SANTA CRUZ - To meet a
deadline outlined in the city's agreement with UC Santa Cruz to control
student growth, the City Council on Tuesday preliminarily passed an
ordinance requiring owners of rental properties to register their units
and eventually submit to inspection.
Council members stressed that the measure is designed to target
thousands of suspected illegal units and negligent landlords, not
unpermitted construction that doesn't pose an immediate threat to
residents or neighbors. The ordinance, which staff altered a great deal
to address concerns from real estate officials, rental associations and
individual landlords, passed unanimously on first reading. A final
reading will be scheduled for later.
While the agreement with the university requires such an ordinance
be created before September, council members said the city has long
needed a plan to address health and safety hazards posed by
overcrowding, illegal construction and poor maintenance. Thousands of
students live in rental units, a fact that contributed to UCSC's
agreement to house two-thirds of future students on campus as part of
the 2008 pact that settled lawsuits over its growth plan.
But Mayor Mike Rotkin said he began working on a rental ordinance
four years ago - before talks with the university - because code
enforcement officers couldn't keep up with complaints about illegal or
unsafe housing, which number about 500. The fees, in addition to
contributions from UCSC, will pay for two new inspectors, a clerk and
other program expenses totaling an estimated $322,000 annually.
"There are more problems than they can get at," Rotkin said. "Current code enforcement is not working."
Opponents urged the council to go after illegal units the city
already knows about rather than burdening landlords whose properties
have not received complaints. They described the plan, which would cost
an annual $45 registration fee and minimum $20 inspection fee, as a
money-making scheme that violates personal privacy.
One woman echoed comments from several speakers Tuesday by saying,
"The only reason the complaint-based system doesn't work is because the
city didn't follow up on the complaints."
Joshua Howard, executive director of the Cupertino-based California
Apartment Association, Tri-County Division, applauded city staff for
making changes, including cutting fees in half from what was originally
proposed and reducing liabilities on landlords when tenants refuse to
submit to inspections.
"I'm not here saying apartment owners and managers want additional
inspections or fees," he said, referring to the ordinance as the "least
worse solution" to fixing illegal units.
Vice Mayor Ryan Coonerty noted that dozens of other cities in
California, including San Jose and Los Angeles, have rental inspection
ordinances, many of which don't allow for self-certification as Santa
Cruz does for properties that haven't had code violations. He
acknowledged the proposal is unpopular, but said the council was doing
what was best to keep residents safe.
Also Tuesday, the council voted unanimously to place a measure on
November's ballot that would increase the utility users tax from 7
percent to 8.5 percent to generate an estimated $1.8 million, the
majority of which will be spent on increased public safety costs.
Council members, who said the average increase for residences will be
$5-$6 per month, had to meet Friday's deadline for submitting ballot
measures to the county elections division.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.