Rent Control Board wants powers expanded

Thursday, June 3, 2010
Nick Taborek
Santa Monica Daily Press

CITY HALL — In a bid to significantly broaden the
scope of tenant protections in Santa Monica, the Rent Control Board
wants to bolster rules that protect against evictions and extend those
protections to cover all tenants in the city, rather than just those
who live in rent-controlled apartments.

To take effect, the
proposed changes would require Santa Monica voters to approve several
amendments to the Rent Control Agency's charter.

Voters could
get to decide on the amendments in November, if the City Council
approves the Rent Control Board's recommendations and places the
proposed amendments on the ballot. The council is set to consider the
proposals on June 8.

In addition to extending "just-cause"
eviction protections to all tenants in Santa Monica, the proposed
amendments would give renters additional time to correct lease
violations before they could be served with an eviction notice and
would afford added eviction protections to senior citizens and those
who are disabled or terminally ill.

"Just cause" protections
affect the eviction process in cases where a landlord alleges a tenant
has breached a contract, created a nuisance, refused to execute a
written lease extension, damaged the premises or denied the landlord
access to the rented unit.

The five-member Rent Control Board on May 27 voted
4-1 to recommend that the council place the proposed charter amendments
before voters. Commissioner Robert Kronovet, who owns property in the
city, cast the dissenting vote.

"Especially in this economically
tumultuous time I think anything the Rent Control Board can help do to
provide more stability in the community through enhanced tenant
protections would be good," said Rent Control Board Commissioner
Jennifer Kennedy, who requested the board take action on the proposed
amendments.

Kennedy, who many believe may seek a City Council
seat in this year's municipal election, asked the board to recommend
the changes after the Rent Control Agency's annual report in May showed
that 74 percent of eviction notices the agency tallied between 2005 and
2009 were for breach of contract or nuisance.

Under one of the
proposed amendments, renters who receive those types of notices could
be entitled to additional time to change their behavior in order to
avoid eviction, said Rent Control Administrator Tracy Conden.

Conden added the proposed changes "could help stabilize the community a
little bit and provide some civility in terms of the interactions
between owners and tenants."

The landlord group Action Apartment Association, though, immediately declared its opposition to the proposals.

Rosario
Perry, the association's attorney, said the proposed amendments would
have "unintended and horrible consequences" for apartment owners in
Santa Monica and would force landlords out of the rental business. He
said he would file a lawsuit to prevent the proposals from appearing on
November's ballot.

"What they're trying to do now is impose rent control on new units," he said.

The
proposal to give tenants additional time to correct lease violations,
he said, is based on faulty legal arguments and is vulnerable to a
challenge in court.

He said the idea of extending eviction
protections to non rent-controlled units is essentially meaningless,
because apartment owners could always just raise the rent to force a
problem tenant out.

But according to a report on the proposal
by the Rent Control Board's general counsel, Maichaelyn Jones, the
extension of protections to all units would afford real benefits to
tenants, including those who live in units that once fell under the
Rent Control Agency's jurisdiction but lost their rent control status
because of the owner-occupancy exemption.

Action's president,
Wes Wellman, also criticized the proposals as "generally unnecessary
solutions in search of problems" but indicated the proposal to give
elderly tenants and others with special needs may have merit.

"It
is hard to argue against eviction protections for the terminally ill,
the genuinely disabled or financially strapped seniors," he said. "But
loopholes should be closed for dubious disabilities induced by stress,
from other creative mental origins or from substance abuse. Affluent
seniors should not be shielded under the sympathetic umbrella raised
for the truly needy."

Patricia Hoffman, who chairs the political
party Santa Monicans for Renters' Rights, said SMRR would back the
proposals if they appear on the ballot in November.

"Our highest
priority is to protect people in their units so they can age in place,
so anything that facilitates that, I think, is good for the tenants of
Santa Monica, and ultimately good for the homeowners, too," she said.

If
the amendments are approved, it would be the fourth change to the Rent
Control Agency's charter since the rent control law was enacted in
1979. Amendments to the charter were made in 1984, 1999 and 2002,
respectively.

The Rent Control Board last week also suggested
the City Council consider increasing relocation fees paid to tenants
who are evicted because of owner occupancy and expanding the relocation
ordinance to cover more tenants.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: