Perhaps it was a stroke of Christmas spirit, but a
landlord in Santa Monica got her wish when the Planning Commission
approved a mechanism to allow her to put an addition on her unit without
destroying three other homes.
Commissioners voted last week to
approve a text amendment which would allow Daniella Kuhn, the live-in
landlord of a rent-controlled complex of four apartments on the 700
block of Euclid Street, to add a second story to her unit as long as it
complied with all other code provisions, including those governing
height, the number of stories and other provisions.
Key was the caveat that the construction not increase the number of units on the property.
Vice
Chair Gerda Newbold and Commissioner Jennifer Kennedy raised concerns
about the treatment of residents during the construction of the second
story, but were assured that those items were covered under rent control
law.
"I'm really happy about how everything went," Kuhn said.
The
change has been several months in the making. Kuhn decided in July that
she wanted to expand her 800-square-foot apartment so that she could
continue to live there when she established a family.
When she went to City Hall to get permission, she was denied.
Size, in this case, wasn't the problem.
The
proposed second story on Kuhn's personal unit was well under the
maximum square feet allowed for a single-family home in her north of
Montana Avenue district.
However, Kuhn's multi-residential
complex was a legacy of a different time, before the area had been zoned
exclusively for single-family homes. As a result, her building was a
"legal non-conforming" use, meaning that she could not do major
improvements on it without turning it into a single-family home.
To
do so would mean taking all four rent-controlled units off of the
rental market, demolishing them and kicking out the existing tenants.
Kuhn
and land use attorney Chris Harding approached the Planning Commission
in October to dispute the ruling, arguing that staff had incorrectly
interpreted the zoning code, and that under their interpretation, the
expansion could be permitted.
Alternatively, they could file for a
text amendment, but the cost was prohibitive: $10,000 to $15,000 just
to ask the staff to look at it.
The Planning Commission didn't
choose between the two methods — they used both, filing for a text
amendment and requesting the staff interpretation of the code.
Last
Wednesday, it was the text amendment that was approved, to the relief
of Commissioner Ted Winterer, who had voted against requesting the
interpretation.
"I was concerned that the hearing on her
particular issue was problematic," Winterer said. "… I was sympathetic
to her cause for a variety of reasons, but thought there was a better
way to change the law."
Having seen City Hall craft a text
amendment that would allow electric cars on the Third Street Promenade,
Winterer felt it would be a fast, clean way to resolve the solution.
The Planning Commission voted to approve the amendment unanimously.
Kuhn was thrilled.
"Someone
is just trying to live their life and then are trapped in a weird code
preventing you from getting on with your life," she said. "Now
everybody's on board."
She hopes that the demonstration of City
Hall's willingness to work with landlords will convince others to take a
more active role in their apartment buildings, possibly increasing the
live-in landlord population in the city.
Kuhn has already hired an architect and will begin moving through the permit process to design and build the new floor.
"I
still have to jump through a lot of hoops, this isn't a done deal.
There are a lot of approvals that have to happen," she said. "It'll take
a long time, but I'm OK with that."