S.F. Landlord Evicting Seniors Who Helped Her Ailing Aunt

Friday, August 14, 2015
Heather Knight
San Francisco Chronicle

They may be the three most dreaded words in San Francisco these days, striking fear into the hearts and bank accounts of the two-thirds of city residents who rent.

Ellis Act eviction. You shuddered a little bit, right?

They’re on the rise again after a dip last year, and a particularly interesting court case between a landlord and the North Beach tenants she’s trying to evict is set to begin in San Francisco Superior Court on Monday morning.

On one side is landlord Annlia Paganini Hill, who inherited the property at Stockton and Lombard streets when her aunt, Virginia Paganini, died.

Paganini Hill works for UC Irvine studying people older than 90 — what the university calls “the oldest-old” — and what types of food, activities or other lifestyle choices allow them to reach that age.

As if cribbed from a Lifetime TV movie of the week, Paganini Hill is also — television music soundtrack turns creepy — trying to evict seniors from her aunt’s old building. Seniors who cooked and cared for her ailing aunt when she was in her 90s. A 78-year-old tenant who received an Ellis Act eviction from Paganini Hill died while trying to fight it.

“You couldn’t make this stuff up,” said Sarah Sherburn-Zimmer, an organizer for the Housing Rights Committee of San Francisco.

We’ll say.

“She studies seniors and what makes them live a long time. Having stable relationships, being part of a community and having stable housing are all pieces of that,” Sherburn-Zimmer continued. “To go ahead and evict a whole building of mostly seniors who’ve lived there for years is heartbreaking.”

Paganini Hill didn’t return requests for comment via telephone or e-mail. Her home in Laguna Beach (Orange County) home was the site of a protest by tenant activists last week who strung up a banner reading, “Eviction = Death” from a beach volleyball net. Like Sherburn-Zimmer said, you can’t make this stuff up.

Paganini Hill is being represented by the San Francisco law firm Bornstein & Bornstein. Attorneys there didn’t return requests for comment either.

After her aunt’s death in 2010 and the completion of the probate process, Paganini Hill became the owner in 2012. Her aunt’s old apartment was vacant, of course, and she evicted another tenant, saying she was moving into the unit. Tenants who remain say she never actually moved in. She then served an Ellis Act eviction in 2013 on the remaining four tenants; Elaine Turner died in March, one household left, and two tenants remain and are duking it out with her in court.

Paganini Hill didn’t return requests for comment via telephone or e-mail. Her home in Laguna Beach (Orange County) home was the site of a protest by tenant activists last week who strung up a banner reading, “Eviction = Death” from a beach volleyball net. Like Sherburn-Zimmer said, you can’t make this stuff up.

Paganini Hill is being represented by the San Francisco law firm Bornstein & Bornstein. Attorneys there didn’t return requests for comment either.

After her aunt’s death in 2010 and the completion of the probate process, Paganini Hill became the owner in 2012. Her aunt’s old apartment was vacant, of course, and she evicted another tenant, saying she was moving into the unit. Tenants who remain say she never actually moved in. She then served an Ellis Act eviction in 2013 on the remaining four tenants; Elaine Turner died in March, one household left, and two tenants remain and are duking it out with her in court.

Flandrich has been on waiting lists for low-income housing for two years but has had no luck. She has no plan if she’s evicted.

The other is Silvio Maniscalco, a 68-year-old part-time bartender at Gino and Carlo and grandfather of five who is blind in one eye. (Really, Lifetime has got to be calling by now, right?) He’s lived in the building for 18 years, paying about $800 a month.

Maniscalco called his landlord “greedy” because she inherited the building as well as the rest of her aunt’s estate for free — and is now trying to make even more money. What she plans to do with the building is unknown.

“If you don’t want to be a landlord, sell the building,” he said. “If nobody wants to buy the building because the rents are too cheap, I don’t have that answer. Hang on to the building. I’m going to die soon anyway.”

Flandrich and Maniscalco qualified for a one-year extension on their leases after the Ellis Act eviction notice was served — a benefit available to those older than 62 or who are disabled. (Flandrich was struck by a car shortly before receiving the eviction notice and was temporarily disabled.) Paganini Hill sued them for not moving out after the end of the extension, but the tenants say she made a variety of technical errors in the eviction process.

Steve Collier of the Tenderloin Housing Clinic is representing Flandrich and Maniscalco. He said their defense also includes strong doubts Paganini Hill really intends to leave the rental business, which is the only way an Ellis Act eviction is legal. He said she says she wants the units cleared for when friends visit, but hasn’t been able to name all these visiting friends and that he suspects she really wants to rent the units out through Airbnb or similar hosting sites.

“She has no good reason why she’s evicting all these people,” he said.

Ellis Act evictions spiked 170 percent between 2010 and 2013 as the real estate market in San Francisco took off. They dwindled last year, which housing advocates attribute to uncertainty among landlords about a number of proposals, including an antispeculation tax in San Francisco and tweaks to the Ellis Act in Sacramento. Neither came to fruition, and the controversial evictions are again on the rise.

There were almost no Ellis Act evictions in the city in the fall of 2014, and there were 40 this February alone. There have been 20 to 30 each month since, according to the Anti-Eviction Mapping Project.

Nobody can predict the end of the city’s current story — whether the tech bubble will burst, whether real estate prices will return to semi-reality, and whether evictions will be curbed. But the end of this odd little tale out of North Beach should finally be known soon.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: