Residents Debate Affordable Housing Sites

Wednesday, November 6, 2013
Nicole Baptista
Novato Advance

Hundreds of people filled Novato City Hall Nov. 4, some lining the walls as the Planning Commission made a presentation and recommended adoption of a plan that outlined five properties proposed for affordable housing sites in Novato.

Most of the crowd — the majority in opposition – voiced concern over the negative impacts they thought affordable housing would bring to the city.

Many also worried that commissioners were hurrying the Novato City Council to certify the Final Environmental Impact Report for the housing element. The housing element is part of Novato’s General Plan and must be approved by the state by January in order to receive $859,000 in transportation funds.

A few residents, such as Trish Boorstein, interim president for the Novato Community Alliance, supported the plan and recognized the deadline.

“The Novato Community Alliance continues to support this draft housing element and realizes the importance of certifying, approving and submitting all necessary documents to the state by January so we can embark on the next housing cycle without any negative consequences,” Boorstein said.

She also spoke about 700 signatures she will be submitting to the Novato City Council in support of the draft element, which the NCA collected in October of 2012. That draft element “was substantially the same as tonight’s revision,” she said.

“May all the effected residents be involved in the process,” Boorstein said. “We all need to be educated on Plan Bay Area and its impacts.”

The five properties include: Landing Court (an RV storage yard), 1787 Grant and Novato Boulevard, McClay Road at South Novato (a senior care facility), 7506 Redwood Boulevard and Redwood Boulevard (near the Buck Center).

Twenty percent of the proposed affordable units will be set aside for low and moderate-income tenants. The rest will be sold as market-rate housing, Novato City Director of Community Development Bob Brown said.

“There is a misperception about the meaning of affordable housing,” Brown said. “Many people think it means housing to be developed 100 percent for those with limited means. That is not the case.”

Many residents opposed the plan, arguing that affordable housing units will increase crime, traffic congestion and noise, will impact the environment and be aesthetically unpleasant.

“We all understand, as taxpayers, about the 20 percent you’re speaking about,” said Roberta Robinson, a member of the Partridge Knolls Neighborhood Alliance. She displayed a photo of the “monstrosity” built in Corte Madera, which she compared to Novato’s proposed affordable housing sites. “It’s about the aesthetics, the traffic, the impact in our community.”

Novato resident Susan Warnick represented the San Marin Compatible Housing Coalition Monday night.

“It’s been three and half years since the issues surrounding the Novato Housing Element exploded in our community . . . much debate has ensued and it’s been a long and painful process,” Warnick said. She supported the final EIR due to the January deadline.

Many spoke about Landing Court, which is in close proximity to Highway 101.

“The California Air Resources Board recommends housing be built at least 500 feet from a freeway,” resident Emily Larson said. “Who in this room would move their families to just 200 feet from Highway 101?”

A resident and member of the Clausing Avenue Coalition asked commissioners to be representative of the community. “We challenge you, Planning Commission, to stop supporting the path of least resistance and do the right thing.”

Chris Thompson, an engineer and longtime Novato resident, questioned why San Marin Drive was even up for debate, considering the City Council removed the site in 2011 with a unanimous vote.

“It shouldn’t’ be proposed, even as an alternative,” Thompson said.

Robert Atkinson, a resident of the Partridge Knolls neighborhood, worried about Redwood Boulevard and San Marin Drive’s intersection, which he said would “operate as an F.”

“It’s a bad intersection now; it will only get worse,” Atkinson said. “I am a father of two small children, and I worry about what this will do to emergency response time. In a disaster it will be every man for himself.”

Others argued that commercial developments and areas reserved for bio-tech would provide the greatest return for the city, and that the small-town feel Novato once possessed is slowly but surely dissolving.

The recommended housing element update also provides new zoning for a homeless shelter to be built in the Bel Marin Keys area.

The Novato City Council will vote on the certification of the Final Environmental Impact Report and the housing element on Nov. 19.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: