San Diego tenants get no help fighting rats, mold

Sunday, April 4, 2010
Megan Burks
HealthyCal

Appalled by the substandard living conditions they found in the City
Heights neighborhood of San Diego, community organizers told residents
last year that they would take their concerns to the city—literally.
Armed with storage-sized freezer bags full of roaches and rats from
houses and rental units, healthy homes advocates presented their
findings to the San Diego City Council and asked for better housing
code enforcement.

The group called for regulation of mold and vermin infestation to
help combat the disproportionate level of housing-related asthma in
City Heights. According to the National Latino Research Center,
residents of City Heights are three times more likely to be
hospitalized for asthma than others in San Diego County.

The council delayed action, asking for more information from
Proyecto Casas Saludables, the organization spearheading efforts to
improve living conditions in City Heights, and other stakeholders.

But the information the council needs could be as close as the
California Health and Safety Code, which the city’s Neighborhood Code
Compliance office said it already enforces. But the city’s enforcement
leaves out several components of the state code, including regulation
of insect infestations, mold, mildew, rats and other rodents, according
to information on the city’s web site.

According to the California Department of Housing and Community
Development, such negligence could be grounds for legal action against
the city if shortfalls aren’t remedied.

Doug Hensel, the assistant deputy director of codes and standards
with the department, said cities are obligated to uphold the code,
which delegates enforcement to city housing or health entities.

Rosalie Leon, a supervisor with Neighborhood Code Compliance, said
no agency in San Diego deals with mold or infestation complaints.
That’s because the code doesn’t specify mold as evidence of substandard
housing, said Alan Johanns, a program manager with the city’s
Environmental Services Department, which doesn’t oversee housing code
compliance. Instead, the code vaguely regulates “dampness of habitable
rooms” and “inadequate sanitation.” What’s more, the code’s language
suggests that a health officer–not expressly an inspector–is
responsible for determining whether the unit has a cockroach, vermin or
rodent infestation.

San Diego doesn’t have a health officer. Residents with these
housing problems and other health queries are referred to the county
government, which often cannot help. The County Department of
Environmental Health regulates mold and vermin, but only for residents
under the county’s jurisdiction. Complaints from city residents are
looped back to the city.

Leon said residents with mold and vermin problems can also contact
the California Indoor Air Quality Program for help. Funding cuts,
however, have forced the program to discontinue its phone hotline.
Residents can still email their concerns, but response time is slow;
the program did not respond before press time.

Though Casas Saludables and other affiliated organizations said they
do not have plans to take legal action against the city, they said red
tape like this makes policy change necessary.

The residents most affected by substandard housing are also most
likely to be refugees and immigrants with limited knowledge of local
government services. Virginia Angeles, the director of Casas
Saludables, said many of the residents she worked with qualified for
Section 8 housing subsidies and feared their landlords would retaliate
if they complained. That’s why Casas Saludables works to train
residents to become promotoras who educate their neighbors on housing
issues and help press for repairs at a grassroots level.

Valerie Camacho, a City Heights resident, said her lungs have been
“pretty much obliterated” by living conditions in City Heights and the
Imperial Valley. Although she did not want to comment on her current
apartment, she said that generally, landlords in the area neglect their
properties.

“A lot of the landlords don’t live in City Heights and never have
and never will,” she said. “I don’t think they understand what it’s
like to live with the realities. The majority of them live in North
County and City Heights is just a cash cow to them.”

Alan Pentico, a spokesman for the San Diego County Apartment
Association, said negligent landlords “are the exception and not the
rule.” He said the association supports better code enforcement, but
cautioned against mandatory inspection policies because of the cost to
landlords and the city, and the privacy rights of tenants.

“There is already a process in place and it’s just a matter of following through,” he said.

Community organizers said the Asthma Coalition of Los Angeles County
is a model for the kind of reform they’d like to see in San Diego. Los
Angeles began mandatory three-year inspections after working with the
coalition to alleviate childhood asthma, but Casas Saludables has not
expressly pushed for mandatory inspections.

Currently, the city of San Diego conducts inspections only at the
behest of tenant or community complaints. The Housing Commission, which
oversees public housing, also does not conduct regular inspections of
its properties, except to take inventory of fixtures when tenants move
in, said commission spokesman Terry Rogers.

“Housing is crucial to make the difference for City Heights,” said Angeles. “It’s connected to everything.”

Though outdoor air pollution and health care disparities are other
factors that plague the community, housing stock in the area is much
older than in other parts of the county. According to the 2000 Census,
only 17 percent of the housing in City Heights was built after 1980,
compared to 32 percent and 36 percent in the city and county,
respectively. This leaves residents susceptible to lead paint, old
carpeting and leaky plumbing, all of which have been linked to asthma.

More than 80 percent of residents do not smoke or keep pets and said
they clean on a regular basis. Still, nearly 80 percent had roach
infestations and over half reported signs of mold, according to the
National Latino Research Center. Of those with roach problems, nearly
half had asthma.

“The single most determining factor for a person’s health is their zip code,” said Camacho.

Despite gaps in enforcement, the City of San Diego is addressing
community health issues in City Heights with its Housing and Urban
Development Healthy Homes grant. Awarded in 2007 and scheduled for
renewal this summer, the grant allows the Environmental Services
Department to fund voluntary inspections and follow-up education and
repairs for low-income families affected by, or at-risk for, asthma.
Since 2007, the program has worked with 225 households and educated
hundreds more, said Johanns. The renewal will award $875,000 and is
expected to serve 150 households.

Johanns said the program will complete a report later this year that
he hopes will affect policy change and provide suggestions for more
enforcement funding. City authorities and advocates alike said funding
is the main hurdle for better housing regulation.

“In a perfect world, the government should and would enforce all
their codes and regulations, but we are not in that world,” said Steven
Kellman, an attorney with the Tenants Legal Center. “Based on such a
limited budget and funding, the Neighborhood Code Compliance will have
to work with a triage method.”

For now, Angeles said Casas Saludables is focusing on getting more
funding and working with the community before it goes back to the city
council. Hensel said the legal department with state housing
authorities would need to be contacted for it to enter into discussions
with the City of San Diego.

“We don’t just go out with a heavy hand at first,” he said. “We
have and we will, but usually they just don’t really know what their
responsibility is.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: