San Francisco Supervisor David Campos said Friday that he will soon push for new development limits in a rapidly gentrifying part of the Mission District, possibly proposing a rare moratorium on market-rate housing projects.
Campos, who represents the Mission, said in the next "few weeks" he will likely propose legislation to add new layers of rules to guide what can be built around the 24th Street BART, or temporarily stop market-rate housing approvals altogether.
Campos plans to craft the proposal based on recommendations from a neighborhood coalition of businesses and residents called Calle 24, which is studying the issue.
In recent months, several developers, including Lennar Multifamily Communitie s and Axis Development Group, have pitched plans to replace warehouses and electricians' shops on the southern edge of the Mission District with hundreds of market-rate housing units. Those announcements have heightened fears that lower income residents will be displaced by rising rents and underscored the lack of new affordable housing getting built near the area.
"There has been discussion of a moratorium, but we don't know what the asks from (Calle 24) will ultimately look like, and we haven't decided what will go forward," Campos said.
The part of the Mission in question extends from Mission Street on the west, Potrero Avenue to the east and 22nd Street to the north and Cesar Chavez Street to the south. Last year, the Board of Supervisors passed a resolution to establish that area as a Latino Cultural District.
Drastic step
"There has been a cry from the community for the last couple years that there is a housing crisis and the projects that are in the pipeline are not responding like it is a crisis," Campos added. "There is a need for more affordable housing to be built."
A moratorium would be a "drastic step," Planning Director John Rahaim said.
It would also be legally hazy. A 2009 Second District Court of Appeal ruling invalidated West Hollywood's temporary prohibition on multifamily housing projects. Even though the city wanted to ensure more affordable housing would get built, it had to prove that it exhausted other options. Also, the city had to demonstrate that development was affecting public health and safety, according to the court decision.
Pro-development groups such as the Residential Builders Association sounded the alarm on a possible moratorium this week in an email to members.
"We ask that any member currently with or considering a project in the Mission District contact the office immediately," the email said.
The organization met with Campos on Friday. The group didn't immediately return a phone call requesting comment. An Axis spokesperson did not return a call for comment and Lennar officials declined to comment.
Possible ripple effect
Tim Colen, who leads the pro-development San Francisco Housing Action Coalition, said a moratorium would also stifle the affordable housing requirements that come with market-rate housing projects.
"We'd be deeply concerned if something were to evolve that restricted production of housing at a time when we need to produce more than ever," Colen said. "The housing affordability crisis and problems with displacement can't be solved if we go toward housing moratoriums."
Campos and Calle 24 are also considering other steps to curb displacement and rent increases.
They could create a special-use district that would impose new regulations to override existing zoning. For example, that could mean that land already zoned for high-density housing would be replaced by zoning rules that impose retail or industrial requirements.
The group could also look to impose interim zoning controls, which could force the Planning Department to add extra layers of review to new projects, like studying how they impact the existing supply of affordable housing. Supervisor Jane Kim pushed for zoning controls on retail along the Mid-Market corridor in 2013, which were eventually adopted.
Condos coming
The area's cultural district designation was "symbolic," but now neighbors want something with "teeth," said Erick Arguello, a member of the Calle 24 council studying potential legislation. He said not only have multifamily developers pitched projects lately, but several property owners are considering demolishing existing retail spaces to build condos.
"I don't think people realize how much development is in such a small area," Arguello said. "We want to make sure it benefits everybody, and it's really truly not benefitting the community right now. It's driving up prices, changing the character of the neighborhood."
He said a special-use district would give the city more time to figure out how to require more affordable housing on projects. About 500 units have approvals from the Planning Department so far, but they have only generated 34 affordable units, according to research by the Council of Community Housing Organizations.
In other parts of the city, like the Central SoMa rezoning area, the Planning Department has signaled that it wants to make below-market housing one-third of all units. That's the goal for the whole city set by November's Prop. K. There is no enforcement mechanism for the goal.
Development anxiety in the Mission is years in the making. It recent years it has been stoked by the influx of white residents in the historically Latino neighborhood. For the first time in at least three decades, the neighborhood saw more white residents moving in than Hispanic residents between 2010 and 2012, according to census data.
Meanwhile, median rents have risen from $2,400 to $3,800 between 2010 and 2014, roughly in line with the citywide median. Multifamily projects that have generated some heated opposition are on the northern edge of the neighborhood, like the 16th Street BART station housing development project by Maximus Real Estate. That project will come up for city approvals this year.
Any type of legislation that Campos proposes isn't a shoe-in to become law if it slows down development. Housing advocates like Supervisor Scott Wiener told the Business Times earlier this month that the Mission housing debates are healthy, but development has mostly been good a good thing for the neighborhood.
"Every neighborhood is unique and is both fragile and resilient, and so is the Mission," Wiener said. "It's surviving and will survive. The Mission has gone through these periods of anxiety for many years."
FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.