Residents of the Rancho de Calistoga mobile home park say they want to appeal a recent decision hiking their rents $60 per month, but they cannot afford to do so without help.
A outside arbitrator ruled in July that the mobile home park’s owner, HCA Management, was entitled to an increase in rent on the 184 lots, but he granted only about a third of what the company had been asking.
Residents complained that even the smaller increase poses an intolerable burden on them, since so many rely on limited incomes such as pensions and Social Security.
Current rents vary at the park, but the average is $537.59 after the latest increase.
They have until mid-October to ask a court to reverse the increase.
“We’d like to go ahead with it, but we spent $30,000” on legal work during the arbitration, said Marvin Braun, a member of the legal committee of the residents association. “We don’t have the money.”
Residents are hoping that an attorney will volunteer to take the case without charge, known as “pro bono.” Braun said paying for a legal challenge would cost at least $20,000, according to people advising the residents.
The head of Novato-based HCA, Dean Moser, declined to comment on any aspect of the case, including whether the company will file its own appeal, asking for more than the $60 the arbitrator awarded.
The amount mobile home parks can raise rents is limited by a city ordinance: no more than 6 percent per year or the rate of the federal Consumer Price Index, whichever is less. It also allows park owners to pass along the costs of major improvements to the property or to meet unforeseeable expenses.
To make larger hikes, more than three times the CPI rate, park owners must go through a lengthy process of notifying the residents and the city, offering evidence that the hike is justified, and submitting to arbitration to settle disagreements.
The owners had asked last fall to increase rents to $625 per lot, saying that the city ordinance had artificially limited annual income of the owners and hurt the value of the park.
While rents had gone up slightly over the years in line with the city ordinance, it had been 16 years since the owners had been granted a substantial increase, when another arbitrator granted a $50-per-space hike in 1995.
In a series of hearings earlier this year, the owners argued that the ordinance cost them about $381,000 per year that they could have been earning and had destroyed more than $4.7 million in the value of the property. They argued that this was an unconstitutional infringement on their property rights and demanded the rent increase to compensate.
Residents, however, argued that the company’s annual income had been rising at a reasonable rate, in line with the city’s ordinance, and that no extraordinary increase was justified.
Moreover, they complained that the owners had reduced the level of services to residents by closing a Victorian mansion on the site that had served as a clubhouse and community center. The owners had said the property needed extensive repairs that they could not afford and that the structure was no longer safe for public use.
The arbitrator, retired Judge Scott Snowden, sympathized with HCA’s argument, saying it was clear that the owners deserved more rent than was allowed under the city ordinance. The size of the hike the company had requested, however, was too steep, he said.
Braun said that if the residents can find a way to get into court, they will argue that Snowden exceeded his authority and ignored the will of the City Council when it constructed the current rent control ordinance.
“He performed a legislative action,” Braun said.
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.