Chris Houston was not notified by the San Francisco Planning Department about the large T-Mobile antennas that are soon to be erected on a roof near his bedroom window, and he is now scrambling to do something about it. He is filing for a discretionary review of the project by the planning commission.
Houston and several neighborhood organizations share a fear about the future ability of a San Francisco citizen to challenge such a project because the San Francisco Planning Commission is proposing to do away with the ability of an individual to file for a discretionary review of a proposed construction project near their residence.
Director of Planning John Rahaim said that the commission does not want to spend time reviewing projects that clearly meet the standards that are in place.
The current discretionary review process has paved the way for stalling and settlement agreements that are delaying projects, Rahaim said. Yet, he ensured the Board of Supervisors Land Use and Economic Development Committee that there will still be plenty of engagement with communities.
The initial stage of that community engagement is the issuing of a 311 notice regarding the proposed neighborhood project. But Chris Houston, a resident of the Marina, claims he was never even told about the plan to install T-Mobile antennas near his bedroom window.
Houston is in the process of filing for discretionary review of the project now, but he told the Land Use and Economic Development Committee that the planning commission never researched the T-Mobile project because "they told me they only do that if the building's tall."
Supervisors Eric Mar and David Chiu expressed reservations about the planning commission's proposed changes. Mar has introduced an amendment that would allow citizens to file for a review of a project as long as it is done through the corresponding neighborhood association.
President of the Parkmerced Residents' Organization Daniel Phillips said that the main concern with the planning commission's discretionary review reform is the ability for the commission to raise fees.
"Developers will have cash backing before they make their move," Phillips said. "But affected neighborhoods organizations, which are often ignored in the notification process, will have to bankrupt themselves to pay the new higher fees. It is clearly another effort to exclude citizens from due process."
Chris Houston said he likely would be able to find a neighborhood organization to support his effort to derail the installation of the T-Mobile antennas.
"But what if I could not?" he asked. "Why should that prevent me from having a say in what happens in the community that I live in? It's bad enough that I have to pay $300 dollars just to be heard."
"No, no, no," is what Aaron Goodman of the Parkmerced Residents' Organization urged the supervisors to say to planning commission's proposal. The neighborhood organizations have been fighting against projects that the planning commission should have been handling, Goodman said, and the commission should be automatically reviewing most projects and forcing the sponsors to make changes.
The planning commission maintains that the despite the elimination of the ability of citizens to file discretionary reviews, internal review procedures will be strengthened, and the permit process will be more consistent. Many architects came out in support of the legislation, explaining that the discretionary review process has slowed projects.
The San Francisco Planning Commission, the body that reviews proposed projects to ensure that they meet city guidelines, is made up of seven individuals, three appointed by the Board of Supervisors and four by the mayor.
» E-mail Conor Gallagher @ cgallag2@sfsu.edu
FAIR USE NOTICE. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.