St. Helena Sued Over Affordable Housing

Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Jesse Duarte
Napa Valley Register

Tenants of a Pope Street rental property where numerous code violations were discovered in 2011 are suing the landlords and the city, claiming the city has failed to approve adequate affordable housing.

Eleven former tenants, joined in the suit by Fair Housing Napa Valley and Latinos Unidos del Valle de Napa y Solano, claim the city has failed “to facilitate and permit the development of housing for the region’s low- and moderate-income residents, including the restaurant workers, spa and hotel workers, and farmworkers who power the industries that make the city a popular destination for tourists.”

Latinos Unidos is a group associated with attorney David Grabill, an affordable housing advocate who’s also sued Napa County and the city of Napa. In addition to Grabill, the plaintiffs are represented by attorneys from Brancart & Brancart, a Pescadero firm, and California Rural Legal Assistance.

The suit claims the city’s failure to provide that housing has resulted in “grossly substandard living conditions for low-income renters” such as those who were forced to vacate the Barbarino property after the city declared their living quarters unsafe and illegal in November 2011.

The suit, filed Nov. 13 in federal court, accuses the Barbarinos and the city of violating the plaintiffs’ civil rights and discriminating against them based on their race. All 11 of the former Barbarino tenants who are party to the suit are Latino.

City Manager Gary Broad said, “It’s a shame we will have to divert scarce public funds to pay attorneys that could otherwise be used for community services, including working to provide affordable housing. We are confident that we have fully satisfied all our affordable housing obligations.”

Along with the city, the suit names property owner Grazia Barbarino, her husband Corrado and their son Manuel. The Barbarinos did not respond to a note left at their door on Tuesday.

City accused of discrimination

The suit seeks damages and court injunctions “requiring defendants … to take affirmative action to provide equal housing opportunities to all regardless of national origin, race and color.”

The suit faults the City Council for failing to support potential affordable housing projects at the Romero property on Pope Street (where the nonprofit developer Mercy Housing abandoned a project in 2011), and the city-owned property at the corner of Adams Street and Library Lane (for which the City Council issued a request for proposals in 2011, then rejected all the responses).

According to the suit, the city’s actions amount to discrimination “because the developments are intended for occupancy by persons or families of very low, low, moderate or middle incomes.” The city’s “denial of numerous residential developments” should be rendered “null and void” by the court, the suit argues.

The suit criticizes the council for disbanding a Housing Committee that supported the development of affordable housing.

It also attacks the city for failing to meet its regional housing allocation, which required the city to plan for 76 affordable housing units between 2007 and 2014, and for failing to implement the Housing Element of its General Plan. Only one affordable housing unit has been built in the city since 2005, but another 10 will be available next year as part of the first phase of the Magnolia Oaks project.

Suit: City ‘complicit’ in violations

Inspections of the rental units revealed a host of code violations, including leaky roofs, windows and doors, exposed wiring, inadequate lighting, a lack of heating, lack of wheelchair access for a disabled tenant, lack of adequate fire exits, and an interior window that looked into a neighboring unit.

The city red-tagged the six illegal units in November 2011, after receiving a tip from Fair Housing Napa Valley, which in turn had been notified by a tenant’s relative and a Head Start worker who had visited the property.

However, the suit claims the city was “complicit” in the violations because officials knew about problems on the property as far back as 1993, when the city issued a “declaration of substandard building and possible demolition proceedings” for 1105 Pope St. The suit claims the city failed to conduct inspections before certifying that the property was up to code in 1995.

According to the suit, the city was notified of tenant complaints in 2005, 2008 and 2010, when a St. Helena police officer left a message with the Planning and Building Department reporting substandard conditions and adding, “I heard that there is a lot of history including flooding, etc.”

The 2005 and 2010 complaints didn’t result in any repairs, and the police officer’s report didn’t even lead to an inspection, the suit claims.

Following the 2008 complaint, the city sent a letter telling the Barbarinos to carry out repairs. When a second inspection found there were still unresolved problems and discovered that some of the units had been built illegally, the city failed to follow up, the suit alleges.

The suit also claims that after the city red-tagged the units in 2011, Grazia Barbarino threatened to report the plaintiffs to immigration authorities, while Corrado Barbarino blamed the situation on one of the plaintiffs and used a racial slur based on the tenant’s Guatemalan origin.

According to the suit, the Barbarino tenants paid between $600 and $950 a month, well below the city’s median monthly rent of $2,250.

According to the 2010 census, 32 percent of the St. Helena population is Latino and 77 percent is white.

FAIR USE NOTICE. Tenants Together is not the author of this article and the posting of this document does not imply any endorsement of the content by Tenants Together. This document may contain copyrighted material the use of which may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Tenants Together is making this article available on our website in an effort to advance the understanding of tenant rights issues in California. We believe that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Law. If you wish to use this copyrighted material for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use,' you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

Help build power for renters' rights: