housing

Friday, July 16, 2010
Lynda Carson
Indy Bay

Berkeley - The scheme to privatize and sell Berkeley's 75 public
housing units has stalled, and currently the Department of Housing and
Urban Development (HUD) has not completed it's review of the
disposition plan filed with HUD to dispose of Berkeley's public
housing.

Around December 31, 2009, the Berkeley Housing
Authority (BHA) filed an application with the U.S. Department of
Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to dispose of it's public housing
units, and expected HUD approval of the scheme in around 90 days. HUD
approval has not occurred.

The City of Berkeley plans to sell
it's public housing units to one or more non profit housing developers,
and the BHA plans to finance the privatization of Berkeley's public
housing units by looting the Section 8 program.

If all goes
as planned, the developer/s plan to convert the units into the Section
8 Project-Based voucher program, a program for landlords in the private
housing sector that allows landlords to charge above market rate rents
to the poor, and the units will be subsidized with federal funding
taken from the poor, in the Section 8 program.

In opposition,
public housing and Section 8 tenants appeared at several Berkeley City
Council meetings and other public meetings to protest and speak out
against alleged illegal activities of the BHA, and the scheme to
privatize and sell their 75 public housing units to an unnamed non
profit housing developer.

Additionally, on January 19, 2010,
public housing tenants held protest signs in front of Berkeley's Old
City Hall in between harsh rain storms pounding the Bay Area before
stepping inside the City Council meeting to demand the resignation of
BHA Director Tia Ingram and BHA's Chair Carole Norris, for their
involvement in the actions to privatize and sell Berkeley's public
housing units.

Nearly 7 months later, Director Tia Ingram and
BHA Commissioner Chair Carole Norris still remain in power, HUD has not
yet approved of the BHA's disposition plan, and many of Berkeley's
long-time public housing residents facing displacement from their
housing feel the stress and anxiety, regarding the outcome of their
future housing situation.

Meanwhile, the BHA hired Overland,
Pacific and Cutler (OPC) to relocate Berkeley's public housing
residents from their housing if the disposition plan is approved, and
on July 16, OPC consultant Chet Wakefield started working on some
notices to send out to Berkeley's public housing residents to let them
know that he wants to have two half-hour meetings with the residents
some time during early August. Wakefield wants to ask Berkeley's public
housing residents what they want to do regarding their housing
situation if the disposition plan is approved by HUD, even though many
have already spoken out publicly against the scheme to sell off
Berkeley's public housing, and Wakefield is already well aware of this.

In a bizarre effort to hoodwink Berkeley's public housing
residents into believing that their public housing units are not really
being privatized once ownership of the public housing units are
transferred to a new owner in the privatized housing sector, in a
recent June 17, letter from BHA Director Tia Ingram to public housing
resident Keith Carlisle and Berkeley's public housing resident
organization called Residents Awareness in Action (RAIA), Ingram
congratulates Carlisle for reactivating RAIA, and formally acknowledges
the groups opposition to the scheme to privatize and dispose of
Berkeley's public housing, which she refers to as the repositioning
project.

In part, BHA's Ingram writes; "I use the term
repositioning as it more accurately reflects what we are attempting to
do, and that is transfer assisted families from Public Housing to
Section 8, not "removing" or even worse "disposing" of units. It is my
hope that with time, and careful, thoughtful and consistent effort, we
will be able to provide RAIA, and every current resident, sufficient
information about how and why we arrived at the decision to pursue
repositioning, and equally important, how repositioning can result in a
win-win situation for current and future residents and the Berkeley
Housing Authority."

Berkeley's public housing residents are
not fooled by the campaign of lies and deceit, knowing very well that
Section 8 is the subsidized program for tenants in the privatized
housing market, and that it should not be confused with the public
housing program, no matter what BHA's Ingram wants them to believe.

Documents clearly reveal that it was BHA Director Tia Ingram that
signed the disposition plan that was filed with HUD to dispose of and
remove Berkeley's public housing from the inventory of public housing
units in Berkeley, with the intent to sell the units to one or more
so-called non profit housing developers, upon HUD approval.

The Affordable Housing Swindle

During 1937, the U.S. Housing Act created the first public housing
program, authorizing local housing authorities across the nation to
build public housing that is financed through long-term bonds to serve
low-income families.

Since the creation of public housing,
additionally there are currently around 13 other major federal
subsidized housing programs to assist the poor, including the Section 8
Tenant-Based voucher program, and the Section 8 Project-Based voucher
program for tenants being subsidized in the private housing market
place.

So-called privatized affordable housing developments
should not be confused with public housing, despite the fact that the
backers of a scheme to privatize our nations 1.2 million public housing
units are doing their best to hoodwink the public into believing that
public housing, and so-called affordable housing developments are one
and the same.

Public housing provides housing to low-income
families, the elderly, blind, disabled and households with no income at
all, while so-called affordable housing developers have minimum income
requirements that discriminate against the poor.

Affordable
housing developers often charge above market rate rents in their
buildings and want the public to believe that that they offer housing
to the poor, but often these developers refuse to rent to the poor
unless the poor are being subsidized through the Section 8 program, or
some other federal subsidized housing program.

PETRA - Preservation, Enhancement and Transformation of Rental Assistance

The so-called affordable housing industry stands to make billions of
dollars in a scheme called PETRA that would accelerate the
privatization of public housing units all across the nation, if
approved by Congress.

If the backers of a right-wing
scheme to privatize Berkeley's public housing have it their way, and an
Obama administration proposal called PETRA ( The Preservation,
Enhancement and Transformation of Rental Assistance ) is approved by
Congress, public housing programs across the nation may be terminated
and around 1.2 million public housing units may become privatized in
the near future, and placed at risk of bank foreclosures.

The
Obama administration has been promoting far-reaching legislation
(PETRA) to change the way our nations 2,400 public housing authorities
(PHA's) operate in an effort to privatize our nations public housing,
setting off a feud between 2.3 million public housing residents who are
in opposition to the privatization of their housing, and the advocates
and proponents of public housing privatization from the so-called
affordable housing industry, who stand to make billions if they can get
their hands on our nations 1.2 million public housing units.

The problem -- Congress has underfunded public housing through the
years creating a huge backlog of repairs and maintenance, and all
Congress needs to do is provide more funding to remedy the situation.

Instead of asking for more funding from Congress, HUD Secretary Shaun
Donovan and the Obama administration want to privatize the 1.2 million
public housing units in a complicated scheme to transfer ownership of
our public housing units to so-called affordable housing developers
that will charge above market rate rents being subsidized by the
Section 8 program, believing that the new owners would then be able to
tap into the equity of the properties to get loans from the private
sector for the backlog of maintenance and repairs, as other property
owners do in the market of privatized housing.

The
privatization scheme threatens to displace hundreds of thousands of
low-income families, elderly and the disabled from their public housing
units if enacted into law, and future funding shortfalls in the Section
8 program would place the housing units at risk of bank foreclosure.

In addition, if PETRA is approved by Congress, the nations major 13
federal subsidized housing programs will be converted into one huge new
hybrid program, with only one funding stream for the whole program.
Currently each of the 13 subsidized housing programs have their own
budget and funding streams, to make certain the funding reaches it's
intended target. Once the funding streams are converted into one huge
slush fund, no one will be able to tell how much funding for the poor,
elderly or the disabled has been diverted to finance the public housing
privatization scheme, called PETRA.

PETRA has been rejected
by thousands across the nation including Congresswoman Maxine Waters
and Congressman Barney Frank, but HUD and the Obama administration are
moving forward as though they already have Congressional approval for
PETRA as is evidenced in the recent HUD budget submitted for 2011.

HUD wants to reduce public housing funding by around $500 million in
2011, in addition to reducing funding for the elderly in the Section
202 housing program from $825 million to $274 million, and reducing
funding for persons with disabilities in the Section 211 housing
program currently from $300 million, to $90 million in 2011.

The Obama administration also wants to reduce the family reunification
voucher program from $15 million in funding to zero, and wants to
reduce the veterans supportive housing voucher program from $75 million
to zero, for 2011.

HUD and the Obama administration is
clearly trying to grab as much funding as is possible from the federal
subsidized housing programs for veterans, low-income families, the
blind, elderly and disabled to finance the PETRA scheme to privatize
1.2 million public housing units, in an effort to enrich the so-called
affordable housing sector by billions of dollars with funding taken
from the poor.

PETRA Forums -- As recent as July
13, the first of three special forums to promote PETRA on behalf of HUD
and the Obama administration took place at the Urban Institute in
Washington D.C., and two other forums are to take place sometime later
during July.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: