Pressure increases on apartment owners

Thursday, July 29, 2010
Joe Naiman
Village News

The San Diego County Board of Supervisors has given its approval to
a new law requiring rental housing owners and operators to undergo
Crime Free Multi-Housing certification if certain thresholds are met,
and be subject to a $2,500 fine if they fail to take the training.

The supervisors’ 5-0 vote July 13 was the second reading
of the ordinance, which was also unanimously approved during its
introduction and first reading on June 29. The ordinance will take
effect Aug. 12.

The supervisors’ motion also directs county staff to
work with the San Diego County Apartment Association on providing
documents that differentiate property owners who have undergone
voluntary certification from those who were required to be certified
and calls for the ordinance to be returned to the Board of Supervisors
in one year for review.

Prior to the July 13 second reading and vote on the
ordinance, the Supervisors gave their input at the June 29 meeting.
"Responsible property owners and landlords are not the target of this
ordinance. It’s only the problem properties," said Supervisor Dianne
Jacob.

The existing Crime Free Multi-Housing education program
and certification has been in place for several years as a voluntary
program, and successful in reducing crime and blight in multi-family
housing complexes.

Those complexes that have not undergone such
certification, which includes inspection as well as training and
requires each tenant to enter into a lease addendum promising not to
commit or allow the commission of criminal activity on the premises,
include poorly maintained or managed properties that have created
problems not just for other tenants but also for neighboring properties
and the surrounding community. The ordinance requires owners or
operators to undergo the certification process if the housing facility
generates at least 10 calls for service to law enforcement agencies
within any 90-day period or if a 90-day period produces a 25 percent
increase in calls for local law enforcement relative to two other
similarly-situated residential rental housing facilities.

"There’s a need to give additional teeth," said Supervisor Greg Cox.

During
the Board of Supervisors hearing, several Spring Valley residents spoke
about problems with a nearby apartment complex that has created
criminal activity and other unruly behavior that affects the neighbors.
The San Diego County Apartment Association expressed support for the
concept of requiring owners of problem facilities to undergo training
but it fears that confusion may prevent the public from differentiating
between owners who proactively undergo the certification process and
facilities forced to be certified.

Crime Free Multi-Family is a trademark and certification
under that particular name may be required to obtain some grants, so
different names for voluntary and mandatory certifications would not be
feasible. Various distinctions are possible. "The current
certification, I think, can be enhanced so it’s even more meaningful,"
Jacob said.

The ordinance includes a process to contest a notice to
require certification and includes provisions for an appeal fee which
will be based on cost recovery along with a waiver provision in the event an appellant claims an economic hardship. While the specific appeal fee is to be determined periodically by the Board of Supervisors, the ordinance
includes a $150 fee for the certification application and a $50 annual
renewal fee. Violators may be fined up to $2,500 per violation for each
day the violation has occurred, and intentional violation carries a
penalty of up to $6,000 per day.

"I just don’t want to see landlords not report crime
because they’re afraid of this penalty," said Supervisor Bill Horn. "We
don’t want to have a chilling effect on the reporting of crimes."

Horn owns rental properties but not in unincorporated
San Diego County, so he does not have a material interest in the
ordinance. "I don’t have a problem with the ordinance. My problem is
the notification," he said.

Because Jacob was working with the San Diego County
Apartment Association on the ordinance, the June 29 hearing was not
docketed until the previous Friday. The day before that hearing Horn
learned from Fallbrook apartment owners that they were unaware of the
proposed ordinance. "I just don’t think the Fallbrook owners got proper
notice," he said.

While the San Diego County Apartment Association
notified their members, the California Apartment Association members
were not notified.

Horn was concerned that North County apartment owners
needed to be informed of the proposed ordinance prior to the July 13
hearing. "I just want the landlords in my area to understand just what
the ordinance is."

The ordinance language requires certification for
"residential rental housing facilities that have at least 10 calls for
service to the Sheriff’s Department and/or the Fire Department within
any given 90 day period." The inclusion of calls for service to the
fire department may count non-crime paramedic and fire calls toward the
10-call threshold. "My concern is the ten calls," Horn said.

Horn also noted that angry neighbors may place calls to be punitive to rental complexes.

Although
the ordinance’s lease addendum states that prohibited activity shall
constitute a substantial violation of the lease and be grounds for
termination of tenancy and eviction, civil courts rather than
administrative county personnel handle eviction appeals. "The judges
are not real friendly in evicting some of these people," Horn said. "We
don’t always win."

There was insufficient time between the hearing dates to
arrange a community forum for North County apartment owners and
operators, but Horn plans to hold at least one meeting later in the
year, where complex owners and operators can discuss what may or may
not be working with the ordinance so far.

Supervisor Pam Slater-Price agreed that the ordinance’s
success will depend on the ability to evict violators. "The courts need
to back up the Sheriff’s Department and responsible owners," she said.

After the July 13 vote, Horn said he is still concerned
that there may be some vague aspects to the ordinance and plans to
offer a community forum in North County on the subject later in the
year. He said he will relay any concerns brought forth at that forum to
his fellow supervisors.

Shelli DeRobertis contributed to this story.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: