With public housing rent owed, evictions feared

Friday, July 16, 2010
John Cote
San Francico Chronicle

The San Francisco Housing Authority has failed to collect rent from
more than a quarter of its households, in some cases for years,
resulting in a $2.2 million deficit that the agency is now trying to
reverse, Housing Authority documents show.

Facing federal pressure to undo years of mismanagement, the
authority has been sending public housing tenants formal notices
threatening eviction unless they pay thousands of dollars in back rent
starting this month.

Now hundreds of the city's poorest residents fear they will become
homeless, something officials say won't happen if tenants make a
good-faith effort and agree to payment plans.

"We realize these are tough economic times," said Henry Alvarez, the
authority's director. "There is no reason to throw people out on the
streets."

Almost 1,300 tenants have not been paying their rent on time,
including 21 tenants who owe more than $10,000 and one Potrero Terrace
resident who owes $28,000, according to a February 2009 report from the
authority, the most recent figures available.

Rebounding from backlog

The Housing Authority has had a backlog of at least $1 million in
unpaid rent since 2003, the report found, and the $2.2 million in total
uncollected rent as of last year could have funded about 22 full-time
positions such as custodians or maintenance workers at an agency that
has long been criticized for poor record keeping and lax upkeep.

Last year, the Housing Authority finally paid off the balance of a
$12 million court judgment to the families of a grandmother and five
children killed in a 1997 apartment fire after the agency was found
negligent for not installing a smoke detector or fixing a faulty heater
in the unit.

Housing Authority officials say the situation has improved notably
since Alvarez became director in July 2008. The rent backlog peaked at
$3 million in 2007, and the agency recently received a "most improved"
award from the local branch of the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development, which funds the agency and has been demanding that it
collect rent.

But some public housing residents and tenant advocates say the
recent steps to try to collect back rent have resulted in people being
erroneously charged and wrongly facing the prospect of eviction.

"The whole problem is entrenched in the culture of public housing -
that it wasn't a big deal if you paid your rent or not," said Sara
Shortt, executive director of the Housing Rights Committee of San
Francisco, which promotes tenants' rights. "We understand people are
expected to pay rent in exchange for their housing, but how do you even
properly do it at this point? There are so many cases where the Housing
Authority hasn't kept proper files. ... Who knows what this tenant
really owes?"

Conflicting paperwork

Anna Stephens, 49, an administrative assistant and single mother,
says she has regularly paid her $156 monthly rent on her two-bedroom
apartment in the Ingleside Heights neighborhood for years. In April,
she received a notice saying she owes the Housing Authority $9,750 in
back rent and faces eviction.

It wasn't the first time. The Housing Authority sued her in 2007,
saying she owed $1,752 in back rent dating to 2006. Stephens, in court
filings, said she was being retaliated against for complaining about
the security in the building, denied owing back rent, and said it
wasn't owed because the Housing Authority hadn't addressed mold,
defective appliances and other needed repairs. The authority dropped
that lawsuit three months later, court records show.

Now, Stephens said she is repeating the same battle. Her current
tenant accounting ledger shows an outstanding balance of $2,500 in
February 2006, but a separate housing authority agreement from the same
month shows $896 due. Stephens also produced copies of a $616 money
order to the authority for the bulk of that, but the payment is not
reflected in the ledger. She has copies of checks and money orders for
rent since then, although more than a year's worth is missing, said
Stephens, who plans to meet today with the Housing Authority.

"It's just kind of frustrating and maddening," Stephens said. "I might be evicted."

Lisa Romero, 27, a single mother raising four young children, lives
in the Ping Yuen housing development in Chinatown. She said she fell
behind in rent after being laid off from her job as an administrative
assistant at UCSF in May 2009. But Romero said her rent wasn't properly
adjusted after she lost her job and she hasn't been given a total
breakdown of her payments and what she owes.

HUD requires residents' rent be calculated on a family's monthly income or the set minimum rent, which is $25 in San Francisco.

An e-mail from Romero's property manager indicates she has an
outstanding balance of $2,117 and needs to pay $185 a month until that
is paid off. Her unemployment benefits expired last month, and Romero
said her family survives on about $300 a month from welfare. She
regularly bundles her kids into the car in the morning for outings
because she can't afford to pay for parking.

Seeking fair results

"It's very impossible for me to make a large payment right now,"
Romero said. "I don't know if they're actually doing the math right."

Alvarez acknowledged concerns about past record keeping.

"If the argument is, 'I don't think you're correctly counting my rent,' then let's have that conversation," Alvarez said.

Advocates welcomed the pledge that residents won't be evicted if
they agree to payment plans but are skeptical it will result in fair
agreements.

"The real issue is it must get translated down to the level of the
property managers and their assistants," Shortt said. "That's on top of
really good outreach that essentially overrides the message ... that
says you owe thousands of dollars and could be evicted."

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: