Privatization of Public Housing Shelved - for Now

Thursday, June 3, 2010
George Lakoff
Truthout

The Department of Housing and Urban Development's
(HUD) attempt to privatize all of America's public housing has been put
on hold - for now. You played an important role. Thousands of you
signed the petition and spread the word, so that those at the House
Financial Services Committee hearing on May 25 understood what the
stakes were.

Barney Frank and Maxine Waters asked the right
questions, and HUD's answers revealed what was hidden in the language
of the bill, namely, that all public housing in America would be
subject to privatization. Under the PETRA bill, public housing could
result in new ownership that would take out mortgages from private
banks to fix and maintain the property. In the case of budget cuts to
HUD or mismanagement by new owners, the mortgage payments would be
endangered and foreclosure would be a real issue. Banks that held the
mortgages could foreclose and then those banks would own what is now
public housing.

Frank's questions to HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan
reveal that Representative Frank understood that foreclosure would mean
privatization. Donovan did not answer Frank's questions. The next day,
Donovan stated in a blog on the Huffington Post that his PETRA bill
would not allow privatization of public housing, contrary to
Representative Frank's - and my - understanding.

Here is Secretary Donovan refusing to answer Frank's
questions at the hearing of the Financial Services Committee of the
House on May 25.

Frank: Going to a Project-based section 8 is
one thing, the ability to finance and put ownership at risk is another.
You say in your opening statement that ownership won't change, but it
might if there is a financing and then a foreclosure. How necessary is
that? Is there a way to get financing without that? And, if you have a
foreclosure, would you then have, well, you can have "use restrictions"
but would you then have a private entity (it's almost like contract
prisons), is there then a private entity standing in the shoes of
government and what are the constitutional implications of that? That's
what concerns me. You anticipate, under this, you could end up with a
foreclosure and a private ownership of public housing, are they then
required to maintain it as public housing in perpetuity? Does the
tenant or anyone else have the same constitutional rights vis-a-vis
that owner? In the municipality, some have a large population in public
housing, does that diminish the right of the elected or appointed
officials? What is the status of a potential private owner of public
housing?

Donovan: If I can speak broadly on this subject, this is intended to level the playing field ...

Frank interrupts: You know we only have five
minutes. I understand that, but that's not my question. You accept the
fact that there may be foreclosures and I need to know what happens in
that case?

Donovan: Specifically, every other kind of housing can access not only private ...

Frank interrupts: Mr. Secretary, look, we
have a good working relationship, please don't jeopardize it by not
answering the question. That's not what I asked you, you had a chance
to talk about that. What happens when a private owner, we have public
housing that is publicly owned, what happens, what is the status of a
private owner who takes it over?

Donovan: So, there is a required,
for any public housing building, there is a required 30 year minimum
term with a use agreement initially, with renewals of any property
based contract at the unilateral discretion of HUD. And so, there is no
way for an opt-out to happen ...

Frank interrupts: Stop, please. What is the
legal position you have now, a private owner of what was public
housing, what is the constitutional relationship with the City, what
are all those implications?

Donovan: I'm sorry, I'm trying to answer the question ...

Frank: No, you're not. Please answer.

Donovan: The use agreement survives foreclosure ...

Frank: Please, stop. I didn't ask you about
the opt-out. If you are living in a place that is owned by a
government, you are under one set of rules, a private entity takes
over, what does that do to your constitutional rights, to the
relationship with the City, the Mayor can't fire you anymore. That's a
very important set of questions.

Donovan: I thought you were asking about, in foreclosure, the risk of that happening ...

Frank: Yes, because then it becomes a private owner.

Donovan: So, all of those current
requirements about the public ownership continue and the fact that
there is private financing doesn't change that in any way ...

Frank: Doesn't a foreclosure transfer the ownership from a public entity to the private entity?

Donovan: The foreclosure, first of
all, all of the requirements of affordability continue and the
transfer, any transfer of the property would be subject to the ability
of HUD to have a right of first refusal on that transfer ...

Frank: That's not the question. The question
is that if, in fact, there is a private owner, what's the legal status
of that private owner, vis-a-vis, the tenants, the rest of the city,
etc. etc. That's pretty clear-cut.

Donovan: If there is a private
owner of that housing, then it would still operate under all of the
requirements, both for affordability and the Housing authority itself
would continue to be subject to all the same appointment of
commissioners and the current requirements of the public ownership of
that land. And if I'm missing the question ....

Frank: My time is expired.

Shortly thereafter, Representative Waters takes up
the questioning of Secretary Donovan. It is clear that she also sees
PETRA as leading to privatization.

Waters: I am going to try and continue some
of the discussion raised by the Chairman in relation to foreclosed
properties and I'm going to go through this exercise because I think it
is important to engage you on these very important issues but I am
starting out with a negative feeling about TRA.

First, Page 11 of your draft discusses
properties in foreclosure or bankruptcy. It is my understanding that in
the event of a foreclosure or bankruptcy, that a use restriction would
remain on the property, meaning that this property has to be utilized
in the same manner. However, you have language on page 12, lines 1-5,
stating that the Secretary can modify this requirement if the units are
not physically viable, financially sustainable or, if necessary, to
generate sufficient lender participation. The section goes on to
require the Secretary to transfer the contract for assistance to other
properties if he makes such a finding. I have a few questions about
this. Why would a property not be physically viable? Isn't it the point
of TRA to allow public housing agencies access to private markets so
they can rehabilitate their properties?

Second, by financially unsustainable, I
assume you mean that the debt on the property exceeds the net operating
income needed to make the property run in the black. How would a
property get to be in this position in the first place, also, if the
property is in foreclosure, isn't it by definition financially
unsustainable? If the Housing Authority was unable to service the debt
because, let's assume the rents were insufficient, wouldn't the
investor have the same problem?

Third, It seems that you want to be able to
waive the use restrictions entirely if you find that it presents an
impediment to lenders making loans to Housing Authorities, knowing that
you could waive the Use Restrictions. It seems to me that lenders would
make waiving the Use Restrictions a condition of their participation. I
think this position renders the Use Restriction meaningless. Can you
explain under what condition you would grant such a waiver?

And, Fourth, if the Use Restriction is
waived, what happens to the tenants of that property? Do they have to
move, do they receive enhanced vouchers? When the contract is
transferred, what kind of property is it transferred to? Is it
transferred to a property across town, next door, in the suburbs, on
and on and on?

I know I threw a lot of questions at you,
but there are hundreds more about this TRA. You want to take a stab at
some of those, Mr. Secretary?

Donovan: Happy to do that. First of
all, we currently have new affordable housing that is developed in this
way. We have long experience on how to protect properties in
foreclosure from losing that housing. TRA would enhance our ability to
do that in a number of ways.

First of all, there would be a required Use
Agreement that would survive the foreclosure, as you said. In addition
to that, however, we also would have a right of first refusal in order
to ensure that if the current Housing Authority or owner is not able to
keep up that property, if we don't believe that they have the capacity
to do that, that we could direct the property to a different public
owner or to an owner we are sure will be able to preserve it. So, that
is a very important tool to be able to be sure that the property is
preserved in the long term. The specific provision you asked about,
about transferring assistance, the truth is that we currently have
properties that are currently under severe distress that we will not be
able to preserve, even today. We have already lost about 150,000 units
of public housing because of the inability to preserve them ...

Waters: Mr. Secretary, my time is just about
up and I will talk with you some more about this, but I want you to
know that this experiment I consider very dangerous and, as I've said
over and over again, I am not about to be a part of privatizing public
housing. I think that there are a lot of problems with this experiment
and I would like you to really think about some of the questions you
are going to hear today and, if you are still interested in pursuing
it, map out a time over the next two years where you can meet with
residents, you can talk with advocates, you can have more hearings, you
can flush all of this out, rather than try to move with something this
tremendous, this big. Thank you.

Later on in the hearing, Waters introduced the
petitions in opposition to PETRA into the Congressional record. For
full details, go to the web site of the Financial Services Committee.

More than 2,500 of you signed the petition, which
has gone into the Congressional record. More signatures will be sent to
Representative Waters. To sign, go here.

Here is a web site with letters, background information and alternative proposals.

The PETRA legislation brings up two important framing questions:

  1. Should public housing be considered
    infrastructure (frame A) or real estate (frame B)? As infrastructure,
    the usual way to finance maintenance is through government bonds. If
    the government defaults on the bonds, it still keeps the public
    property. As real estate, real estate is financed through private bank
    mortgages. If a mortgage isn't paid, the bank takes the property and it
    is clearly private. The PETRA bill finances maintenance through private
    bank mortgages. It is using frame B.
  2. Here is language from the PETRA bill on page 30 (on the HUD web site):

(ii) PROJECTS AND UNITS OWNED BY PUBLIC HOUSING
AGENCIES. The Secretary may consider a project or unit owned by a
public housing agency to include a project or unit owned by an entity
in which the agency or its officers, employees or agents hold a
significant direct or indirect interest and which has among its
purposes the ownership or management of affordable housing.

Let's parse that a bit. Consider:

A project or unit owned by an entity in which the
agency or its officers, employees or agents hold a significant direct
or indirect interest and which has among its purposes the ownership or
management of affordable housing.

This gobbledygook language actually says that the
secretary of HUD can consider private (or privatized) property, no
longer legally owned by the government, as if it were "owned by a
public housing agency." This is linguistic trickery by which private or
privatized, property can be called "public." Given this trickery,
Donovan can claim that all privatized property is still "public,"
because the PETRA bill allows him to call it that and "consider" it as
such. It is basically lying with language.

Let us praise Frank and Waters for calling privatization "privatization."

But don't take them for granted. Donovan is still Secretary of HUD.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: