Tenants in San Francisco who lose their jobs or whose wages plummet
at least 20 percent could be temporarily exempt from rent hikes, under
a ballot measure that city voters will consider next week.
Proposition F, the "Renters Financial Hardship Applications"
measure, is the latest attempt by San Francisco's politically
influential tenant advocates to chip away at property rights in a city
were renters outnumber property owners by about 2-1.
Backers describe the proposal as a measured response to the worst economic recession since the Great Depression.
"We're seeing a big increase of people struggling to deal with rent
increases who face eviction for nonpayment of rent," said Ted
Gullicksen, who heads the San Francisco Tenants Union. "This can help
keep people in their homes."
Under current law, tenants whose rents are raised to pay for certain
property improvements and tax increases can ask the city Rent Board to
limit the increase due to financial hardship.
Over the past two years, an average of three hardship appeals were
filed monthly, with about two-thirds of the requests granted in whole
or in part, according to the Rent Board.
Prop. F would extend the hardship exemption to the annual rent
increase that landlords are allowed to impose, which this year is set
at 0.1 percent, or a $1 increase for every $1,000 of rent. The
allowable cap is tied to the local consumer price index. Landlords are
allowed to bank the annual rent increases and enact them all at once if
they want. Rent control applies to most rental housing built before
June 1979, when the limits were enacted.
Under Prop. F, tenants could apply for a hardship exemption if they
become unemployed, if their wages drop 20 percent or more or if they
live on government benefits, such as Social Security, and did not
receive a cost-of-living increase in the past 12 months.
Once one of those conditions is met, an administrative law judge
working under the auspices of the Rent Board would base the hardship
decision on whether the new rent would account for more than a third of
the tenant's income. The tenant's assets also would be considered.
Either side could appeal the decision to the Rent Board.
The freeze would be lifted and a landlord could raise the rent once the tenant's financial circumstance improves.
The proposal does not take into account the property owner's financial situation.
The proposed law "advances the philosophy of public ownership of
housing. It boxes in the owners," said Janan New, executive director of
the San Francisco Apartment Association, a leading landlord advocacy
group.
She and other Prop. F opponents argue that passage would hurt both
property owners and, ultimately, tenants. Since rent control doesn't
apply to vacant properties, they argue, landlords will feel compelled
to charge more when units turn over if rents are frozen on occupied
units.
In addition, the measure does not impose income limits on tenants
claiming financial hardships, as long as the rent comprises 33 percent
or more of gross income.
Prop. F was placed on the ballot by Supervisors John Avalos, David Campos, David Chiu, Chris Daly and Ross Mirkarimi.
In addition to the Tenants Union, the proposal is backed by the San
Francisco Democratic Party, Senior Action Network and the Affordable
Housing Alliance.
Opponents include Mayor Gavin Newsom, Supervisors Sean Elsbernd and
Carmen Chu, the San Francisco Association of Realtors, the San
Francisco Republican Party and Coalition for San Francisco
Neighborhoods.
Newsom said that if Prop. F passes, he wouldn't be surprised if it's
legally challenged, like many other plans to strengthen rent control
and eviction protections.
San Francisco propositions
Voters will be asked to decide the following:
Prop. A: Renew for another 20 years a school
facilities tax to fund capital projects in San Francisco public
schools. Property owners would pay $32.20 a year for single-family
homes and nonresidential parcels, or $16.10 per unit for multifamily
residential and mixed-use properties. The parcel tax is expected to
generate $7 million a year.
Prop. B: Authorize a $412 million earthquake bond
that would shore up neighborhood fire stations and an auxiliary
water-supply system used by the Fire Department.
Prop. C: Change the city charter to take away the
mayor's authority to appoint all 11 members of the Film Commission and
limit the mayor's picks to six appointees. The remaining five members
would be appointed by the Board of Supervisors.
Prop. D: Force the city to set aside more money to
help fund the pension system, require San Francisco's newly hired
public safety workers to increase their pension contribution to 9
percent from 7.5 percent and calculate benefits based on the pay for
new employees by averaging the last two years of employment. Currently,
pensions are based on the pay earned in the last year of work.
Prop. E: Require the Police Department to report
how much it spends annually to protect the mayor, members of the Board
of Supervisors and other dignitaries.
Prop. G: Support the northern terminus for the
state's planned high-speed rail route in the new Transbay Center at
First and Mission streets.