Renters aren’t roaches

Saturday, May 29, 2010
Adrienne Belz
World Journalism Institute Times Observer

NEW YORK CITY – The roaches, mold, mushrooms, and leaky, sunken
corners of her apartment make up just part of the problem in Ingrid
Hernandez’ home on the 400th block of Audubon Avenue in Washington
Heights.

“[The landlords] want to be very strict about us fulfilling our part
of the contract – getting our payments in on time – but they don’t give
us the common courtesy to make sure their end is up to par,“ said
Hernandez.

Hernandez, 29, pays $946 each month for her one-bedroom apartment,
but everyone in the building pays a different amount mostly because
older tenants have a set rent amount – some of which have not changed
in the last thirty years. Steady rent amounts, also known as rent
control, means tenants have a price ceiling to protect them from being
taken advantage of. Some older tenants in Hernandez’ complex pay $500 a
month while new tenants pay $2000.

“Hence starts the issue – people are paying their rent and working
very hard, but then they get poor service,” said Angel Audiffred, the
chief of staff for City Council member Ydanis Rodriguez in the 10th
District of New York City.

According to Audiffred, because the landlords need to keep making
money, they let tenants live in the disintegrating apartment buildings.
Sometimes landowners clear out the apartment by turning off the hot
water or heat in the winter leading tenants to leave. Meanwhile the
landlords either sell out to a big corporation who will remodel or
repair the apartments to raise the price and rent it out to wealthier
people, said Audiffred.

Hernandez’ apartment complex is slowly decaying, and the tenants cry out for help.

Hernandez sees how her landowner wouldn’t have the biggest concern
for a building full of older people who have been paying $500 in rent
for the last 30 years, but she doesn’t get why her landlords don’t make
renovations on a derelict building.

Tenants such as Hernandez are tied to the area for familial and
financial reasons. She won’t leave her mother and she’s not in a
financial position to move. She wants to hold out to prove to the
management of her apartment that she won’t give up.

In 2008, the third floor stairwell fell completely when a tenant was
walking down, according to Hernandez. Last August, the gas line went
out in Hernandez apartment complex, and she said the lines haven’t been
fully repaired. “At the most it should have taken 60 or even 90 days,
but it’s been ten months,” said Hernandez.

Hernandez uses a portable mini electric stove on top of her
non-working stove in her apartment. “It’s traumatizing to live, day in
and day out, without gas  - and have to spend two hours cooking
something that should only take half an hour,” said Hernandez.

Hernandez contacted her manager to fix the problems, and maintenance
came in to patch up the cracks in walls and exterminate the vermin that
get in through the open wall the maintenance for.

The manager of Hernandez’ apartment lives in California though. Hernandez doesn’t know her manager’s name or business number.

How do some landowners sleep at night?” said Yokarina Duarte, the community liaison for Council Memeber Rodriguez.

Audiffred said, “People don’t want to stay in the building for six
months. They don’t want to fight the fight. And that’s where the
landowners beat the system.”

“At the end of the day, New York City defends the tenant over the landlord. They have to live with some help,” said Audiffred.

Although the tenants on the apartment complex on Audubon’s 400th
block started their own tenant group six months ago, Duarte said that
the City Council offers a little boost to the people pursuing reform.

The tenants in Hernandez’ complex are banning together for a rent
strike now. None of them will pay their rent to the landlord, but they
will put their rent into a joint bank account.

The tenants will pay their rents to the landowner after he makes the repairs on the building, according to Duarte.

Twenty-eight people from Hernandez’ complex have signed on to
boycott, according to Duarte. She went around on Thursday night,
knocking on doors to ask if they would become a part of the group.

Ideally Duarte would like to get at least half of the tenants - 31
tenants - to sign up to be a part of the rent strike. She said it’s
very hard to convince a person that they are able to go against his
landowner by not paying him the rent.

Many tenants think they will be evicted. The catch, according to
Duarte, is that tenants could go to court and explain that they didn’t
pay their rent because of poor upkeep and maintenance in apartment
complexes, which would secure them as trustworthy tenants.

Duarte is hopeful that the plan for tenant rent strike will work to bring justice for tenants.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

 

Help build power for renters' rights: