In an ongoing debate about rent control
legislation on his Goleta property, Rancho Mobile Home Estates, real
estate mogul Daniel Guggenheim is attempting to carry his case to the
United States Supreme Court.
The series of appeals stretches back
to 2009, when Guggenheim persuaded the city council to approve plans
converting the park into condominiums through a legal loophole,
requiring residents to either purchase the land their mobile homes rest
on or lose rent control protection in as little as seven years. After
the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals voted 8-3 against him last December,
Guggenheim enlisted former U.S. Solicitor General Ted Olson as his
attorney to take the case to Washington, D.C.
Goleta City Attorney
Tim Giles said Guggenheim had little precedent to attempt to evade the
legislation as he purchased the mobile home park in 1997, knowing that
it was protected under Santa Barbara County rent control ordinance.
“Mr.
Guggenheim got exactly what he purchased, which was a park subject to
rent control,” Giles said. “And what this case was about was giving him a
windfall just because the city [became] incorporated.”
According
to Giles, Guggenheim sought to push the boundaries of the ordinance to
exact more profit from tenants after the incorporation of the City of
Goleta in 2002.
The Supreme Court consents to only a portion of the petitions it receives throhout the year.
Despite
Olson’s impressive credentials — including arguing against California’s
Prop 8’s constitutionality — Giles said it is unlikely Guggenheim’s
appeals will go any further.
“[Olson] has an excellent reputation
and a tremendous amount of experience with the Supreme Court,” Giles
said. “The problem is the Supreme Court takes on very few cases, and
they take cases based upon the decisions of the courts below, or the
decisions of the court of appeals and not on the personality of the
attorney.”
Additionally, Giles said the Court of Appeal’s decision
is clear and well reasoned, and he doubts the Supreme Court would
accept a case so specific to the parties involved, instead of an issue
that would establish broad legal precedent.
“I think that they are
going to look at this, and look at the facts and the law here and see
that this is not something they want to waste their precious time on,”
Giles said.