Philadelphia’s renegade sheriff faces office shutdown after stand for homeowners

Thursday, July 22, 2010
Linda S. Wallace
Tri State Defender Online

In a city where foreclosures have drained small fortunes from
working-class neighborhoods, a police officer-turned-politician decided
to take on the financial institutions and protect homeowners’ rights.

In 2004, and again in 2008, Philadelphia Sheriff John D. Green –
elected to the job in 1987, decided to postpone the monthly sheriff’s
sale for judicial foreclosures to give homeowners more time to try to
save their homes. His activism sent shock waves through the financial
sector, which feared the local sheriff’s homegrown brand of consumer
protectionism might spread like a virus to other cities.

Fast
forward to 2010: Philadelphia’s foreclosure intervention model, which
began as one sheriff’s effort to get homeowners, lenders and housing
activists talking, is widely heralded as a national model for
foreclosure prevention. Representatives from other cities travel to
Philadelphia to figure out how to save homes.

However, the
renegade sheriff who took on the bulk of the legal and political risks
to secure homeowner rights is himself facing a powerful coalition of
groups – including many run or backed by local businesses and real
estate interests – that wants to abolish his office and turn the
sheriff’s job into an appointed position.

Sheriff halts sales; summons lenders

The
saga began in 2003, when Green assembled the Task Force for Foreclosure
Prevention, a coalition of local stakeholders working to identify ways
to increase the number of homeowners receiving loan workouts, stop
mortgage fraud and address reports of predatory lending and servicing
practices in Philadelphia.

As sheriff, Green is charged with
transporting incarcerated defendants to trial, protecting the local
courts and ensuring public safety. He decided to do something
extraordinary to get the attention of big banks; he postponed sheriff
sales for residential properties – twice – and called lenders to
Philadelphia to discuss homeowner’s complaints of mistreatment and
disrespect.

The matter ended up before civil court, where Green
argued that the Sheriff’s Sale system was broken. At a hearing last
year on foreclosure prevention before the Congressional Oversight
Committee, Judge Annette M. Rizzo of the Philadelphia Court of the
Common Pleas, credited Green with laying the foundation for
Philadelphia’s nationally acclaimed Residential Mortgage Foreclosure
Diversion Program, which makes mediation mandatory.  No owner-occupied
house may be foreclosed on and sold by the sheriff’s office in
Philadelphia before a “conciliation conference,” a face-to-face meeting
between the homeowner and the lender aimed at determining if special
modification programs or loan workouts might be appropriate. Homeowners
in default receive counseling and at times free legal representation.

Similar
versions of this model have since been adopted by cities such as
Chicago and Pittsburgh, and mediation programs are now being tested or
considered in numerous states, including New Jersey, Ohio and Florida.

Last
week, U.S. Rep. Steve Cohen (D-Memphis) introduced a bill to establish
a grant program for state and local governments to help provide for
such mediation sessions between homeowners and lenders nationwide in an
effort to help prevent foreclosures and auctions.

Not in my city, you don’t

Philadelphia
has a reputation as a working-class city. Tenants have strong rights.
Unions have a powerful voice in political decisions and sway with
government.

So when Sheriff Green began to see 1,000 properties
a month coming up for auction, he set up a task force to get borrowers
and lenders talking, and make it clear to national mortgage companies
that, in Philadelphia, they needed to follow the rules set up by the
Federal Housing Administration to protect homeowners.  

The office:

Conducted
the largest public service campaign regarding foreclosure prevention in
recent history. The campaign included informational brochures that
explain where homeowners can find help and assistance; full-page public
service newspaper ads; interviews on public affairs programs; and
notices left on homeowners’ doors. A year after the campaign began
Philadelphia sheriff’s sales had declined 21 percent.

Assigned a
foreclosure response team to work with homeowners who felt that their
rights had been violated during the foreclosure process. A director of
foreclosure prevention – appointed to Green’s staff – directs
homeowners’ complaints to appropriate authorities and, at times,
personally intervenes.

 Worked with the Court and housing
counseling groups to identify new ways to streamline red tape that
might prevent workouts in the late stages of foreclosure.

In
2008, the sheriff’s consumer-protecting ways landed him on the front
page of the Wall Street Journal.  “He’s taking the Law into His Own
Hands to Help Broke Homeowners,” the headline read. “In a city beset by
poverty and crime, Mr. Green has emerged as an unlikely blend of
lawman, politician, spiritual leader and social worker,” the newspaper
of choice for the business community wrote.

“It’s not just the
sheriff’s job to sell houses,” Deputy Sheriff’s Officer Paris
Washington, a veteran of the department and a member of the sheriff’s
executive team, told the Journal.  “It’s the sheriff’s job to serve the
people who elected him. Because he was elected by the people, he has to
listen to the people. Aren’t the people the law?”

At a glance

Linda
S. Wallace served as coordinator of Philadelphia Sheriff John Green’s
Task Force for the Prevention of Mortgage Foreclosure. She is part of
the grass-roots campaign underway to keep an independent, elected
Sheriff in Philadelphia.

This is the first of a two-part series.

Next week: No good deed goes unpunished


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: