In the history of San Francisco rent control wars, landlord Edward Litke
may not have committed the most egregious violations. But he's now on
the hook for a huge payoff to some of his former tenants. Last week,
the California Court of Appeals
upheld a $1.2 million judgment against him in a wrongful eviction case
involving a family who had lived in one of Litke's apartments for more
than 40 years.
Robert De Vries, an attorney with 30 years of experience in landlord, tenant, and real estate law, says that the award to Jorge Chacon and his family is a lot for a rental violation case in San Francisco. "I would say this is definitely a top 10," he said.
Experts say landlords typically settle cases through insurance rather than risk going to court.
Litke owns buildings across the city and has an estimated net worth
of $40 million, according to court documents. In the past 15 years, 18
of his tenants have complained about him to the San Francisco Tenants
Union, manager Ted Gullicksen said.
The trouble began in 2004, when the Chacons complained about the
dilapidated state of their rent-controlled four-bedroom home at 264
Dolores. By that point, three generations of the family were living in
the apartment, which they rented for roughly $700 a month. Jorge, the
patriarch, had lived there since 1963.
Litke claimed he couldn't repair the apartment unless the family moved out, and he served them with an eviction notice.
When the Chacons moved, they assumed they were leaving for only
three months. "It was never an issue of, 'Wow, we're out of there for
good,'" Jorge's daughter, Tania, testified during the trial. "No, this
was our home."
But when the Chacons asked when they could move back in, Litke
claimed they had forfeited their lease. Court papers say he changed the
locks, and even forbade them to return to reclaim the belongings they
had left in the apartment.
Unable to afford San Francisco rents, the family split up among apartments in Hayward, South San Francisco, and Fremont.
Tania, who was studying for law school exams while caring for her baby,
considered moving into a homeless shelter with her fiancé. Jorge and
his wife, Gilma, moved from place to place. At least once, the elderly
couple slept on the floor of their son's office.
The Chacons initiated a wrongful eviction action against Litke in
San Francisco Superior Court in 2006. Two years later, the trial court
judge, Suzanne Bolanos,
ruled in their favor, using a complicated formula and expert witness
testimony to determine that Jorge and Gilma would have spent another 20
years in the apartment. Bolanos calculated the "loss of use" value over
those 20 years at $382,000, which she trebled to more than $1.1
million. She also awarded the family another $90,000 for emotional
distress.
Meanwhile, Litke never even tried to rent out the Chacons' apartment at a higher rate. He left it empty.
Litke's lawyer, Michael Johnson,
did not return requests for comment. A woman who identified herself
only as an employee of Edward Litke said that he was 84 years old and
too sick to speak to the media. The Chacons also declined to comment.
Full disclosure: One of the Chacons' attorneys also represents SF Weekly.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.