SFGate commenters are prolific. Unfortunately, much of the
commentary is ruthless, even offensive, a trend that's not only been
noticed by the Gate itself, but by other blogs.
This trend extends to all topics, even the most benign (movie reviews?
Mommy Files blogs?); but some of the most bitter vitriol is reserved
for any blog that makes mention of renting.
Though indeed offensive, the worst of these comments do give rise to interesting debate.
For instance, in a City Insider blog about Mayor Newsom vetoing legislation that would have extended just-cause eviction protection, one commenter, using the handle "yellav_eon" wrote:
Good for him. I do not even know why renters are allowed to vote on city issues. They have no vested interest in the city.
Cue outrage. As renters (and voters), we are dumbfounded. How to
even start responding to this? By this logic, well over half the city's
residents should be ineligible to vote on city issues. Only the landed
gentry should have this right, something that smacks of politics we
thought were killed off in the Revolutionary War.
A similar comment comes from regular contributor SFConservative 1, who posted this thought on Tracey Taylor's On the Block blog from yesterday:
Come on SF renters, put your money where your mouth
is? Leftist policies ruined SF, step up ad INVEST in the community you
supposedly hold so dear!
Since this blog was about buying now, instead of renting,
we can only assume SFConservative1 means that buying a home is the only
meaningful way to invest: as if a) renters, be they teachers, fire
fighters, police officers, artists, parks and rec workers-- be they
anything at all-- offer nothing if they don't own the house they sleep
in; or b) we can all afford to buy here. We're just being coy.
But to put this argument in balance, we have to admit that same
disproportionate renter population does have a curious effect on
elections. When renters vote on housing issues, specifically, the
results are worth a closer look: for instance, when rent control
initiatives make the ballot. In 2008, Prop 98 would have abolished both rent control and eminent domain.
The measure was soundly defeated, not just in SF but in CA at large, a
fact that reminds us California is home to more renters than owners.
Thus, it's hard to imagine any anti-rent control initiative ever
winning.
Some would say this unfair to owners. Others would say it is totally
fair: the city and state laws should serve the majority of people
living within, and that these elections are examples of democracy in
action. But other people don't think renters are intelligent enough to
vote at all, such as this commenter, "Always Buy," of The Front Steps, who was responding to a rent vs. buy article there .
Renters are generally more pessimistic, less
wealthy, less educated, and transient people with commitment issues.
Anybody with 10 years of work experience and still renting is definiely
(SIC)behind the ball.I feel sorry for people who were tricked into renting for the past 5 years while SF prices continue to go up.
Aside from being insulting, the comment is not very savvy, since we
all agree that no blanket statements will correctly cover the disparate
markets of different SF districts and neighborhoods. And these days, it
doesn't take very long to come with a list of recent sales showing
actual depreciation. Further, rent control might give a smart person a
strong reason not to buy: if a person is renting something
below market that provides more space, convenience, ease, luxury--
whatever matters to that person-- than he or she could get for the
price of a mortgage, well... what educated person would try to buy in
one of the most price-inflated cities in the world?
The irony of trying to say renters shouldn't vote is acute. Taking
away this right would be against the Constitution, and to use a tired
but apt term, totally un-American. Yet those who would say renters
shouldn't vote would point to the fact that their large numbers skew
elections unfairly to the renters' favor. The only way to fix that is
through government control of housing, ensuring that every American
could afford to buy a home. This would have to involve taking some of
the immense wealth away from the immensely wealthy, a move that would
be damned as socialist, Marxist, and, yes, most certainly: un-American.