Richmond Seeks Middle Ground on Rent Control

Saturday, August 8, 2015
Karina Ioffee
Contra Costa Times

Christine Sinnott was 25 years old when she found a sweet one-bedroom apartment in Berkeley. The home was an old Victorian with high ceilings and great light, and it was within biking distance to her job. Most important: It had rent control.

But after her daughter, now 14, was born, the place became too crowded: Sinnott sleeps in the living room, where a piano, bookshelf and bed compete for space, while her daughter takes the bedroom.

"If for any reason I have to leave that apartment, I'm going to have to leave the Bay Area," said Sinnott, now 44, who pays one-third of what market-rate units go for (she doesn't want to disclose the amount of our fear of making her neighbors jealous). "There are not many other places in the U.S. where I feel comfortable as a lesbian woman."

After months of contentious debate, Richmond last month became the first California city in 30 years to enact rent control. While supporters hope it will offer the same type of lifeline to residents there that it has to Sinnott in nearby Berkeley, detractors argue that the policy's legacy is one of bloated bureaucracies that discourage property owners from investing in housing and allow tenants to monopolize artificially low rents even when their incomes rise.

Richmond's rent control policy, set to go into effect in September, would limit increases to the rate of inflation, currently about 2 percent a year, and require landlords to pay $170 to $220 per unit each year to cover about a dozen city staff members who will manage the program. Landlords will be able to pass on 40 percent of the fees to tenants and petition the board if they think they aren't getting a fair return on their investment.

In doing so, this city of 107,000 appears to be striking a balance between Berkeley's rent-stabilization program, which has sometimes been described as too stringent, and Oakland's ordinance, which has been faulted as being "too pro-landlord."

In California, about a dozen cities have implemented the policy, including Berkeley, Oakland, San Francisco, East Palo Alto, San Jose, Los Angeles and Santa Monica, although details vary from place to place.

Berkeley, which has had rent control since 1980, has one of the strongest policies in the country, charging landlords $213 per year for each unit they own and allowing landlords to raise rents by just 65 percent of the Consumer Price Index, or slightly more than 1 percent, each year currently. The rent control board has been criticized for inserting itself in issues of proposed development, pushing for rent control in other cities and hiring a lobbyist to further tenant interests in Sacramento.

"The rent control board has a job to do, but they've gone way beyond their mandate," said Sid Lakireddy, president of the Berkeley Property Owners Assocation.

Berkeley's tenants rights advocates defend the city's tough rent policies as well as the rent board's $4 million annual budget. And they say that the Costa-Hawkins state law, which exempts rent control on all housing built after 1995, condominiums and single-family homes, ensures that landlords earn plenty on their investment.

"We want people to get a reasonable rate of return, but the idea that you're going to make excessive profits over (the interests of) community to me is really nauseating," said Jesse Townley, chairman of the Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board. "Most landlords do quite well, especially in this overheated market."

Rent-controlled units in Berkeley, even those occupied just a couple of years, on average go for far less than those built after 1995, last year charging an average of $1,459 per month for a one-bedroom apartment, compared with $2,786 for a similar apartment in a non-rent-controlled unit, according to the Berkeley Property Owners Association. In Oakland, the average one-bedroom today goes for $2,500, according to RealFacts, a company that analyzes real estate trends.

The average price of a rent-controlled unit is not known because the city doesn't require landlords to register their units and only finds out about excessive increases if someone files a complaint.

Oakland also charges landlords of rent-controlled units just $30 per unit each year, funds that support the Rent Adjustment Program's $1.8 million annual budget. Although its oversees 60,000 units, about three times more than in Berkeley, it employs just eight full-time workers, compared with 18 people run who Berkeley's program.

Oakland landlords also are able to pass on as much as 70 percent of capital improvement costs, although rent increases are capped at no more than 10 percent a year, thanks to a tightening of the ordinance last year.

The law was strengthened in response to a growing number of tenants who have been displaced after receiving large rent increases by landlords who said they had made expensive repairs and needed to be reimbursed.

Clifton and Mercedes Harrison, who have lived in Oakland's Adams Point neighborhood for 27 years, received a letter last year notifying them that rent would be increasing from $1,057 to $2,225 a month. The Harrisons say the rent went up after they complained to the city about a leak in the bathroom that the landlord had ignored for a year.

The couple temporarily relocated when the work started, but they were shocked to discover not only a new bathroom but new marble kitchen counters, new doors and new paint when they returned. The landlord, Kathleen Solares, said that she had wanted to remodel the apartment, built in 1954, for many years but that the Harrisons had refused to move out. As for putting in expensive features such as marble counters, Solares said all of the units in the building are "high-end" and that she was only passing on the costs she had accrued to her tenants.

The Harrisons are not convinced and are appealing the rent increase.

In Berkeley, landlords must petition the rent board before passing on increases accrued through capital improvements such as new exterior paint, a new roof or foundation repairs (basic repairs are not covered). Richmond will do something similar, with landlords being required to petition the board before passing on any capital improvement costs to their tenants.

It's an uneasy coexistence in many ways, with many renters willing to put up with problems in exchange for lower rents and landlords wary of making improvements, then trying to recoup their investment. For Christopher Palmer, an economist at UC Berkeley's Haas School of Business, the issue comes down to basic supply and demand, with the Bay Area's housing shortage exacerbating the problem.

"When there's a line of tenants waiting to get into the door, landlords don't have the same incentives to fix up apartments," Palmer said. "If you're the incumbent tenant, you're definitely winning (with rent control). But after the person moves, someone rich can snag the unit and enjoy only 2 percent a year increases while there is no guarantee that they are a nurse, teacher or other working-class person the ordinance was designed to protect."

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: