Poll Shows Strong Support for Rent Control in San Jose

Monday, July 27, 2015
Nathan Donato-Weinstein
Silicon Valley Business Journal

A new poll suggests that support for strengthening rent control runs deep in San Jose, potentially giving a boost to tenant advocates who are expected to make a big push for new pro-renter policies in Northern California's largest city in the months ahead.

Roughly 72 percent of survey respondents expressed some degree of support for "adopting a rent control law that limits rent increases in San Jose to no more than 2 percent annually," according to results provided by Bob Brownstein, director of policy and research for Working Partnerships USA, the labor-aligned think tank. The survey was conducted by EMC Research and involved a sample of 592 San Jose residents.

"The rent situation is so bad that everyone knows someone who’s being squeezed badly," Brownstein said.

The poll results come several weeks after San Jose city staff was directed to study policies that could strengthen the city's relatively weak rent-stabilization laws. The push is being spearheaded by District 3 Councilman Raul Peralez, who has not yet to make a formal proposal on policy changes. Last week, Richmond became the first city in years to adopt a rent control ordinance after a nail-biting council meeting. The ordinance could become law in December and would affect about 9,900 units out of almost 34,000 total.

Hoping to build a sense of momentum, San Francisco-based Tenants Together on Monday released a " rent control toolkit" that "synthesizes the legal, organizing and policy expertise of Tenants Together staff, volunteers, members, and member organizations on the issue of rent control," according to a news release. The downloadable booklet includes a "model rent control ordinance for California cities" as well as talking points and a guide to rent regulations in the state.

"We wanted to dispel a lot of the misinformation that’s out there about rent control, so we have a short fact sheet and a longer document on Rent Control 101, and we also drafted a model ordinance that cities can use and customize as to how they want their rent control ordinance to look," Dean Preston, executive director, told me.

The discussion around rent control is taking shape amid record-setting rents in Silicon Valley. Asking rent for a one-bedroom apartment in San Mateo County now averages $2,516, up 12.4 percent compared to a year ago, according to market research firm Real Answers. The same unit type will set you back $2,336, on average, in Santa Clara County, up 12.2 percent year-over-year.

The San Jose poll, which carried a margin of error of about 4 percent, would suggest that rent control enjoys broad support across demographic categories. Democratic women were the most supportive at 80 percent, with Democratic men at 75 percent supportive. But even Republic men were 56 percent in favor, Brownstein said, with Republican woman 66 percent in favor. The poll's sample was 59 percent homeowners and 41 percent renters.

The 2 percent figure rent increase mentioned in the poll does not reflect any specific policy proposal, but rather tests for a fairly strong curb on rent renewals, Brownstein said. San Jose's rent control ordinance currently caps renewals on eligible properties at a maximum of 8 percent annually; Peralez wants to study limiting rent increases to a maximum of 4 percent annually.

Of course, the poll did not reflect the limited benefit any rent control ordinance would be able to provide, a fact that could lead to weaker support if the limitations were fully explained. Opponents to rent control would likely hit upon that in any campaign against the policy.

Under the state's Costa Hawkins Act, only properties built before 1995 — or built prior to the date of existing rent control laws — are subject to rent controls. In San Jose, that means only units built before 1979 qualify. That means rent controls aren't even an option for the large complexes that often drive the region's strong rent growth figures.

The California Apartment Association's local chapter did not respond to a request for comment by publication time. However, a poll conducted for the landlord trade association earlier this year showed that among San Jose respondents, rent control trailed public employee pension reform and gun control in a favorability contest among those issues. In a matchup where respondents were given a the choice between increasing the minimum wage and keeping rental prices low, 52 percent chose minimum wage, while 27 percent chose rent control.

However, that poll didn't measure what was measured for Working Partnerships — support for rent control on its own. CAA did query on that front in Burlingame, where a survey found that 60 percent of respondents opposed rent control, 33 percent supported it and 7 percent didn't know or refused to answer. Burlingame is a majority-renter city and has seen some grassroots interest in rent control.

Terry Christensen, a professor emeritus of political science at San Jose State University, said the level or support seen in the latest San Jose survey reminded him of the response to the initiative that raised the minimum wage in San Jose.

"The poll shows that it's common knowledge that rents are exorbitant in this region," Christensen wrote in an email. "Both homeowners and renters (and Democrats and Republicans) support some sort of regulation."

Only 12 percent of respondents were "strongly opposed" to rent control, while 7 percent were "somewhat opposed." Nine percent didn't know.

You can read more about the current politics of rent control in my cover story from earlier in July, here. [Link at original site.] 

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: