Hundreds of buildings, from the South Bronx to central Brooklyn, whose
renovation and rescue from ruinous debt were critical to the rebirth of
blighted neighborhoods, are again in severe financial trouble. That
poses a dilemma for the city, which began unloading the properties in
the mid-1990s as part of an arduous effort to divest itself of
thousands of decrepit buildings seized because of tax delinquencies.
Filled with unemployed tenants unable to make rent or mortgage payments
and squeezed by soaring city fees, about 442 buildings are in serious
default on property taxes and far behind on municipal bills.
As the number of imperiled buildings grows, the city, struggling with
its own cash shortage, faces unappealing choices. Seizing the buildings
is not an option. The city’s previous role as a master landlord was
widely deemed a disaster, with many buildings locked in chronic states
of disrepair.
Instead, housing officials must either force deadbeat owners to pay
their debts, or else foreclose on the buildings and find new owners in
a harsh real estate climate. A total of $140 million is owed on the
buildings, and nearly half of them have arrears of at least $3,000 of
debt per unit, according to the city’s housing department.
Many of the buildings are now slipping into the kind of shoddy conditions from which they had been saved.
While the debt-ridden buildings are found across the city, the most are
clustered in Bedford-Stuyvesant and other parts of central Brooklyn,
the South Bronx and Harlem.
All are owned by private or nonprofit groups overseeing buildings that
were already deeply distressed and populated by the poorest of
residents, giving owners razor-thin margins to operate on. People
bought co-op apartments for as little as $250, according to the city,
while renters pay as little as $90 a month.
“More and more of these properties, especially the not-for-profits, are
not making their mortgages, not paying taxes, water,” said Douglas
Apple, first deputy commissioner of the city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development. “It’s gotten to the point where we are very concerned.”
In shedding its enormous real estate portfolio, once numbering nearly
9,000 buildings, the city steered ownership of the buildings to
tenants, nonprofits and private developers. Buildings were
rehabilitated, new tenants moved in, and neighborhoods were
transformed.
Once emblematic of a failed New York, the buildings came to symbolize a
city reborn. And most of the low-income buildings sold by the city are
still faring well, said Anne-Marie A. Hendrickson, a deputy
commissioner with the housing department.
Many owners diversified their income stream, Ms. Hendrickson said, by
adding the more lucrative buildings to their holdings or providing
social services and health care programs that let them collect
subsidies and other fees. That would be of little solace to the
residents of 1694 Davidson Avenue in the Morris Heights section of the
Bronx, a formerly city-owned 42-unit building where tenants say living
conditions have gone from to bad to worse.
The front door locks have long been broken. The garbage incinerator
stopped working for months, leading to a stomach-churning stink and
attracting raccoon-size rats.
Five years ago the elevator ground to a halt,
forcing children of one tenant, Nina Mitchell, to take turns last year
hoisting their mother, hobbled by a torn Achilles tendon, up and down
four flights of stairs, in her wheelchair, until she healed. Ms.
Mitchell, 37, is one of many tenants in the six-story building who have
stopped paying rent to protest living conditions.
“It’s like we’re under siege,” said Monique Jenkins, 39, president of the building’s tenant association.
The housing department is moving against the building’s owner, the
Bronx Heights Neighborhood Community Corporation, which owes $3.7
million in taxes and other arrears for 1694 Davidson Avenue and eight
nearby buildings it owns. The city has started foreclosure proceedings
against the nonprofit corporation’s entire portfolio.
The corporation lost a 10th building in a recent sheriff’s auction
after a judgment was issued against it by someone who fell in the
building and filed a lawsuit.
The group has failed to provide required financial reports to the city
for at least five years. “I’m at a loss to say where the money is going
if they’re not making municipal payments,” Ms. Hendrickson said.
Interviews with members of the corporation’s board elicited
finger-pointing about who was to blame for the nonprofit’s woes. Some
members said the board’s treasurer, Gbethea DevineBhutta, had failed to
pay bills and had turned board members against one another.
Ms. DevineBhutta denied the accusations and said the board had ignored
its responsibility to fill vacancies; there has been no executive
director for years. “It was like they were trying to close down Bronx
Heights,” she said.
Sergio Clark, the chairman of the board, said the city had been warned
of the corporation’s management problems but had done nothing. “It’s
one individual that single-handedly did damage to this nonprofit
corporation, but the city itself is insensitive to the needs of
nonprofit corporations,” he said.
Some housing advocates said the financial troubles of several hundred
buildings paled in comparison with the collection of crumbling
buildings the city once owned. When the portfolio was at its height, in
1979, the city owned 8,950 buildings, or 110,000 housing units. Today
it owns about 190 buildings.
“It took 100,000 slumlord units and changed them into 100,000 units
that catalyzed the redevelopment and revitalization of tens of
neighborhoods around the city,” said Benjamin Dulchin, executive
director of the Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development, which represents dozens of housing groups.
The proliferation of troubled buildings is lamentable, Mr. Dulchin
said, but it is “a minor part in what has been an overwhelmingly
successful public policy story.”
The financial woes of some buildings might be beyond their owners’
control. Sharply increased municipal costs have made it harder for
delinquent building owners to climb out of debt. Water and sewer fees
have soared in recent years, and tax abatements granted to many
buildings have expired.
Besides the Bronx corporation’s buildings, the housing department is
moving to foreclose on about 10 other properties, though it would not
disclose where. Foreclosure, housing officials said, is usually a last
resort. The city works with owners on structured payment plans or
forgives interest, which can be about 18 percent, on overdue fees.
During any transfer of ownership, tenants are protected because
pre-existing regulations, like rent stabilization rules, would carry
over, housing officials said.
And new ownership, officials said, would allow the city to impose rules
for those owners, requiring them to stay current on taxes, keep
buildings in good condition and maintain income caps for tenants.
The city would have a harder time, however, forcing the sale of the
scores of co-op buildings that are in serious default, because it does
not have regulatory power over their mortgages. Another hurdle is the
city’s limited power in issuing tax liens against the properties.
The owners of those buildings are technically called housing
development fund corporations, and under city law their tax liens, or
debts, cannot be sold, giving owners less incentive to pay their debts.
One option is to force the co-ops to assume new management, which opens
the possibility of shareholders losing their stakes in the buildings.
Tenant advocates praised the city’s approach, saying it was acting
responsibly to address the problem: weeding out delinquent buildings
with poor management, in the interest of protecting housing for
low-income New Yorkers. “The city in general realized they needed a
stronger stance toward asset management,” Mr. Dulchin said. “In any
flock, sheep will go astray.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.