Rent Protection Talk Exposes Community Rift: Landlord and Tenant Tensions Flare over Eviction Regulation

Wednesday, July 15, 2015
Austin Walsh
Daily Journal

A meeting intended to discuss potential ways to relieve the burden on Burlingame renters turned into a debate over the merits of an ordinance guaranteeing eviction protections for tenants during a City Council study session.

In an effort to combat a growing local housing crisis, Mayor Terry Nagel called a special meeting Monday, July 13, which was designed as an opportunity for officials to develop strategies to aid residents faced with an escalating cost of living.

What ensued though was a clash between property owners, apartment management representatives and advocates for renters over whether the city should consider instituting an ordinance which would regulate the ability of landowners to evict tenants.

In a memo authored by Nagel circulated prior to the meeting, a tenant protection ordinance was identified as a possible means of defending renters against landlords.

The ordinance, commonly referred to as a just cause eviction measure, could impose such restrictions as forbidding land owners from changing the terms of a lease more than once a year, requiring landlords to give renters more than 60 day notice before evicting them, protecting extremely ill tenants from losing their homes and requiring property owners to pay for the cost of relocating tenants evicted without justification.

Joshua Howard, senior vice president of the California Apartment Association, said he opposed officials considering a just cause measure, as it would likely have unintended consequences, and severely restrict the rights of landlords and property owners to evict tenants who adversely impact the lives of others living near them.

He said such an ordinance often leads to drawn-out legal battles between tenants and landlords, which can be difficult for all parties.

“The only winners in just cause evictions tend to be lawyers,” he said.

Ross Bruce, of AVR Realty in Burlingame, echoed those sentiments.

“Please allow me to protect my tenants,” he said. “And just cause prevents that.”

Cynthia Cornell, of Burlingame Advocates for Renter Protections, though said she disagreed and favored officials considering implementing the ordinance because it would grant greater defenses for tenants.

Officials should favor protections for residents who are being unfairly evicted, said Cornell.

The debate regarding the rights of tenants takes place in the wake of a series of rent hikes across the city, which have driven some Burlingame residents from their homes, and brought into focus a conversation regarding rent control, among other issues.

Due to Measure T, which voters approved in 1988, officials cannot enact any ordinance which would impact rental rates in Burlingame.

Vice Mayor Ann Keighran expressed a firm opposition against imposing a just cause ordinance which would restrict the rights of landlords to evict tenants, in part because she felt many of the rent hikes some renters have received are within the legal discretion of property owners.

Commonly landlords will invest heavily in purchasing or renovating a residential development, then increase the rent to tenants, which should not be considered an eviction, said Keighran, but rather a private property owner exercising their rights.

Councilman Michael Brownrigg also expressed reservations regarding whether imposing a just cause ordinance would address the issue of significant rent hikes facing tenants.

“I don’t think our landlords are evicting people unjustly,” he said. “I don’t think this solves a problem that exists. I find this to be a really bitter battle over almost nothing.”

San Mateo County Supervisor Dave Pine and Bill Lowell, director of the San Mateo County Department of Housing, were also present at the meeting to give city officials perspective on the county’s efforts to address similar concerns throughout the region.

Burlingame officials agreed to wait for the findings from a pending county report to glean more information about the housing crisis throughout the Peninsula, with intent of developing a more definite strategy regarding how to combat the issue.

“This is a huge, huge problem,” said Councilman Ricardo Ortiz. “It is a regional problem.”

Nagel said she would favor imposing a fee on developers who are building office and residential projects in Burlingame, which could be spent to subsidize affordable housing.

Projections estimate 24 million square feet of office and commercial space will be built in San Mateo County over the next four to five years, which Burlingame could capitalize on to benefit the 52 percent of city residents who rent their home, said Nagel.

The council had also been asked by Nagel to further consider the feasibility of such renter protections as instituting a mediation service which would negotiate disputes between renters and landlords, encouraging the development of second units at existing residences and establishing a best practices guide for landlords.

Ultimately, the council opted to gather more information before moving forward toward any of the potential protections.

“I don’t think we have enough raw data to know what to study,” said Brownrigg. 

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: