It's been a good time to be a renter in Sonoma County, but change is on the way.
After years of slow-rising rents, investors and analysts are predicting increasing costs for people who live in rental units — and more revenue for the landlords who own them.
“Rents have only one direction to go,” said Kurt Zech, a senior managing director with Kennedy Wilson, a real estate investment firm that is betting on a stronger rental market.
The Beverly Hills company recently paid $68 million for a 492-unit apartment complex off Lakeville Highway in Petaluma. Two years earlier, the former Lakeville Resort complex sold for $52 million.
The deal for the complex, now named Enclave at Adobe Creek, makes good financial sense for investors, Zech said.
Predicted job growth will lead to the formation of new households and to more people seeking new digs, Zech said. Fewer people will be looking to buy homes and those seeking rentals will find the supply limited by a lack of new construction.
Many agree with that general outlook. But some add that the near-term pace of rent increases will be limited by the financial hardships that many renters suffered during the last few years.
“It's still tight. Every household has to watch every penny,” said Sarah Bridge, owner of RealFacts, an Novato research company specializing in the apartment market.
While Bridge still considers it a renter's market, she agrees the trends suggest that rents will rise in Sonoma County. However, the size of the increase will be tempered by landlords' desire to retain renters.
“They're going to back off if they see they're going to lose tenants,” she said.
The rental market is a large segment of the county's 180,000 houses, apartments and condominiums. Nearly four in 10 housing units in the county are occupied by renters, according to the U.S. Census Bureau.
Landlords have been reluctant to raise rents sharply during the recession. Rents in Sonoma County have increased just 5.3 percent in the past four years, according to RealFacts. During that same period the Consumer Price Index registered a gain of nearly 8.2 percent.
Sonoma County apartment rents averaged $1,183 in the fourth quarter of 2010, according to RealFacts. The occupancy rate was nearly 95 percent, which Bridge considers relatively balanced for both tenants and landlords.
But there are signs of change. Rents rose 2.5 percent in Sonoma County last year — the fourth-biggest increase among California's 26 metro areas.
Recessions often force renters to double up or move back in with relatives, leading to larger vacancy rates. But the latest downturn added a new twist as both renters and homeowners became displaced due to a wave of foreclosures.
At least 38 percent of all foreclosures in California last year involved houses with renters in them, according to the San Francisco-based renters' rights group Tenants Together. That amounted to more than 200,000 displaced tenants.
Experts said the impact of the lost homes has been hard to gauge on the rental market. But Keith Becker, owner of DeDe's Rentals in Santa Rosa, a company that oversees rental houses, said he regularly meets prospective tenants who previously were owners or renters in homes lost to foreclosure.
“The mortgage mess is still having an effect,” said Becker, secretary and past president of the North Coast Rental Housing Association. “It's not just the sale market. It also is stretching into the rental market.”
Among those affected is Derrick Hamner, who became a renter a year ago after going through a divorce and home foreclosure in Rohnert Park.
Hamner quickly signed a one-year lease for a two-bedroom apartment in the city. The rent was $1,135 a month. This winter it was going to jump to $1,235 a month.
Instead of re-signing, Hamner recently moved into a three-bedroom home in northeast Rohnert Park for $1,350 a month for himself and his two children. Most of the prospective houses he had looked at were priced at $1,500 a month or more.
“I was pretty happy,” Hamner said of the home. “The ones at this price were tough to find.”
Many experts predict that relatively few new rental units will be built in the county for several years. The same could be true for affordable housing units, which last year made up the vast majority of the 188 multi-family building permits issued in the county.
John Lowry, executive director of the nonprofit Burbank Housing in Santa Rosa, said in the next five years fewer dollars will be available from federal, state and local governments. Cities, for example, may see their redevelopment funds captured by the state, while few home builders will start projects and pay new development fees that help build subsidized housing.
“It's going to be lean times for affordable housing developments,” Lowry said.
The development costs for new apartments can exceed $200,000 a unit, experts said.
In comparison, Zech said, Kennedy Wilson was able to buy the Enclave at Adobe Creek property for about $138,000 per unit, considerably lower than the complex's replacement cost.
Scott Gerber, president of NorCal Commercial in San Rafael, has been tracking rental prices and occupancy rates in the North Bay for 16 years. If the county begins to see job growth, he said, the vacancy rate in the coming years could drop close to zero.
County landlords raised apartment rents by only 2.4 percent a year from 2001 to 2010, Gerber said. During those years, he said, many landlords didn't pass along double-digit increases on water and other utility bills.
Even so, he predicted that county rent increases overall will be limited to about 3.5 percent this year and perhaps 4 percent in 2012.
“This is a time when we normally would expect to see double-digit rent increases,” Gerber said, “but it's not going to happen because people don't have the money.”
FAIR
USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting
of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants
Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which
may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants
Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to
advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe
that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided
for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this
copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you
must obtain permission from the copyright owner.