As if their rising cost to state and local governments weren’t
trouble enough, public pensions also face legislation cracking down on
pension boosting, improperly influenced investments and real estate
schemes that displace the poor.
A whiff of anti-corruption cleanser, or the verbal equivalent,
wafted through the Capitol this month. Bills moved to curb the
“spiking” of final pay to boost pensions and regulate “placement
agents” paid big fees for helping money managers get pension funds.
Moral outrage colored testimony as a committee approved a bill to
prohibit pension fund investments in “predatory equity,” ill-fated
attempts to move rent-controlled units to market prices that cost
CalPERS and CalSTRS $700 million in investment losses.
Action is needed to maintain public confidence in the pension
funds, said Democratic advocates of the legislation, which faces
opposition or pleas for changes from powerful interest groups.
But the scandal-driven bills have a better chance of passage, even
if watered down, than another sweeping reform introduced by Republican
leaders last week that would cut pension and retiree health benefits
for new state workers.
Senate Republican Leader Dennis Hollingsworth of Murrieta and Gov.
Arnold Schwarzenegger said the bill, SB 919, is needed to prevent
pension costs from “crowding out” funding for higher education, health
care and other programs.
“In California we had the internet bubble, we had the housing
bubble, and I see in the very near future a public pension bubble,”
Schwarzenegger said at a news conference.
Schwarzenegger proposed last year that pensions for new state hires
(the pensions of current workers are protected by court decisions) be
rolled back to the level in effect before a major benefit increase a
decade ago.
A pension reform group wanted to put an initiative on the November
ballot to cut benefits for new state and local government hires. But
the drive stalled after Republican gubernatorial candidate Meg Whitman
and others did not provide hoped-for funding.
Labor officials, who have the ear of Democratic legislators, say
any pension benefit changes must be negotiated. A Highway Patrol
official has said lower benefits for new hires might be considered as
an alternative to a more punitive initiative in the future.
The spiking of pensions drew national attention last year after the
Contra Costa Times reported that two fire chiefs retired, at ages 50
and 51, with pensions far larger than their final salary.
The author of a bill, SB 1425, imposing new spiking controls on the
California Public Employees Retirement System and the California State
Teachers Retirement System said he is asked why he is carrying the bill.
“The answer is it was an issue I heard about repeatedly during year
2009, more than at any time during my 25 years of public service,” said
state Sen. Joe Simitian, D-Palo Alto, a former mayor, school board
member, county supervisor and assemblyman.
Public pensions are based on years served multiplied by a
percentage of the final pay, usually 2 to 3 percent in California. A
common way to spike a pension is to boost the final pay by cashing out
unused vacation and leave time and a number of other things.
CalPERS sponsored legislation, SB 53 in 1993, that created screens
and audits to control spiking. Similar legislation for the 20 county
retirement systems operating under a 1937 act, SB 2003, failed in 1994.
Now Assemblywoman Fiona Ma, D-San Francisco, is carrying a bill, AB
1987, that would impose spiking controls on the 1937 act counties,
including the Contra Costa system that administers the pensions for the
two fire chiefs.
“I decided to take on this bill because I agree that reform is
necessary to protect not only the health of our system but the public’s
trust of our system,” Ma told an Assembly committee last week.
A complication for the 1937 act systems is a state Supreme Court
ruling in a Ventura County suit in 1997 that a number of things had
been improperly excluded from final pay, resulting in retroactive
increase for retirees and a wide range of settlements.
If anti-spiking legislation passes, the 1937 act systems are said
to be worried about lawsuits claiming Ventura decision violations.
Other problems: a lack of resources to enforce the new controls and
potential conflicts with counties.
The two anti-spiking bills have a provision aimed at curbing
“double-dipping,” which is retiring and then returning to the same or
similar job. The retiree would have to wait six months before taking a
job covered by the same pension system.
To save money, the city of Rocklin, near Sacramento, boosted the
pensions of nine retiring managers earlier this by giving them credit
for an additional two years of service, then rehired them in their old
jobs as part-time employees.
Representatives of counties and a school business group asked for
more “flexibility” in the six-month ban, arguing that recent retirees
are sometimes needed for things like filling jobs temporarily during
recruitment and training.
A pension scandal in New York early last year led to the disclosure
by CalPERS that the firm of one of its former board members, Al
Villalobos, collected about $60 million in “placement agent” fees for
helping private equity firms get CalPERS funds.
A bill sponsored by state Treasurer Bill Lockyer, AB 1743, requires
placement agents to register as lobbyists and bans contingency fees
based on the amount of funding received. He said the Legislature
abolished contingency fees for lobbyists 60 years ago.
The bill moved out of a committee earlier this month, despite
financial industry opposition to the fee ban and no support from
Republicans. Democrats worried that small minority-owned investment
firms might be harmed by the fee ban.
Because the bill modifies the political reform act, a two-thirds
vote is needed on the floor, requiring some Republican votes. A
compromise on the fee issue or a rewritten bill that does not change
the political reform act may be necessary.
“My guess is if we can’t reform the system, pension funds in
California are going to do what New York did, which is just ban
placement agents,” Lockyer told the committee. “And I think frankly
that hurts the small ones (investment firms).”
It was bad enough when CalPERS reportedly lost $500 million and
CalSTRS $100 million on what some have called the biggest real estate
deal in U.S. history, $5.4 billion for New York’s Stuyvesant Town and
Peter Cooper Village rental complex.
But critics call it a “predatory equity” plan in which the huge
purchase is intended to be paid off by raising rent-controlled units to
market prices, forcing low-income tenants out of affordable housing.
CalPERS also lost $100 million in a similar ill-fated attempt by
Page Mill Properties to upgrade 1,700 rent-controlled units in East
Palo Alto, triggering a long legal battle with the city and tenant
groups.
Chris Lund of the East Palo Alto Fair Rent Coalition told a
legislative committee last week that the development “resulted in the
displacement of over 1,500 predominantly Latino and African-American
low-income residents in less than 18 months.”
A number of the displaced tenants are said to be CalPERS members.
“It’s unconscionable to use your own money to displace yourself,” Terry
Brennand of Service Employees International told the committee.
A bill, AB 2337 by Assemblyman Tom Ammiano, D-San Francisco, would
prohibit CalPERS and CalSTRS from making “predatory” investments. The
CalPERS board last week adopted a policy with the same aim.
The banking industry said the bill was overly broad, possibly
covering things like checking accounts. An apartment association said
the bill could discourage investments in rent-controlled properly.
A CalPERS lobbyist, Danny Brown, suggested that the bill be made
more like the CalPERS policy. He said the bill might prevent pension
fund investment in affordable housing and hamper CalPERS in the
investment marketplace.
“You have my commitment,” Ammiano told the chairman, Alberto
Torrico, D-Fremont, before the bill passed the Assembly retirement
committee. “If it needs to be narrowed, we will do it.”
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner