When Governor Paterson proposed changes to the city's rent regulation laws, criticism poured in from both tenants' groups and landlords.
Pro-tenant organizations, concerned with the deregulation of 190,000
units since 1994, pointed out that the changes would do nothing to
prevent the loss of rent-regulated apartments over the long term.
Landlords, on the other hand, argued that the system currently protects
rent levels for high-income households that do not need assistance.
Paterson proposed a change to the provision that allows
rent-regulated apartments to be deregulated once the rent reaches
$2,000 and the apartment becomes vacant--a provision known as vacancy
decontrol. Since 1994 about 84,000 apartments have been deregulated
through vacancy decontrol, further reducing the number of "affordable"
apartments on the market. The proposed change would raise the threshold
to $3,000.
But neither of these monthly rent levels, $2,000 or $3,000, are
affordable for low-income families. Affordable housing is generally
defined as 30 percent of a family's income. At $2,000 a month, an
apartment would be affordable only to families earning more than
$80,000. A family would have to earn $120,000 for a $3,000 a month
apartment to be affordable.
Real reform would either prevent rents in rent-regulated apartments
from reaching this level in the first place or would aggressively
pursue ways to add to the rent-regulated housing stock to make up for
the units being lost to vacancy decontrol. On average, 6,800 units are
added to the rent-regulated rolls every year, nowhere near enough to
make up for the 14,000 units that are lost on an annual basis.
A new report
that examines rent regulation in New York City recommends that changes
be made that would deregulate even more apartments. The recommendation
is based on the assumption that rent regulation is an "inefficient"
tool for preserving rental affordability for low-income families.
Even more important, the report inadvertently highlights just why
rent regulation is a vital tool for keeping more families from falling
into homelessness. The report estimates the effect that deregulating
all of the city's regulated apartments would have on rent levels.
Overall rents would go down, the authors contend, but only because a
number of households would drop out of the housing market completely,
"Some households obtaining regulated housing would not be able (or
choose) to compete for housing in an unregulated market."
In other words, these families would be homeless.
As the city loses 14,000 units every year, there is little surprise
that the city is experiencing record levels of homelessness.
The city's affordability crisis is a challenge that must be met on
multiple fronts. Stemming the loss of rent regulated units--either by
preventing rents from reaching the $2,000 mark or by significantly
adding new regulated units--is a good first step. We must also raise
the income levels of low-income households. A citywide minimum wage
should be established that will allow a full-time working family to
earn enough money to rent a suitable apartment without the need of
government assistance. Third, as the report also points out, we need to
encourage more residential construction, but in a way that also creates
opportunities for affordable housing construction. This means beefing
up the city's inclusionary housing program so that more affordable
units are created. Finally, the federal government must pursue a
housing strategy that helps cities like New York create affordable
rental housing, rather than propping up home values in the suburbs.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.