Did a tenant of a mobile home park violate her lease agreement by having her friend attempt to pay the rent for her? And if she did, does the breach warrant her eviction? A lawsuit filed in civil court last year hinges upon these questions.
When Lynette Del Ponte had her neighbor at the Alimur Mobile Home Park on Soquel Drive pay her rent in February 2011, she didn't realize that by doing so she could be violating her lease.
Her landlord, Paul Goldstone, said the terms of her lease, signed in March 2005, stated that payment must be made from the tenant to the landlord. He refused to accept the payment, according to court records, and moved to evict Del Ponte from the park. When she failed to leave within the 60-day termination notice period, Goldstone sued.
Goldstone's attorney, Paul Jensen, argues that his client isn't required to accept payment from third parties and that attempting to do so was a breach of Del Ponte's lease.
Judge Jeff Almquist in September sided with Goldstone, ruling that Del Ponte's tenancy was "duly terminated for failure to pay rent." Her eviction was stayed while her lawyer filed an appeal, and earlier this month, a panel of three judges overturned Almquist's decision. The case will now go back to the lower court once more.
In his filings, Jensen asserts that the specific legal provisions for payment of rents and charges by third parties pertaining to mobile home parks are limited to certain situations. It's limited, he writes, to instances "in which the tenant has died, or a registered owner of a mobile home (other than a tenant), a legal owner or junior lienholder has foreclosed on their security interest, or has received a motive of termination of the tenancy from the park."
Del Ponte's attorney, John Hannon, has argued that the suit against his client represents retaliation. He argues that the suit was retaliation against Del Ponte and other tenants who'd obtained a $1.9 million settlement stemming for the failure of the landlord to maintain the park. Hannon also says its retaliation for the tenants who'd objected to converting the mobile home park to an owner-owned park.
The park had a long-running dispute with the county after the county Board of Supervisors denied Goldstone's request to subdivide his property and sell off the individual, rent-controlled lots, instead of owning them and renting them to tenants, who provide their own mobile homes. The plan was touted as a way for residents to win homeownership but many residents who benefitted from rent control laws saw the change as a financial setback.
Goldstone "denies any reason for terminating defendant's tenancy other than her nonpayment of rent and her overall poor tenancy history, and specifically denies any improper or retaliatory motive," according to Jensen's filings.
Jensen could not be reached to comment Friday.
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.