Council will adopt, publish ordinance one more time to avoid threatened litigation
An ordinance to stabilize rents for tenants of mobile home parks will go
before the Ukiah City Council one more time to make sure all the
required steps were completed exactly as needed.
After discussing, drafting and finally adopting a mobile home park
rent-stabilization ordinance last fall, the council will need to adopt
it again, City Attorney David Rapport said at the last meeting Dec. 15.
"Once the ordinance is adopted, the council needs to publish it in its
entirety within 15 days of the adoption," Rapport said, explaining that
when the ordinance was adopted previously, the city did publish it the
Ukiah Daily Journal within the proper timeframe, but due to the file's
size, it was published over two issues of the newspaper rather than all
in one.
City Manager Jane Chambers said Bruce and Judy Hatch, owners of one of
the city's mobile home parks, pointed out the discrepancy, and to avoid
any question about the legality of the ordinance, the city will adopt,
then publish it again in one issue.
Rapport said the ordinance can be adopted in the council's consent
agenda, which would not require a separate vote. If it is adopted at the
council's next meeting Jan. 5, it would take effect 30 days following
on Feb. 4.
After discussing possible ordinances, the council drafted and adopted an
ordinance similar to the one in effect in Santa Rosa, which establishes
a base rent and limits any increase to 100 percent of the consumer price index (CPI), as long as it is 6 percent or less.
If an owner feels the CPI does not provide a "fair return" on the
investment, he or she can seek an increase through a formal arbitration
process.
Lisa Hillegas, an attorney who represents low-income families and seniors in Ukiah, urged the city to follow Santa Rosa's lead.
"I strongly encourage the city to adopt the Santa Rosa ordinance - it is
far superior (to others)," Hillegas said. "It guarantees what the rent
increases will be and puts the burden on the park owner (to prove the
increases are not enough)," while other ordinances require the residents
to protest increases, sometimes as often as every six months.
Hillegas said residents of mobile home parks - which she described as
largely single women over 60 - have a "special vulnerability" and are a
"captive audience" for park owners.
"This is the only housing they will be able to own and afford," she
said. "I (hope we can) preserve one of the very few ways we have to
offer home ownership for our low-income residents."
Numerous seniors then addressed the council to ask for an ordinance
while dozens more sat in the audience, applauding in approval.
"We are so powerless," said Manor Oaks resident Jessie Martin,
explaining that she dreads the time each year when rent increases are
expected, wondering if she will be able to stay in her home. "There's no
rhyme or reason now to the rent increases. If I had some idea about
what kind of increase (there would be), I could plan ahead."
Council member Phil Baldwin lobbied strongly and consistently for an
ordinance "that (incorporates) the best features of the Santa Rosa
ordinance," while the rest of the council expressed reservations.
When it finally came time to vote on the ordinance, Council member Doug Crane was the sole "no" vote.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.