A November hearing of the San Francisco Fire Commission produced a startling revelation: the Bureau of Fire Prevention has 1,500 complaints without a response.
The 1,800 member San Francisco Fire Department has the power to enforce fire code violations in residential rental properties, and yet, fire safety issues continue to be a problem in San Francisco. It may be hard to believe, but some owners will not even remove impediments to a fire escape drop ladder. Others intentionally padlock escape routes as “security measures.”
Why isn’t the Fire Department more effective in fire code enforcement to protect San Francisco tenants?
No Penalty Hearings
The SF Fire Department lacks an effective penalty process for rental owners who refuse to comply. State and local codes give the Fire Department the authority to issue Notices of Violation and hold penalty hearings, but the Fire Department does not utilize this authority. Fire Department personnel, when they do take action, mostly issue “Notices of Correction” instead, which do not carry the legal weight of a Notice of Violation.
In order for a negligent or scofflaw landlord to be held accountable, state and local codes require a hearing to be held before a penalty can be applied. Currently, no penalty hearings are being held at the Bureau of Fire Prevention.
Furthermore, California state law requires an annual inspection by the Fire Department for all residential rental properties with three or more units. SFFD has delegated these inspections to fire fighters from the engine companies. Only apartment buildings with six or more units, however, currently receive inspections, per SFFD policy.
The fire fighter is supposed to identify violations, but rather than cite the owner, the violation is referred to the Bureau of Fire Prevention. The BFD is supposed to issue notices and initiate code enforcement proceedings, but since there are no penalty hearings, it is hard to see how this can be achieved.
If a fire inspector does not have any means of compelling a negligent landlord to comply with basic fire safety codes, what is the point of he or she coming to work each day? Meanwhile, fire safety issues persist for San Francisco tenants.
No Transparency
The Fire Department does not have on-line access to inspection records. If a person wants to review records and files maintained by the SF Fire Department, one has to make an appointment and go to the Bureau of Fire Prevention at 698 Second Street in person to view these records. The Bureau of Fire Prevention has an imposed limit of two (2) street addresses to be viewed during each appointment.
The Fire Department has an online district map and phone list, but it doesn’t identify or name the district inspector for particular areas of the city, unlike online information from other departments.
Tenants, landlords and community service providers need access to fire inspection records in order to protect themselves, better maintain their properties, or assist clients.
In contrast, the Department of Building Inspection has an on-line complaint tracking system and provides free copies of documents on demand. DBI also responds to tenant complaints within 48 hours and holds penalty hearings every week for tenant habitability issues.
DBI issues Notices of Violation, liens properties with fines, notifies banks and lenders, and initiates litigation through the Building Inspection Commission. The City Attorney’s Office has reported that they do not receive referrals from the SF Fire Department for fire code enforcement litigation.
Some people will say that the Fire Department will never change. But until voters passed Prop G in 1994 creating DBI, people said the same thing about housing inspection for tenant issues at the former Bureau of Building Inspection.
We hear a lot of talk about fire fighters and permissible blood alcohol levels, or subpar ambulance response times. Yet, in the area of fire code enforcement by the San Francisco Fire Department, there are glaring problems that can be solved.
How many tenants must lose their homes before the city addresses them?
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.