A high-end sober-living home has filed suit against West Hollywood,
alleging that the city's attempts to get its clients evicted from nine
apartments discriminate against recovering drug and alcohol users.
In a complaint filed late last month in U.S. District Court in Los
Angeles, KLEAN West Hollywood and its landlords said the city's actions
violate the Americans With Disabilities Act, along with federal and
state fair housing laws and provisions of the U.S. and state
constitutions.
The suit was filed Oct. 28, three months after the city, which is known
for defending the rights of renters, sued the property's owners for
violating an agreement to maintain the apartments as rent-controlled
residential units.
A hearing is scheduled Monday in Los Angeles County Superior Court in
Santa Monica to consider the city's request for an injunction preventing
the owners from allowing the units to be used for short-term stays,
which it says are not permitted under its rent stabilization and zoning
ordinances.
Andrew Spanswick, KLEAN's chief executive, said last week that "the city needs to get its priorities straight."
"Resources that have been spent filing frivolous lawsuits could be much
better spent addressing the rampant drug problem in West Hollywood,"
Spanswick said in a statement Friday.
KLEAN plans to set aside 10% of its beds to provide needed care at no
charge for West Hollywood residents, Spanswick said in an e-mail.
City officials contend that the discrimination suit filed by the home's
operator and landlords is motivated by profit rather than by a desire to
protect disabled people.
"We are not a city that discriminates," said City Atty. Mike Jenkins.
"They have found a way to make a lot of money, and all of this other
nonsense — this highfalutin talk about principle and about
discrimination — it's just a pretext."
The burgeoning business of luxury rehabilitation has caused friction in a
number of California cities, where residents fear such facilities will
lead to declining property values, more crime and congestion.
KLEAN West Hollywood, on a leafy block of Hilldale Avenue, has been
locked in disputes with city officials and some of its neighbors since
it opened last year with plans to become a rehab center.
"I have no objection to it remaining a sober-living place," said Norma
Sandler, who has lived in a nearby apartment for more than 30 years.
"But they don't want to do that. They want to go full-steam ahead and
bring all the addicts in."
KLEAN's attorney, Harry Nelson, accused the city in the statement of
trying "to appease the NIMBY sentiments of a very small group" of
residents.
Spanswick said 14 recovering addicts are living in the apartments, which
are being run as a 24-bed sober-living home with sleek furnishings,
flat-screen TVs and modern art on the walls.
Although KLEAN executives eventually hope to fill 27 beds, they argue
that the location should be considered a residential property because no
more than four people will occupy each apartment. Each will have its
own address. According to state law, sober-living homes and licensed
treatment centers that do not accommodate more than six people are to be
treated as single-family residences.
KLEAN has applied to the California Department of Alcohol and Drug
Programs for licenses to operate seven treatment facilities at the site.
Clients would be charged about $30,000 a month for programs that
typically last two months, according to court documents.
Jenkins said West Hollywood has a critical shortage of affordable
housing, and the units occupied by KLEAN were supposed to be leased as
rent-controlled, permanent residences.
Several years ago, the city learned that the previous owners were using
the apartments as an extension of the adjacent San Vicente Inn and
threatened to take them to court.
The property's new owners settled the dispute in August 2007 by agreeing
to restore the apartments to their original purpose, Jenkins said.
"Now KLEAN is not a person who is residing in the unit and making it their home," he said. "KLEAN is a for-profit business."
KLEAN's clients, he said, check into the facility as part of a recovery program.
"It isn't becoming their home," he said.
An attorney representing the owners, identified in court documents as
852 Hilldale LLC, 850 San Vicente LLC and 845 San Vicente LLC, did not
return calls seeking comment.
According to city court filings, about 80% of West Hollywood residents
are renters. There are 16,576 units covered by the city's rent
stabilization ordinance. The city has lost 452 residential units since
1988, most of them to new development. Another building with 32 units is
being phased out of the residential rental market.
FAIR USE NOTICE. This
document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this
article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of
tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair
use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the
U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes
of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the
copyright owner.