Today, the Board of Supervisors Budget Committee will vote on a
proposal that everyone knows is dead on arrival – but Mayor Gavin
Newsom insists that opponents are being too “ideological.” Blowing the
cap on condo conversions of T.I.C.’s (tenancies-in-common) is something
that real estate speculators have pushed for decades, and now they want
to pit middle-class homeowners against tenants. Everyone admits it
would only bring $8 million in revenue this year – 0.12% of the whole
City budget. Newsom also wants to privatize Jail Health Services –
which he attempted last year – right when the City’s jail population
has declined, and the program’s costs are down $1 million. He says it
would “save” the City $11 million, but no one really knows the figure –
ranges are between $3-$11 million, so a fair estimate would be about $7
million. Combined, these problematic (and permanent) proposals would
net the City $15 million – or 0.228% of the budget, at a time when we
are not making the kind of reasonable cuts elsewhere.

What’s So Bad About Condo Conversions?

This afternoon, the anti-progressive group Plan C will turn out
homeowners to talk about wanting security in their investment – and how
they’re willing to give the City money in these tough times to achieve
it. They are T.I.C. owners, who are sharing a mortgage with neighbors
until their number comes up in the “condo-lottery.” Owning a T.I.C. is
a risky investment – which is why they are cheaper than condos, and a
more affordable path for first-time homeowners. But it’s a risk they
knew precisely what they were getting into.

Here’s the problem. These T.I.C.’s were once rental units – and largely
during the dot-com boom, tenants were evicted under the Ellis Act. The
City’s maximum of 200 condo conversions per year is in place to stem
the erosion of pre-1979 rental housing (all new construction is exempt
from rent control), and to stop rewarding bad behavior. If you are a
T.I.C. owner who genuinely wants to condo convert for the full
“security” of being a homeowner, waiting a few years should not be a
problem. But what the “condo lottery” does is make it harder for real
estate speculators to quickly convert and flip the property.

But didn’t we pass a law
a few years ago that blocks the condo conversion of buildings with an
Ellis Act evictions ? Yes and no. First, only if the eviction happened
prior to November 16, 2004 – and most T.I.C.’s with Ellis evictions
pre-date that time. Second, only if the eviction was of a senior,
disabled or catastrophically ill tenant. Third, real estate speculators
have become very creative since the law passed – offering “buy-outs” to
tenants (which end up being rotten deals) to avoid having an Ellis
recorded on the property. If you’re told there is no defense to an
Ellis and you’re being offered $5,000 to leave, wouldn’t you take it?

A mass-conversion of T.I.C.’s into condominiums will open the floodgate
for real estate speculators – and would only bring $8 million in this
year’s budget. But the details are even worse: T.I.C. owners who want
to convert would pay a fee depending on how long they have been in the
“condo lottery.” If it’s your first year, it would cost $20,000 – and
$4,000 less for each additional year. If you’ve been in the lottery for
five or moe years (i.e., all T.I.C.’s caused by Ellis evictions before
the law changed), you only pay $4,000. In other words, the “worst”
T.I.C. conversions would bring the least revenue to the City.

Progressive Supervisors are unhappy about the Mayor including this as
part of his Budget – because it makes it even harder to save important
social programs they care about. To add insult to injury, Newsom’s
Budget also cuts $125,000 in Ellis Act eviction defense that lawyers at
the Tenderloin Housing Clinic provide – which produces victories like
the Jasper Place tenants in North Beach, who now have peace of mind that they can remain in their home.

What’s So Bad About Privatizing Jail Health Services?

Every year, Mayor Newsom proposes contracting out Jail Health Services
– saying we could save money by replacing the Public Health Nurses who
currently deliver services with a private company. He often cites
Alameda County, which privatized its Jail Health services and spends
less per prisoner – as have other counties and the state prison system.

But showing how it’s done elsewhere only proves the perils of
privatization. The health disparities between inmates in San Francisco
and Alameda County – whose contracted out services have led to
de-skilling nurses’ positions – is staggering. “In order to realize the
‘savings’ of contracting out Jail Health Services,” said Gabriel
Haaland of SEIU 1021 at last week’s Budget Committee, “they would have
to cut nursing staff in half.” There are real health consequences for
the City’s most politically defenseless population.

At his budget speech
on June 1st, Newsom claimed that privatizing Jail Health Services would
“save” the City $11 million a year. Turns out that number is only under
the rosiest of scenarios. The Controller did a study, which showed that
it could save anywhere from $3 to $11 million. Budget Analyst Harvey
Rose has estimated it at around $7 million.

But the timing – as far as budget reasons go – could not be worse. Jail
Health Services expenses are down by $1 million, because of the
declining inmate population. At his presentation to the Budget
Committee, Sheriff Michael Hennessey announced that they have even
temporarily closed two of the small Jail Houses at the San Bruno Jail
site. In other words, calling for this right now in order to save money
doesn’t make much sense.

When the Money Doesn’t Add Up to Much

Sometimes, just because a proposal “saves money” doesn’t make it a good
idea. Just like there are a thousand ways to skin a cat, there’s more
than one way to balance the budget. Mass condo conversions and
privatizing Jail Health Services both add a significant level of risk,
and the “benefit” of money doesn’t add up to much. Combined, the two
would net $15 million – which sounds like a lot, if you don’t know much
about the budget.

But San Francisco’s budget is $6.482 BILLION dollars. In other words,
$15 million is less than one-fourth of one percent. Is that really
worth such a dangerous endeavor? As one Supervisor said recently on a
related topic: “it’s chump change ... it’s decimal dust.”


FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.