After her apartment was repeatedly broken into, Georgina Jenkins
thought she had found a ticket out of Alemany, the public housing
project known to residents as the Black Hole. The San Francisco Housing
Authority had placed her on its priority transfer list, reserved for
tenants facing immediate danger or urgent medical need, according to
Jenkins and her attorney.
Jenkins, a 25-year-old aspiring medical technician, said she was
offered a unit at North Beach Place, a renovated project on the other
side of the city. She was preparing to move when she was informed in
March that her security problem, dire as it was, could not be resolved
until she paid thousands of dollars in back rent.
Sitting in her darkened apartment, with holes in the wall and a
boarded-up bathroom window, Jenkins said she was tired of waiting — the
last break-in was in February.
“Anybody that has an emergency transfer needs to be moved in a nice amount of time,” she said. “I’m trying to get out of here.”
There are 246 people on the Housing Authority’s little-known
priority transfer list, according to the agency. Jenkins’s
still-unresolved case underscores the complicated issues that arise as
San Francisco tries to overhaul its crime-plagued public housing
buildings, which have about 6,000 units.
According to documents released in late May under a public records
request by Bay Area Legal Aid, which represents low-income communities,
233 people — or 95 percent of those on the list — have waited more than
three months to be relocated, and 176 have waited more than a year. The
list, which is compiled by the Housing Authority in consultation with
the police, includes people seeking protection from hate crimes,
violence, repeated robberies, domestic abuse and medical conditions
that may be worsened by their surroundings.
Tenants rights advocates say the statistics show that the Housing
Authority is failing in its most basic function: keeping low-income
residents safe.
“If 95 percent of your emergency cases are three months out and
still waiting, it doesn’t seem much like an emergency,” said Minouche
Kandel, a lawyer at Bay Area Legal Aid.
Housing officials acknowledge that the delays are a serious problem.
But they say they are the result of a lack of space — 28,000 people are
awaiting public housing in San Francisco — and other factors that have
little to do with security. As the city renovates public housing units
across the city, it is turning over management of some facilities to
private companies that, by most accounts, have made them cleaner and
safer — but they have also made it much harder to gain admittance.
North Beach Place, a gated, clean community near Fisherman’s Wharf, is one of them.
“We don’t have the inventory of units where people want to go;
that’s really the dilemma on the transfer list,” Henry A. Alvarez III,
executive director of the Housing Authority, said in an interview.
As a result, some residents whom city officials and the police have
deemed to be in immediate need of protection have been unable to gain
admittance to the buildings where they would be safest.
In March 2008, for example, Alejandro Aguilar, a 40-year-old day
laborer, severely beat a woman in her apartment at Valencia Gardens, a
public housing development in the Mission district, according to police
records and an account by the victim. After being taken into custody,
Aguilar said twice that “next time” he intended to kill the woman,
according to the police.
Aguilar was charged with assault after the woman accused him of attempted rape.
Terrified by the threats and by the prospect of testifying against
Aguilar, the woman was placed on the priority transfer list. But after
she was shown an apartment at North Beach Place, the facility’s
manager, the John Stewart Company, denied her an apartment because of
bad credit, according to e-mail messages between the Housing Authority,
the company, and the woman’s advocates at the Housing Rights Committee
of San Francisco.
Justine Minnis, an official with the John Stewart Company, wrote in
an e-mail message in July 2008 that the woman “did not meet the
resident selection criteria,” because her “credit history has changed
since she was originally screened at Valencia Gardens.”
Loren Sanborn, a senior vice president with the management company,
said screening criteria were important to the success of North Beach
Place.
“We believe that everyone should be treated the same,” Sanborn said.
Eventually, the Housing Authority, which is strapped because of
budget cuts, agreed to intervene to guarantee any unpaid rent owed to
the management company and cover the woman’s moving expenses up to
$50,000. She finally moved in September 2008.
“Under normal general circumstances, that’s not something we want to
be doing, but this was one of those extreme cases,” said Alvarez, the
executive director.
But Alvarez, who was brought in to clean up the troubled agency two
years ago, did not fault the John Stewart Company for wanting to
maintain higher standards. North Beach Place, he said, has become one
of the most sought-after facilities in the city.
“If we’re going to create this opportunity where people say, ‘This
is what I want,’ then I think there are going to be different
expectations of what is required to participate,” Alvarez said.
“Whether one argues if that is too harsh or not too harsh, I have to
look at the results.”
But advocates for public housing residents said the rules got in the way of keeping people safe.
“What we can’t tolerate is when we get to that point when you
finally get people out of their violent situation and then they are not
be able to access it for arbitrary reasons,” said Sara Shortt,
executive director of the Housing Rights Committee, a tenants rights
organization.
Shortt said that it was a violation of the public housing code to
deny housing to people facing security risks based on factors like bad
credit. Shortt and others have been trying to get the Housing Authority
to make private management companies drop the screening requirements
for priority transfer cases.
It took Marvella Branner two years to move from Westside Courts, in
the Fillmore district, to North Beach. Living on the third floor and
struggling with severe asthma, Branner had trouble climbing the stairs
and was worried that paramedics who frequently took her to the hospital
would someday be unable to reach her in time. She said she sought
placement on the priority transfer list in 2007 and was finally moved
last fall.
The Housing Authority said it now had more vacancies in older and
more crime-ridden projects like Sunnydale and Alice Griffith, both in
southeast San Francisco. In some cases, tenants on the priority
transfer list are refusing relocations to older facilities, believing
they are no more safe than where they currently live.
Carolyn Pollard, 48, was offered a transfer earlier this month after
the third break-in at her apartment in Sunnydale, the city’s largest
project, situated below McLaren Park. But Pollard, who lives with her
daughter and a 4-year-old grandson, turned down the transfer because
the offered home was in Hunters Point, which also has serious crime
problems.
“My son is from the Western Addition, and if he comes down to visit
me and his son, who knows what’s going to happen?” said Pollard, who
pays $231 a month for her apartment.
Pollard, a cheerful woman whose nickname is Tootie, said she spent
weekends with relatives to get away from Sunnydale. She leaves in place
a wooden board that a repairman put over a broken window in her living
room — even though the glass has been repaired.
“They’re just going to break it again, right?” she said. “I told them to leave it there."
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.