City Council members agreed in principle on new rules intended to strengthen its process for mediating rent disputes but stopped short of passing an ordinance on Tuesday.
Council members said Tuesday that they are prepared to approve rules that would enshrine the existence of the city’s Rent Review Advisory Committee in the city’s code, require landlords to provide renters information about the committee when they hand out rent increases and require landlords and tenants to participate in scheduled rent dispute hearings.
But Mayor Trish Spencer said she wants city staff to make sure a proposed provision to void rent increases imposed by landlords who don’t show up to scheduled rent committee hearings – leverage designed to ensure landlords participate in the mediation process – isn’t a de facto rent control that could violate state law limiting rent control to certain properties.
A revised ordinance could be back before the council in July, City Attorney Janet Kern said. Meanwhile, the city will get to work on a study documenting the impacts of rising rents.
Council members did not broach the topic of imposing rent controls. Nor did they consider restricting evictions, despite concerns that some landlords are giving tenants notices they have 60 days to move as a means of avoiding rent increase reviews.
n 2014 the City Council narrowly voted to forgo a formal city rents task force that would hold hearings and collect data on rising rents and evictions in favor of a community process intended to gather anecdotal information and to come up with solutions.
After a series of public meetings, the community group came up with a list of six discussion points, five of which landlords and tenants agreed on, that council members in January asked staff to adapt into new rules to both better promote and strengthen its non-binding mediation process.
The sixth point – setting a minimum rent increase required to trigger the right to a hearing before the rent committee – was included in an alternate ordinance that council members didn’t support.
"We're taking away rights tenants have today," City Councilman Jim Oddie said.
Both landlord and tenant advocates spoke out in support of the ordinance, which had the support of four members of council. But some tenants also urged the council to do more to protect them.
Barbara Duncan said she and tenants in the other three units in her building got notices this past Saturday that their rent was being raised by $170 a month.
“And I thought I had the best landlord,” Duncan said.
Another speaker said she received a $600 a month increase. She said more needs to be done.
"Please do something about these landlords who raise these rents. Because seniors and people with fixed income really need your help," the woman, who didn’t give her full name, said.
State law permits landlords to require tenants who have occupied a home or apartment for a year or more to move, with 60 days’ notice. State law also does not impose restrictions on rents, though it does limit the restrictions cities and counties can impose.
Some cities – including Oakland, Berkeley, Hayward and San Francisco – have local rent control laws, while others have “just cause” laws that limit evictions. The state’s Costa-Hawkins law prohibits cities from imposing rent control on single-family homes and condominiums or any dwelling built and authorized for residential use after February 1, 1995.
Spencer said she wants more information on the amount of rental property that the law would exempt from rent control; the city lacks data on single-family home rentals and has built little multifamily housing since Measure A prohibited it, in 1972.
The law also permits landlords to decide how high to raise rents after a tenant leaves. Prior to the law’s passage, a handful of California cities controlled rent increases even after a tenant moved.
The law also permits landlords to decide how high to raise rents after a tenant leaves. Prior to the law’s passage, a handful of California cities controlled rent increases even after a tenant moved.
Alameda’s rent review committee mediates landlord-tenant rent disputes, but the decisions it makes aren’t binding, and landlords and tenants aren’t required to show up to the hearings they set. Last year the committee had at least two cases where a landlord declined to appear because the city’s rules didn’t require them to.
Some tenants have called for rent controls, while landlords have said imposing it will have unintended impacts on housing availability and quality. The idea has not won the support of a majority of the council.
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.