Sacramento housing agency disputes HUD report of misspending

Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Robert Lewis
The Sacramento Bee

A federal watchdog says the Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency misused millions of dollars intended to revitalize areas the foreclosure crisis had left as wastelands.

The agency
misspent more then $1.1 million in federal Neighborhood Stabilization
Program funds on ineligible properties and costs, according to an audit
by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's Office of the Inspector General. The audit recommends that SHRA be forced to repay those funds.

In addition, the agency overbudgeted by $3.8 million for apartment rehab projects, the HUD audit found. The reason: inflated developer profits and amounts allocated for renovation that were too high.

The federal report recommends that the money be redirected to other
projects, along with an additional $1.5 million allocated to ineligible
projects but not yet spent.

SHRA
officials say they did nothing wrong. The money is helping fix a
blighted area of the unincorporated county in need of such projects.
The local officials struck a defiant tone Tuesday afternoon, calling
the inspector general's office uninformed and refusing to change tracks.

"We're not going to stop work," said Christine Weichert, the agency's assistant director of housing and community development. "We are meeting the intent of the stimulus funds."

The controversy stems from the agency's use of federal funds to rehab seven fourplexes at Lerwick Road near the intersection of Watt Avenue and Auburn Boulevard, and an additional eight fourplexes at Norcade Circle near Folsom Boulevard and Highway 50.

The owner and developer of all the properties is EPO Development, a firm run by brothers Erik and Paul Olson. They received more than 40 percent of the $18.6 million allocated by HUD to SHRA to fix up vacant or foreclosed properties in unincorporated Sacramento County. That money was awarded to the Olson brothers without competition.

But
the inspector general's audit says five of the EPO properties were
ineligible for the federal funds, because the developer had already
bought them before SHRA even applied for the money. The audit also found that the housing agency allowed the developer to bill for unnecessary upgrades and exorbitant costs.

"The Agency
approved the construction company … to earn 20 percent in profit and
overhead when the average for similar projects averaged about 9.62
percent for other developers," the audit states.

As a result of the inflated costs, the agency budgeted $500,000 to rehab each Lerwick Road and Norcade Circle property. HUD, however, estimated the actual cost per property should have been closer to $100,000. In total, SHRA overbudgeted $3.8 million for those properties that could be redirected to other projects, according to the audit

Geoffrey Ross, a program manager with SHRA,
disputed the inspector general's reading of the rules regarding the
properties' eligibility for funds. Ross said it doesn't matter that the
developer already owned the properties in question, because they were
and still are vacant.

EPO was able to purchase the Lerwick
properties and begin work on the two sites thanks in part to $6.7
million in local funds the agency also committed to the projects, according to SHRA.

Paul Olson said the costs for the project are in line with the marketplace. EPO is a for-profit company, he said.

"In
private industry, 10 percent profit and 10 percent overhead is a low
standard," he said. "We have an obligation to not lose money."

Olson
also took issue with the inspector general's finding that the
developers made unnecessary fixes that drove the cost up. EPO plans to
be a long-term landlord, and simply slapping down new carpeting and
fresh coats of paint would be a short-term solution, he said.

In addition to the allegations regarding the agency's handling of money, the inspector general's office faulted SHRA for failing to meet reporting requirements. The agency was supposed to submit quarterly reports to HUD regarding the program and to post those reports online.

"Contrary to the requirements, not only did the Agency
not upload the reports to its website, it also did not report essential
information about the projects to HUD," the audit states.
"Consequently, the Agency was not being transparent to HUD and the public on how the funds were spent."

U.S.
Housing and Urban Development officials will ultimately decide the
remedy for the alleged violations. HUD has 120 days from the date of
the audit to review the inspector general's recommendations.


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: