Proposed rent increase upsets seniors at T.O. mobile home park

Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Teresa Rochester
VenturaCounyStar.com

The news arrived in the mailboxes at the Thunderbird Oaks Mobile Home Park for senior citizens early last week.

The park’s owner is seeking approval for a $322.52 monthly increase
in each tenant’s rent, the letter from the city of Thousand Oaks said.
The increase would allow the owner “to obtain a ‘just and reasonable’
return on its property,” according to a memo from the owner’s attorney.

Hugh Faulkner, 81, thought the amount was a typographical error.

“I must of read it over and over,” said Faulkner, who relies on food stamps, Medi-Cal and

Medicare. “I am living right on the edge. I live totally on my Social Security. I don’t have a penny left at the end of the month.”

The city’s recently reactivated Rent Adjustment Commission will
conduct a hearing Oct. 5 on the Thunderbird Oaks application. The
commission has the ability to deny or approve an increase and set the
amount. City staff may present its own recommendations and residents
will have an opportunity to oppose an increase, offer a different
formula to determine an increase or offer an alternative.

The commission was reactivated by the City Council earlier this year.
Ranch Mobile Home Park on Los Feliz Drive also submitted a rent
adjustment application to the city, but it was deemed incomplete, said
Russ Watson, the city’s housing and redevelopment manager.

Thunderbird Oaks officials and documents said the increase is
necessary so owners receive just and reasonable rent and return on the
property.

“If we keep going the way we are, it won’t be long before the park is
operating at a negative,” said park attorney Boyd Hill of the firm
Hart, King & Coldren.

In a memo to the city, Hill points to Thousand Oaks’ Mobile Home Rent
Stabilization ordinance, which essentially enacted rent control for
mobile home parks in the city in 1980. The ordinance states that the
Rent Adjustment Commission can adopt a discretionary rent increase if it
finds that automatic increases fail to provide a just and reasonable
rent.

A commission resolution allows commissioners to make a rent increase
using net profit and inflation to determine the amount. Different ways
of figuring out an increase are also allowed.

Using a formula, called a maintenance of net operating income
formula, Thunderbird Oaks owners determined a monthly increase of
$322.52. That translates to an average increase of 80 percent for
tenants whose rents at the park range from $373.40 a month to $483.40.

“It may not all be imposed at once,” Hill said.

Marge Hagy, 82, and her husband, Richard, moved to Thunderbird Oaks
in March to be closer to their children. They moved from a park that had
many more amenities. Hagy said the couple was not given any indication a
rent increase would be pursued.

“Thunderbird management is simply trying to take advantage of elderly
individuals living in our neighborhood,” said Hagy, a retired
registered nurse. “The rent stabilization ordinance is intended to
protect us against these very actions and Thunderbird should not be
allowed to proceed with such an unjust rent increase.”

Hagy pointed out that senior citizens resorted to cutting medical
care, medicine, food and utilities to survive when faced with large rent
increases.

Dorothy Dean, 91, moved to the park with her husband and mother in
1978. Dean said she loves her home and thinks the proposed rent increase
is a shame. She can’t particularly afford a jump from $428.40 a month
to $750.92, but she has no intention of leaving.

“I’m going to croak here,” she said, adding that when she read the
letter “I just thought of the people who couldn’t afford the raise. I
can’t afford it, but I can make it. I won’t have much to eat on.”

Residents are planning to meet Monday to discuss the matter. City
staff will release a report to the commission with their recommendations
at least three days before the commission meeting. The Rent Adjustment
Commission will have until Oct. 20 to render a decision.

Any decision can be appealed by the parties to the Thousand Oaks City Council.

Faulkner, who’s lived in the park for 14 years doesn’t know what he
will do if the proposed rent increase goes through. His rent of $373.40 a
month would jump to $695.92, according to the application submitted in
May to the city by Thunderbird Oaks’ owners.

“I just don’t know if it’s going to turn out all right,” Faulkner said. “It’s scary. It’s very, very scary for me.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: