Rising Rents and Opposition to Building Spur Discussion of Rent Control in Marin

Sunday, September 21, 2014
Richard Halstead
Marin Independent Journal

Rising rents in Marin and opposition to construction of new affordable housing have sparked talk of rent control as a possible means of addressing Marin's affordable housing shortage.

In July, Fairfax Councilman Larry Bragman called for a discussion of rent control. At the time, the Fairfax Town Council was dealing with an outcry from a group of residents who objected to passage of a zoning ordinance that would have paved the way for the addition of 124 housing units.

Opponents of the ordinance gathered more than 1,000 signatures on a petition, enough to force the council to either repeal the ordinance or put a referendum on the ballot asking Fairfax voters if it should be repealed. The council repealed the measure, known as Ordinance 778, in August.

In a July 2 memorandum calling for the Fairfax Town Council to discuss rent control, Bragman wrote, "During its ongoing deliberations in regard to the status of Ordinance 778, the Town Council heard many speakers describing the scarcity of affordable housing in Marin County. Several also described receiving large increases in their monthly rent that were well above the increase in the cost of living for our area."

He concluded the memo by writing, "A properly drafted rent control ordinance would protect Fairfax residents from arbitrary eviction and unreasonable increases in rent. Hence, I believe that our council should consider the viability of a municipal rent control ordinance in Fairfax."

But before the council could discuss his suggestion, Bragman withdrew it earlier this month. Bragman said in the interim he had heard from local property owners, landlords and real estate professionals, "universally blistering the idea of going forward with the idea of rent control."

Bragman cited several reasons for his change of heart. First, he said he discovered that under state law, property that was issued a certificate of occupancy after February 1995 is exempt from rent control; and tenancies in single-family homes and condos are exempt from rent control if the tenancy began after Jan. 1, 1996.

"So there is an inherent unfairness built into the structure by the state," Bragman told his fellow council members when he withdrew his request on Sept. 2.

Bragman had mentioned this fact in his original memo noting, however, that, "In Fairfax, most of our multi-unit rental stock was probably issued certificates of occupancy before February 1995."

Another reason Bragman cited for withdrawing his request was the complexity of implementing rent control.

"As it has developed in San Francisco, it has developed an entire subset of administrative and legal entanglements that are extremely expensive to administer," Bragman said. "It's a very tough project for a town of our size to take on."

And finally, Bragman said that given the "level of rancor that was boiling" over Ordinance 778, he had concluded, "This thing was the seed of another massive fracture in the community."

Michael Burke, a real estate broker with Decker Bullock Sotheby's International Realty in Greenbrae, said, "I am not aware of any city or municipality in Marin that is currently seriously considering rent control." Burke added, "A false rumor of rent control could affect decisions of those investing in Marin's real estate as well as those managing existing rental properties."

Nevertheless, the idea of implementing rent control in Marin will remain a topic of discussion for some time to come, because the draft version of the county of Marin's new housing element calls for considering rent control as well as other tenant protections.

Gayle Theard, who heads the Marin Housing Authority's Resident Advisory Board, said more protections for tenants are needed, particularly in light of the fact that federal funding for maintaining the county's stock of public housing is dwindling.

"Rent control is not an anti-landlord policy," Theard said. "It's just a means of trying to keep the rates stable so that the most vulnerable populations won't be displaced."

The housing element has been approved by the Marin County Planning Commission and has been submitted to the state for its approval. It is expected to go to the Board of Supervisors later this year or early next year for final adoption.

"Rents have gone up dramatically in the past year to two years," said county principal planner Leelee Thomas.

According to information in the county's housing element, the average monthly rental price for a two-bedroom apartment in Marin County increased from $1,667 in 2010 to $2,014 in 2012. As of July, the average monthly rental price for a two-bedroom apartment with two bathrooms in Marin stood at $2,676, according to Novato-based RealFacts; the average monthly rental price for a one-bedroom apartment in Marin was $1,924 in July.

Patricia Cahill, 52, who shares a one-bedroom apartment with her husband at Larkspur Courts in Larkspur, is feeling the effects of the rising rents first-hand. Cahill said this month new management there boosted her monthly rent from $1,795 to $2,730. Cahill said a new $30-a-month fee has also been added for valet trash service.

"We had a really nice community here," Cahill said. She said now many residents are moving out. Cahill said a neighbor of hers in the building, an 88-year-old woman, couldn't afford her rent increase.

"She's in a nursing home now," Cahill said. "I just think it is unconscionable."

Riverstone Residential Group, which manages Larkspur Courts, did not respond to a request for comment.

Yvette Wakefield, who lost her Section 8 apartment when her landlord raised her rent and now lives in a single room in Fairfax, said she felt empowered when she learned that a member of the Fairfax Town Council had called for a discussion of rent control. It motivated her to gather 30 signatures on a petition asking the Fairfax Town Council to discuss a one-year moratorium on rent increases.

"It only took me a short time to gather those signatures," Wakefield said. "People are being made to move left and right."

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.  

Help build power for renters' rights: