Santa Monica Rent Board Staff Opposes Collecting Buyout Offers

Tuesday, March 10, 2015
Jonathan Friedman
Santa Monica Lookout

While a recently passed Santa Monica law makes it a requirement for all landlord-tenant buyout agreements to become public records, the Rent Control Board staff recommends against it being the holder of these records.

This recommendation, which the board will consider on Thursday, follows two recent public meetings about the topic and conversations among a rent board subcommittee and representatives from landlord associations and Santa Monicans for Renters’ Rights (SMRR).

“The board’s collection and public dissemination of buyout agreements would raise serious privacy concerns, and could violate the state constitutional right to privacy,” wrote J. Stephen Lewis, the rent board’s general counsel.

All buyout agreements must be filed as public records following the City Council passage of a so-called anti-harassment ordinance. If the rent board decides not to be the holder of the records, then this duty would go to the City Clerk.

Lewis wrote that San Francisco recently passed a law requiring buyout agreements be made public, and it is expected to be challenged in court.

“Staff further understands that the Santa Monica City Attorney’s office intends to monitor that litigation to ascertain whether it highlights any vulnerability in the recent amendments to our local law,” Lewis wrote.

He added that the recommendation does not mean “that local law requiring landlords to file executed buyout agreements is invalid,” nor does it mean that the concept of accepting buyout agreement filings should be totally rejected.

“Staff merely recommends that the board refrain now from implementing a buyout agreement filing regulation, and revisit it when the privacy-related issues have been more fully considered,” he wrote.

Buyout agreements have become a hot topic in Santa Monica, with some people alleging landlords are aggressively pursuing them as a method to get rent-controlled tenants to leave units so they can be replaced by people paying market rate.

“These tactics sometimes result in tenants entering into buyout agreements without a full understanding of their rights,” City Attorney Marsha Moutrie wrote in a report late last year.

She added, “The buyouts vary widely in amounts and, in some cases, are even below minimum relocation benefits which are required to be paid for all no-fault evictions.”

Rent board staff has recommended that the board approve a measure requiring landlords to use a special form to make buyout offers. The form would include “the disclosure of rights” the tenants have.

Lewis wrote that staff was not in favor of the rent board passing a measure prohibiting landlords from posting buyout offers on tenants’ doors as suggested by one member last month.

The board's purpose “is limited to implementing existing law, and does not include creating new substantive rights or liabilities," Lewis wrote.

If the board determined the method of making buyout offers should be regulated, then it could suggest the City Council amend its anti-harassment ordinance, Lewis wrote

Board member Todd Flora said at last month’s meeting that posting buyout offers on a door was meant to intimidate, as have all notices placed on doors throughout human history.

“It has been a powerful statement since blood was thrown on doors, that something put on a door is a powerful statement,” Flora said.

Staff has also recommended that limitations not be placed on tenants asking for buyout offers, disputing the allegation made by landlord advocates at last month’s meeting that this had become an issue.

“The anti-harassment ordinance’s purpose is to prevent landlords from attempting to circumvent the rent control law’s limits on the grounds for eviction,” Lewis wrote. “It is not clear that a buyout offer initiated by a tenant poses such a danger.”

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

Help build power for renters' rights: