SF Board Says 'Yes' to Lennar

Wednesday, July 14, 2010
Zusha Elinson
The Bay Citizen

Lennar's massive waterfront project rolled decisively forward early Wednesday morning.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors approved the environmental
impact report on the big plans for the old Hunters Point Naval
Shipyard, eight to three, after a 10-hour long hearing.

"As I said before, we are at a crossroads today,” said David Chiu, board president, as he cast his vote at around 1:30 a.m.

Coming into the contentious hearing, Chiu was thought to be the
swing vote, but there was no need in the end. Supervisors Chris Daly,
Eric Mar and John Avalos were the only ones to vote against certifying
the report. Daly tried to continue the item, saying, “This is a massive
project with massive impacts with a massive EIR that none of us have
read cover to cover,” but his motion didn't carry.

Lennar plans to build 10,000 homes on the 700-acre site that
includes Candlestick Park should the 49ers stay in San Francisco. It
would transform the southeast side of San Francisco. The shipyard is a
contaminated superfund site that the federal government has spent more
than $700 million on cleaning up.

Environmental and community groups asked the board to reject the
report because of two main concerns: a rush to develop the land before
properly cleaning it up, and a bridge that would disturb the delicate
tidal ecology in the area.

Before the meeting, Chiu had tried to alleviate those concerns by
adding amendments that would give the city more control over the
cleanup process and the design of the bridge. He also proposed
expanding a health clinic in that part of the city. It appeared that
Chiu's amendments helped him win over some progressive supervisors.

At the hearing, hundreds lined up outside the board's chambers to
speak. Environmentalists and community activists spoke out against the
project. Carpenters, pile-drivers and scores of other union members
looking for work came to offer their support. The project has split the
blue-collar Bayview district, where unemployment is high in a
jobs-versus-environment debate.

“I know that young folks want jobs – but I tell you today, not at
the risk of their lives,” said Marie Harrison, a longtime Bayview
activist with environmental justice group Greenaction.

Wilma Subra, an environmental scientist who long has long opposed
the project, warned the board that the report didn't take into account
the “cumulative impact” of an insufficiently cleaned up superfund site.

“Because the community is overburdened and very vulnerable and the
large number of chemicals on site, these people will be heavily
impacted,” said Subra.

She and others also raised concerns about the Navy's proposal to
pave over one of the most contaminated portions with a cap rather than
cleaning it up. Chiu's amendment would call for a hearing this fall at
which those different options would be discussed.

Both the city and the federal Environmental Protection Agency swore
up and down that the land wouldn't be transferred from the Navy to the
city for development before it was cleaned up.

“We're not going to allow any transfer until we know that it's safe
to happen,” said Mark Ripperda, the EPA official in charge of the site.

The other big point of contention has been the bridge planned to be
built over Yosemite Slough. The Sierra Club and other groups claim it
will disturb the wildlife and wetlands. Meanwhile, planners and
business owners said that the bridge would connect the relatively
isolated area to the rest of the city. The status of the bridge was
unclear by the end of the meeting with some supervisors indicating that
there was still room for discussion.

Supervisor Sophie Maxwell, whose district includes the shipyard and
has been the leading proponent for the project, read prepared remarks
sometime after 1 a.m.

"I believe we have both jobs and safety covered,” she said.

Of the supervisors, Daly spoke most vociferously against the
project. He criticized the report for not taking into account the
impacts on gentrification and displacement in the Bayview and Hunters
Point community, which has a large African-American population.

“The ultimate result will be widespread gentrification,” said Daly.

The board is set for a final vote on the project at the beginning of August.

FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: