Rent wars rage on

Monday, May 24, 2010
Bill Bauer
Santa Monica Daily Press

Santa Monica's gonzo Action Apartment Association is
up to its old tricks. They've filed another lawsuit in Santa Monica
Superior Court challenging Santa Monica's 31-year-old rent control
laws. And, yes Virginia, it's an election year.

Action's latest
complaint contends that apartment owners haven't been allowed to "pass
through" to tenants the full cost of five property tax surcharges
established since 1979 when rent control took effect.

Action's
attorney Rosario Perry says the formula used by Rent Control
Administration to determine annual rent increases does not take into
account the real costs of this tax liability even though the current
formula does add two percent annually each year to a property's
accessed value. If Action prevails, it is predicted that rents in a
rent-controlled building would rise by $140 per month for the average
tenant.

Perry claims owners can only add these costs on to new
rentals by charging higher rents to incoming tenants while older,
established tenants get a free pass, But, I'm thinking that most owners
have probably been adding these tax costs on to their new tenants'
"market rate" rents for years. Nevertheless, Perry still claims it's
unequal treatment and "unfair and unjustified"

Hello! All this
time, I thought landlords were just asking for high rents because new
tenants would pay them. And, isn't the key reason for rent control to
protect long-term, senior and low-income tenants and preserve their
housing?

Perhaps Perry could convince owners to rent out
their vacant units at lower "rent control rates" instead of at inflated
market rates. Then everything would be "fair and equal." Fat chance
that's going to happen.

Costs of taxes such as college and
school bond, school parcel taxes and 2006's "Clean Beaches and Ocean"
taxes are now fully passed on to tenants. Owners don't pay one cent of
these "voter approved" taxes. So, in the interest of equality and fair
play, maybe City Hall should require landlords to pay a percentage of
these costs, too? How about it, Rosario?

Since 1979, apartment
buildings have substantially increased in value. Most property owners
are enjoying handsome capital gains. Isn't it "only fair and equitable"
they share their gains with tenants? Anybody want to sue landlords on
this issue?

Action Apartment Association has been in the
forefront with numerous legal challenges to the city's rent control
laws since the beginning of rent control. They haven't prevailed in
most cases. A similar complaint dealing with constitutionality issues
was dismissed by the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, In December
of 2007

In July 2004, Action sued City Hall stating that Santa
Monica's rent control laws were allegedly in violation of the 5th
amendment. Action's WAM newsletter trumpeted, "This lawsuit is the
mother of all lawsuits and we will seek to have the federal court
declare that Santa Monica, West Hollywood and Los Angeles' rent control
laws are unconstitutional. Once and for all, we will wipe out the
regulatory processes of this SMRR (Santa Monicans for Renters' Rights)
city council (sic) which seeks to harbor rich tenants on our properties
to enrich their economic life style." Oh, brother.

Action lost
and their badly-timed legal assault and their "chest-thumping" handed
SMRR a big victory in the fall elections. It appears that Action and
its counsel were so self-centered and selfish, they didn't care about
the blowback.

In the meantime, Rent Control Administration has
recommended a two percent annual rent increase for September 2010
through August 2011 for rent controlled units. While I'm sure apartment
owners will piss and moan about being "robbed," it's a reasonable
compromise. A person paying $900 monthly rent will face an $18 increase.

Congratulations
to the Rent Control Administration for its good work. The full Rent
Control Board will vote on the recommendation at its June 1 meeting and
City Council will officially certify the increase this summer.

Bigger and dumber

Item
8-B on this week's City Council agenda is the review of Development
Agreement for a 284-room hotel/commercial project at Seventh Street and
Wilshire Boulevard. The project would retain and remodel the landmark
Santa Monica Professional Building and add a seven floor (81-feet high)
tower with a rooftop pool at the rear of the property.

Required
community benefits proposed include a mixed-use, deed-restricted
(affordable/ workforce/senior) housing project with ground floor retail
and on a separate property at 1218 Lincoln Blvd. Improvements to Reed
Park, on-site bike and car rental and local recruiting and hiring
preference are also possibilities. The benefits are insufficient for
this oversized project.

Holy political correctness! Item 13- C
is interim Councilmember Terry O'Day's request that council adopt a
resolution denouncing Arizona's recently approved anti-Illegal
immigration law and approve a boycott of Arizona businesses. Please,
Terry. You're not running for the Senate ... yet.

Instead of
this inanity, "environmentalist" O'Day should call for boycotting Japan
because of their ongoing slaughters of whales, dolphins and other
endangered sea creatures. Remember "The Hump?"

Bill Bauer can be reached at mr.bilbau@gmail.com.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: